ABOUT TEST PATTERN

Don't touch that dial: Test Pattern tunes into television, movie, music and pop culture links, as well as gossip and idle chat from around the Web.

Every week, msnbc.com entertainment producers Gael Fashingbauer Cooper, Denise Hazlick, Paige Newman, Kurt Schlosser and Anna Chan weigh in on topics ranging from TV commercials to movie hype to the latest celebrity blunder. We're not ashamed to admit our love for bad TV or reveal what's on our iPods, and invite you to join the conversation via your comments.



Trouble on the set

Posted: Wednesday, January 24, 2007 3:32 PM by Gael Fashingbauer Cooper
Filed Under:

It's not that viewers are dumb enough to assume that "Grey's Anatomy's" on-screen relationships are real, but still, it has been jolting to read that Isaiah Washington used a homophobic slur to refer to cast member T. R. Knight, sparking a fight with fellow castmate Patrick Dempsey. And then things only got weirder.

After the Golden Globes, Washington denied using the slur yet managed to say it again. Knight went on "The Ellen DeGeneres Show" and contradicted Washington. Quite a leap from how the actors' characters relate to each other -- Washington's Dr. Preston Burke and Knight's Dr. George O'Malley developed a fun friendship on-screen and even shared an apartment for a time.

And now today's news reports that Washington is seeking counseling to understand what's behind his homophobic remarks. Reading between the lines, it would seem that ABC has mandated the counseling, trying to salvage its hit show.

And the natural question, however facetious, is: How exactly does one receive counseling for homophobia? Simple therapy? "Will and Grace" marathons? Roundtable sessions with the cast of "Queer Eye for the Straight Guy"?

Washington's terse statement notes that he regards the counseling as necessary to understand his own actions and that he appreciates the opportunity. As he should: Imagine what would happen to you or I if we used these slurs towards a co-worker while at work. We would have been fired yesterday.

And it's hard not to group Washington's actions in with those of Mel Gibson and Michael Richards, who infamously lashed out against Jews and African-Americans, respectively.

We're not naive enough to think that racism, anti-Semitism and homophobia aren't out there -- we see them every day. But often they're hidden. Celebrities especially can get away with a lot of bad behavior, but spouting off at work? To a cop? To an entire comedy club full of people? That takes prejudice and wraps it in a weird self-destructive blanket, as if the men in question really want to bring themselves down.

It would be nice if every workplace operated like the fictional Seattle Grace Hospital, where people are judged, as Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. said, by the content of their character, not their skin, religion, gender or sexuality. But we're not there yet and we likely never will be.

