ABOUT TEST PATTERN

Don't touch that dial: Test Pattern tunes into television, movie, music and pop culture links, as well as gossip and idle chat from around the Web.

Every week, msnbc.com entertainment producers Gael Fashingbauer Cooper, Denise Hazlick, Paige Newman, Kurt Schlosser and Anna Chan weigh in on topics ranging from TV commercials to movie hype to the latest celebrity blunder. We're not ashamed to admit our love for bad TV or reveal what's on our iPods, and invite you to join the conversation via your comments.



Brandy's car accident

Posted: Monday, January 29, 2007 3:07 PM by Gael Fashingbauer Cooper

I can't stop thinking about the horrible crash singer Brandy reportedly caused.

According to reports, the tiny singer was driving a Land Rover on the 405 in L.A.. Traffic slowed and stopped; she did not, say reports. Her car apparently pushed a Honda into another car, the Honda then hit a center divider, and then was hit by yet another car. Awatef Aboudihaj, 38, was in the car hit by the Land Rover, and was killed. TMZ.com has put photos of the cars online, and it makes my heart sink to look at how Aboudihaj's car door is smashed in. Airbags, seat belts, nothing was going to save that driver.

The news is sickening because it's easy to imagine yourself in the situation. A friend and his pregnant wife were recently stopped at a traffic light and were hit by a car and pushed into the car in front of them. My friend's wife saw the crash coming and could do nothing but sit helplessly and brace for impact. Thankfully, both of them and the baby are OK, although their three-week-old car was totaled.

A year ago, my husband and I were stopped in heavy traffic when a pickup truck failed to stop, smashed into the car in front of it, pushing that car into us and our car into the car in front of us. Four cars headed to the shop, four carloads of people jolted (again, thankfully, no one was seriously hurt) -- all because someone apparently wasn't paying attention to the road.

We don't know if Brandy, or any of the drivers in the other accidents, were using cell phones or were distracted by any of the many gadgets now in today's cars -- DVD players, GPS units, built-in computers. But we've all been driving and seen distracted drivers doing everything from reading newspapers to yakking on the phone to applying mascara to eating giant meals. It's gotten so bad where I live, in Seattle, that I have a little game I play. If a nearby driver is in some way driving recklessly, I look for a phone. 90 percent of the time I can also see that the bad driver also has a small phone shoved up to his or her ear. (Note to commenter Kim: I'm a passenger when I play this game, not the driver.)

I'm not against gadgets, don't get me wrong. As a woman who sometimes has to drive alone, I'm happy to have the security of a cell phone in my purse, especially at night. Phones, DVD players, these are all useful appliances. Used safely, they won't kill anyone -- it seems ridiculous to even have to say that, but there it is.

I saw Brandy last summer at the TV Critics' Association meeting in Pasadena, when she was on a panel for "America's Got Talent." She seemed so tiny, and so young, and even a little bit shy, trying to gamely parry and joke with fellow "Talent" judge David Hasselhoff. And while I can't stop thinking of the woman who died and her poor family, I can also too easily imagine what it would be like to be Brandy at this time. How does she live with herself? How does she ever drive a car again? This is no TV show, no Hollywood movie, there are no retakes. Nothing she does can ever bring Awatef Aboudihaj back to her family.