 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I love this show but when I first heard of the fight and the derogatory remark directed at "George" by Washington, Dr Burke quickly became known in our household as Dr. Jerk. Hope the therapy helps but the damage has already been done - ala Richards and Gibson. It also makes me wonder how long an actor would remain on a show if he had used the "N" word toward a castmate...???
Why are Washington's remarks being called 'homophobic'? Just because he used a slur, one shouldn't assume that he is afraid of homosexuals as the word homophobic implies. Why isn't Mel Gibson 'semiphobic'? Is Micheal Richards 'Afro-Ameriphobic? Use the right words. Don't editorailize by assumptions of Washington's issues. Calling Washington 'homophobic' shows how biased our 'conservaphobic' and 'moralphobic' media is. Ridiculous PC-ness. Washington is wrong to slur. That doesn't necessarily make him afraid.
The whole going into rehab thing is getting very tired very fast. How can this be a qucik fix for everything, and how can someone be 'rehabed' for something that was not debilitating to start with. Take Miss USA, who really thinks she had a consuming drinking problem? Of course she did not, shes a young, beautiful girl who liked to have fun. Too bad she was in the spotlight. But since she agreed to go to rehab she got to keep her crown. She is not a cured alcoholic, no more that Washington will be a cured homophobe. If people continue to be let off the hook by going to rehab, there will be more incidences of problematic behaviours, becase people are seeing that they can do whatever they want as long as they go to 'the spa' for a week.
Oh come on. Stop being so negative. Yes, prejudice is out there, yes it always will be, that's the nature of people. But to say we will NEVER be able to judge people by their character is just not giving us enough credit. And I must say that it always surprises me that the very people who want to be treated equally and without bias are the ones who are the most judgmental. It's sad.
What happened to the first amendment? Are the American people no longer allowed to have opinions and are we not allowed to defend our opinions? We are fast becoming a nation where the people have no rights because minorties rule.
I don't believe he did this one his own, I think he was given a choice to either go in to counseling or lose his job. But, everyone deserves a second chance and maybe he will learn something out of his counseling sessions. It is very sad because it totally humilitated and hurt T.R., very deeply, and that is the real issue. We live in a world where unfortunatly we all have it in us to sterotype people, but to say it outloud particularly in the work place is unacceptable. I know I would be fired if I made any type of racial slur at work, and rightfully so. All types of racial and sterotypical slurs are hateful and only breed more hate and animosity. When you are in the public eye you do have a responsibility to behave yourself. I don't want to bash the guy, he made a very big mistake, and then tried to deny it on public television to stir up the pot. If he needed to say something that night it should have been I'm sorry, or kept his mouth shut...Which I am sure he now he highly regrets. It took away from the the high honor award the show won that night. I am sure he feels bad about it now and wishes he could take it back. I hope he does anyway. Unfortunatly, that can't happen and he will forever be remembered as that guy who called someone a faggot on national TV. And, that is unfortunate too, because we all make stupid mistakes, and deserve to be forgiven. We are all guilty of saying hateful things at some point in our lives, and anyone who cannot admit that is lying. I think it's being handeled, the show is great, he is a great actor, and we should all move on now that he has accepted responsibility for his actions and is taking steps to correct it.
This whole brou-ha-ha is laughable....has anyone heard of freedom of speech. Mr. Washington should have limited himself to slandering white men and those we consider "white trash"....then everyone would laugh and he'd be cool. These hypocrites are so annoying. But there is no question all this "political correctness" crap (should be pronounced "lie") will disaapear. It is just a total waste of time. Rupert Everett who is not "Richards Simmons" gay but out of the closet has the only intelligent comment I have read. He said in effect....."Who cares if someone calls me a f**? I prefer that to his lying to me or pretending to be something he's not. Anyway, who cares?"
Freedom of speech is one thing. Using racial or other slurs to demean someone is another. I will fight to the death someone's ability to speak freely but I will not defend them if that speech is designed just to be hurtful to another. It is not being "PC" it is being respectful to others. Something most of us learned in Kindergarten. I saw the cast on the Oprah show recently and when the incident was discussed there was no mention by anyone of the slur - only that Dempsey and Washington had gotten into a fight - and they had made up and were now best buddies. The whole segment dealt with the mended relationshsip between those two and no one ever mention how TR was hurt by this incident - or how the fight escalated when Washington called TR a "faggot". It was like the elephant in the room and they all danced around it. I do think Washington has some issues with gays - not fear or "homophobia" but issues - that he needs to deal with. It was obvious from that Oprah segment that he was more concerned with mending his relationship with Dempsey than with TR.
It's amazing to me that people won't even say the "N" word on TV or type it but people seem to be able to say/type faggot or white trash. YEs we have freedom of speech but that freedom does not give us the right to trash somebody else's freedom. I think Mr. Washington should be fired, I think for once an actor should be held up and be made to face the same treatment that us "common" people have to face. Rehab! please. Does anybody honestly believe that any of us would be given the chance for rehab then come back to our jobs. It's hard to beleive a man is truly sorry for saying that, when he stood right there in front of the very people who originally heard it and said he never said it. Now that we all heard him say it, now he's saying oh sorry I need help. Please give me break.
This is just retarded, OOPS! I said something not PC, I guess I better head to rehab. It is unbelievable to me that anything he said warrants the type of publicity that it has received, much less counseling. What if he'd called him fat? Would that be ok? Or ugly? Or stupid? What next? Give me a break.
All very intresting-----------If I am correct (and I am) We are told in the Bible to "Love thy neighbor" NO Where does it say "Unless" or Until" I just think its' a shame that with everything going on in this world people have nothing else to do but hurt another person. Who cares what color/race/sexual pref etc... Really now, should we not focus on being kind to one another. And yes, I do beleive that he should get some pro. help. Those that slam others tend to have bigger issues that have to be worked on. I venture to say that learning why he felt it was okay to say the things he said will help him deal with other issues I feel certain he has with other asspects in his life.
Isaiah's character can be given to another actor to protray. Leaving Isaiah in the cast sends a message to T.R. that he really does not matter to the powers-that-be. What I want to know is, "Why punish the good guy..."
As children, we were taught to ignore negative names from other children. (sticks and stones may break my bones but names will never hurt me) As adults, we have all kinds of problems when a slur is hurled around. Groups who were not even in the room when a word was used get their time in the spotlight to air their outrage. Why are we teaching our kids to ignore this stuff when the adults can't let it go? The PC movement is getting ridiculous. The fact that Washington had to meed with GLAAD reps to get his spanking seemed so silly and sanctimonious. So he said something stupid, let him stand there looking stupid. Isn't there anything else going on in the world that deserves more attention than this?
When well it ever be enough. So many people say things that are inappropriate but they do not go to therapy for it. Whenever someone "famous" says or does society does not think is right we have to hear about it over and over again. So he did or did not call someone a name. Who cares. If you don't agree like Mr. Washington turn off your televison, don't watch the show, but enough already. And while we are at it, to all you people working in fast food complaining about K-Fed's new commercial, it is a COMMERCIAL about car insurance, nothing more nothing less. GET OVER IT!!
Both Washington and White should be fired. Washington for not keeping his thoughts to himself and White because he is not able to portray his character as a straight guy. It has become a joke to see him kissing a female and trying to be masculine. He has lost his credibility as "George".
Carolyn - does that mean they should fire the whole cast since none of them are surgeons in real life?? Should they only hire real murderers to play psychopaths on CSI since if they are not REALLY evil then they lose all credibility? Puhlease. And as an FYI - not all gay men are effiminate.
If Knight had called Washington the n-word, he would have been fired immediately. Al Sharpton and Jessie Jackson would have flown in to make sure it happened. Would that have been freedom of speech? Would the outcry stop? Not until Knight's career was ruined. Washington needs to be fired. It would be so easy to write him off with the hand problems his character is having now on the show. He (and anyone else) needs to be held accountable for what comes out of your mouth. Something we learned in kindergarten. Washington needs to understand that he isn't that great of an actor and that he can and should be easily replaced. Then maybe his large ego could deflate just a bit and instead of a rehab he doesn't need he could find a job in another field. Something where he doesn't have to work with others.
All of these poor, maligned actors are just players in fictional telecasts. There's no story here - except how we look for meaning in the meaningless. Come on, people - we got War in Iraq, child molesters on every corner, Genocide in Darfur, killers in schools and you have nothing better to get upset about than the ravings of a few Hollywood actors. Get a life - really. Get a life.
I total disagree with the comment about "White", which I take to mean T.R. Knight, being fired. I have absolutely no trouble believing George is straight and having a romance with a woman -- in fact, George and Callie's romance is probably my favorite. It sounds like Carolyn has a problem separating fact from fiction.
In response to Caryolyn from Medon, TN.... perhaps "White" should be fired, that way T.R. Knight can keep his job....since he is an awesome "George." :)
I don't agree with Washington's remarks. Nor do I agree with Mel Gibson's or Michael Richard's. However, this is America. And we do have freedom of speech. That's what makes this country so different. I can say whatever I want, whenever I want, to whomever I want. America was built so that one would not be persecuted for every minor infraction. And it is sad to see that is no longer so. Yes, the words were wrong and yes, the speakers hurt someone else's feelings. But when was it against the law to hurt someone's feelings? People need to get tougher skin. We are building a nation full of cry-babies and whiners. So someone talked bad about you. Does that make it true? Does that change who you are? We should learn that the only opinion that matters is the one we have of ourselves. Once everyone accepts that as truth, someone spouting off unintelligible slurs will only show their ignorance. It is their character and image that suffers the greatest blow.
The speculation of what would have happened if the N word was instead used is useless. Who knows? Who cares? Use of any derogatory word, no matter who it is directed toward is wrong. Although everyone would like to think that if the same situation were to happen at their work someone would be fired, I know from experience that, especially in larger corporations, things are definitely hushed and actions are not taken. Mr. Washington has offended his co-workers and many others with his ignorance However, I would be willing to bet that there are many more people in the public that, sadly, are equally as ignorant as he. He should be held to no higher regard just because he is on a TV show. He is no smarter for being on TV, he is not necessarily better educated just because he is on TV, he doesn't have a different background just because he is now on TV . . . Why are we shocked and appalled at his actions, and not the actions of hate crimes, rampant racism, homophobia, and ignorance that happen every second in this country and others?
Had TR Knight (or any other cast member) brandished the N-word toward Washington, would he be okay with the name-caller going to "rehab" to get over their racism.
Carolyn in Medon, TN... are you saying TR Knight should be fired because he is gay? I do not see the character any differently now that Knight is out of the closet. Should they have fired Eric McCormick for being straight (playing gay) on Will & Grace? The actor and the character are two different people.
Why is this being blown out of proportion. He called the person what he felt. Was it wrong, yes because disrespect is just that. However, he has the right to feel the way he does. His appology should be enough. Why counseling?
Wow. Some of the above comments weren't particularly well-informed, but Carolyn's takes the cake. What definition of masculinity are you using in evaluating an actor's performance as a heterosexual? Is that in the "Rudolph Valentino must have been gay because he wore nice clothes" category? Laughable. Washington's comments were unfortunate and insensitive, and it is too bad that discrimination against gays is still in many ways the only widely accepted form of discrimination in our society today (not that the others don't exist; they're just less tollerated by, say, the general media). Even still, the situation has crossed over the threshold into hysteria. Sometimes, by choosing the wrong battles, you run the risk of not being taken seriously.
Who cares what the Gay rights people think. They have the right to live thier life in a gay relationship and I have my right to think it's wrong! I like the show and what any actor thinks does not influence me at all.
To: Carolyn, Medon, TN I believe you meant T.R. KNIGHT. I don't see what the problem is with him playing a straight character. After all, this is only a character and he is an actor. There are many heterosexual actors who play homosexual characters. I don't see a problem with that. They are required, as actors, to portray a character according to the storyline or script of a tv show or movie. And if they do a good job it shouldn't matter what their actual sexual orientation is.
I have been a pre-school teacher for several years. I am responding to the writer who cannot understand why adults become so upset at slurs, yet children are taught to grin and bear it. This is not the whole picture. A child who is treated cruelly by others may be counseled to be strong and ignore name-callers, but that does not mean they are not deeply hurt. They are being taught coping skills to deal with painful experiences. However, the child who has struck out verbally at another is also counseled to understand how damaging the verbal abuse is to the other person. There are two sides to every coin. It is important to teach children not to allow themselves to be victimized. It is equally important to teach aggressors to try to understand the consequences of their behavior, or at the very least, to dial down their behavior .
Oh please, everyone get over it! Why are we bashing Washington but nobody says a word about Rosie O'Donnell for CONSTANTLY bashing people and sticking her big nose into other people's business? Say your sorry Washington and let's be done with it. We, as a country, spend way to much time worrying about what we are calling each other instead lets worry about Iraq, our troops, our children, our land, our economy. At the end of the day, what is important? A stupid comment that simply needs an apology to ONE person or how we are affected by the bigger things in life???
I despise this show and my hope is that this incident is the first sign of an implosion that will eradicate it from TV land forever. Isiah Washington is simply an idiot for bringing the incident up again in such a public manner -- it had pretty much blown over before he mentioned it again.
Kaye Ronning, Lakeville, MN: I lot of us do bash Rosie for her constant bashing of people. A lot of us think that she's part of the problem.
In response to an earlier comment. So basically you're saying its okay to call "minorities" any slur because they are "minorities"??? Plain and simple. He did say that word. Who cares if it was "PC" or not. But he said it. He is an adult, he should know to respect ANY kind of person. He should've been a professional and when asked the question at GGB he should've just said that "it was dealt with and we have moved on thank you." But he got stupid and blurted it out on national TV. The fact that he is going to rehab is not gonna help one bit. He should be talking to the person he hurt, 'cause rehab is not gonna change the way he thinks. This whole incident is just gonna teach him a lesson.
Speaking as a gay man I just wanted to say that it is NOT free speech when words that degrade and hurt people are used. I would never use the N word for MR. Washington no matter what he may say or do,nor would I use any degrading words for anyone who may be different from me. America has to remember that free speech does not give you the right to say what ever you may want whenever you want. I too would fight to the death your right to free speech but not your right to use words that hurt. There are many ways to use free specch without making anyone feel that they are less a person then they are.
I think that this is another one of those cases where the gay groups are just waiting for an opportunity to bash someone that doesn't agree with them. I personaly believe that being gay is an abomination and I'm not afraid to say so. If they don't agree, too bad.
You know it is a good show, and both men are great at what they do. Why do we as people have to judge everything that goes on. I don't care if they are black. gay or green. It is for enjoyment. If Washington said this you should not have if T.R. is gay good for him. Be proud of what you do each week keep entertaining us and stop all this ya yaing. Everyone keeps talking about the effect this has on them and what they were taught as children. Well I was taught the bigger man walks away. I hope this ends soon and we can just go back to enjoying a really good show.
the very thread of our society is at stake here! what happen to our morals and role models America? Freedom of speech ok, but at the expense of somebodies feelings?? What does it mean to be human today? Whether or not it's a Actor or not,and it seems lately there's a lot of Actors making these slurs.. wrong is wrong. He should be fired. Any other job, he would be terminated for harrassment and a bunch of other things. It's very sad to see that it's 2007 and we still live in the dark.
To think this person is someone we watch every week!! I was saddend to hear a remark,from a person who portrays compassion and caring in front of how many millions of adoring fans. It really is sad to see some one that gets paid as much as he does,&cant spend some money on getting better educated.He is after all of a afroamerican so really he should know better on being a bigot come on, would it be different if someone called him a racial slur or judged on his way of life. Which cant be too great if he needed to cheep shot someone he has to see on a regular basis, Also to put cast mates in a very uncomfortable state, working together and all.
Please give me a break actors and actress use derogatory remarks all them time. I have heard them used in comedy and movies. from some of the biggest well known stars. If that is ok, what's the big deal that washington said it. people can be so contradictory. If you don't want people to say it then don't portray it to be ok for any reason.
Why don't you all listen and try to understand what gay people have to say about this remark. If you are not in their shoes how do you know what it feels like? Gays have always been at the bottom of the barrel - hello you all vote on our personal lives each year. And we all pay the same taxes - but maybe I'm being to sensitive - or very gay.
In case anyone has not heard, the word this man used is very emotionally charged and historically based. During the Inquisition, they would throw people being suspected of homosexuality on top of the fires they were using to burn witches at the stake. They called them "faggots," referring to sticks of wood, or kindling. This was a very barbaric and torturous practice and to call someone this name is to condone and welcome the idea. For me, it's one of the worst words out there, along with the N word, which I am sure this actor would have been incensed at hearing himself referred to as. This is not a matter of free speech. This is hate speech, and it is time to recognize it and rise above it, not condone it. It's not about being politically correct, it is about inclusion and acceptance. This world needs some of that in a ba way!
In 3 jaar tijd afkomen van je schulden


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://testpattern.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=41014