Something distracted Brandy -- maybe not a phone, maybe just something she saw out of the corner of her eye, maybe something she was thinking about, maybe the glinting L.A. sun -- but for a time, she apparently was not focusing on piloting her vehicle, and she, and the drivers around her, paid a horrible price.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Brandy's MVA is naother instance of an spoiled, self indulgent ego living life large and not appropriately cognizant of the ramifications of her actions as the rest of us have to be. Total lack of responsibility. How can a little 90 lb thing even handle a monsterous sized SUV?
Accidents are called that for a reason. I'm sure she didn't have a mind set to hit the other car. I'm sure she is just like others who have had accidents due to their careless attitude. The only reason she is being looked at in the light is because of her career.. would you be saying she is spoiled rotten if it had been just the casual "90" pound Jane Doe... I don't think so.
police are saying brandy needs to be charged only becasue of who she is she didnt head out the day to kill anyone
Wow, dfluff62. Dislike celebrities, do you? This sounds like an accident that unfortunately occurs everyday. Being a celebrity and weighing 90 lbs has nothing to do with. I agree with Sonya.
Perhaps she was playing this game, where she was looking at another driver, and was looking for their phone? Unfortunately, our senses are distracted by many things while behind the wheel. I almost rear ended someone once because I was distracted, simply because I checked my rearview mirror a second too long. My prayers are with everyone involved in this accident. It really could be any of us in this situation.
To dfluff62: For God's sake, have you never heard of power steering, power brakes, and adjustable seats?. Almost any adult can drive almost any modern vehicle safely, from a Geo Metro to a Boeing 747 Jumbo Jet. Physical size, and strength mean very little, unless you are very small (or a child), and that is only a question of reach, not ability. I have had a similar accident, (thankfully no one was hurt) and I know how fast, and unexpected they can be. Someone pulled into my lane taking my safety space, and while I was applying the brakes to get more space the 15 cars ahead of him stopped in the middle of the freeway to look at a police officer giving someone a ticket. There was nothing I could do, with no safety space there was no time to stop. Had the sun gotton into my eyes, or had I been distracted at that moment, the accident could easily have turned out much worse. I could have been in Brandy's position right now. Of course, no one would be talking about my accident because I am a nobody. Brandy is a public figure, and as such gets way too much attention from people who need to get a life. My sympathy is with Brandy, and all the other people who were caught up in this tragic incedent.
I see many small women driving big honking SUVs and really don't know how to handle them. And often times, someone driving those size of vehicles, just gotta be yakking away on a cell.
Okay, so Brandy caused an accident because for some reason she wasn't in control of her vehicle. BUT the vehicle that crashed into the same car she crashed into is responsible for the demise of the driver. Had THAT driver been paying attention, it would not have it the car, causing the death of the driver. Brandy is considered 'deep pockets' - she's a celebrity of sorts, so it's going to be uglier for her than the driver of the car who actually caused the fatality. You don't see that anywhere.
This has just been a very unfortunate accident which could have been caused by anybody for any reason. Jail time for her....not necessarily due to the circumstances but heavy fines, losing driving privledges, helping out the family....yes and she can afford to help them out very, very much and for a very long time. Not everybody who causes an accident like this is sent to jail and she shouldn't be either, and no not because she is a celebrity but because she is human and made a mistake. It's not like she did this on purpose.
In reference to sonya's comment. If it was an average 90lb jane doe then it probably would be an accident, but when you have celebrities, they dont consider themself average. They think they live above the law and sadly sometimes they do. But in this case she felt invincable and someone had to pay the price.
Everybody gets into car crashes...it may have been brandys fault but the way the driver handled its actions was on them... i mean the driver didnt need to hit the center divide and what about the other driver that struck her? Brandy may have been at fault but I cant help but think of the other drivers were also. Its just a bad situation for everybody and it is very unfortunate. Everybody needs to stop making a big deal of this Im sure she is going through enough as it is, let her be for god sakes.
Is Brandy a licensed driver? Did she take all of the tests necessary to acquire her license? If so, then she is (or should be) well aware of the responsibilities she has as a licensed driver. She is also a citizen, and as such, is subject to the laws of the state where she was. She should be subject to the same detailed scrutiny as we all should be in a case such as this, causing the death of another person, unless you suggest that some people be treated differently than others. I say, let her take her lumps, just like any other person would. If she is found to be negligent in her actions, or it is found that she was careless in the manner she chose to drive, then she should be prosecuted, just like the rest of us might be. For far too long, "celebrity" has offered the opportunity for various "mishaps" to be forgiven. I call BS on that, and hope that the proper authorities investigate completely, and do the right thing at the end of that investigation, whether it be prosecution or not.
And while we're at it, was she taken for drug and alcohol tests, like any of us would be? If not, I smell a cover-up. It is a shame that someone died in this "accident". It is obvious that the deceased woman's car was hit by Brandy's vehicle at a high rate of speed. Did she try to brake? If not, why not? There is only one excuse that would pass muster: That the brake lights on the car that Brandy hit were not working. Brandy was responsible for keeping a safe distance between her vehicle and the vehicle in front of her. If I remember right, the driver who hits another driver from behind is the one who is responsible for the accident, in almost any circumstance. I feel sorry for all those involved, especially the woman who died. Common decency would result in the person who caused all this to take responsibility.
A lot of people are charged for causing fatal accidents. The only difference is that when no celebrity is involved it doesn't make the news. She should be treated like anyone else. It's likely that she wouldn't even serve jail time if convicted - probably just probation and community service, maybe a fine.
I was in an accident; it was my fault. Thankfully, no one died or was injured, but if you ask me what happened, I can't tell you. I thought I was paying attention, that I was fully focused on the road. There was no phone to my ear, no mascara wand in my hand, no coffee to my lips. The point is this: no one, not even the affluent, are exempt from mistakes. We should try to show empathy for all parties involved directly & indirectly. As ubiquitous as SUVs are in the USA, this accident could have been caused by anyone. And in this particular situation where a life was lost, we should realize that the party responsible will be held rightfully accountable despite their social distinction.
How can a car stopped in traffic be at fault when another driver hits them? The person who started the chain is usually at fault, though there are exceptions (read Timothy's post above). You can't say that the other person is at fault for being in your way, or for not stopping their car from hitting others. Even if your foot is firmly pressing on the break, your car will slide when hit from behind at even moderate speeds. I agree that this particular incident is getting blown way out of porportion because Brandy is a celebrity, but hopefully all the publicity will serve to remind people that this can happen to anyone. You, as a driver, are not just responsible for the saftey of yourself and those in your car, but also for others in other vehicles. I find it interesting that this comes at a time where we have several insurance company commercials (I'm mainly thinking of Allstate) which point out the dangers of distracted driving.
In response to Stephon; how do you know what Brandy was thinking at the moment of the accident? Why are you lumping her in with the "bad" category of celebrities? The vast majority of celebrities are not like the Paris Hiltons and Britney Spears' of the world; they live their lives in (relative) anonymity when they aren't doing something in the spotlight. Brandy is like that; she's never caused major scandals or been involved in one that I know of, and aside from what she's done in the past, she has lived very low-profile for a "celebrity". I have to agree with Rowan above; the driver who hit the car Brandy hit last was likely the cause of the driver's death, not Brandy herself. Did she spark the event that caused it? Certainly; but that doesn't excuse the other drivers that hit the car either. If we're going to place blame, we need to put it on ALL the drivers who hit that poor woman's car, not just Brandy.
She does not deserve to go to jail, in my opinion. It was an accident, we all take our lives into our hands when we get into a vehicle. She should have to pay the appropriate fines and perhaps lose her license for a period of time (she should NOT receive any special treatment), but jail time, no, everyone in this country gets so carried away with things. It is a terrible tragedy and I understand people not wanting her to get special attention but, the constant attention being spent on this is giving her special treatment. People die in automobile accidents everyday and I bet most of you do not pay those stories any attention.
I've seen those kinds of things happen in LA far too often. You're barreling along, keeping up with traffic, when all of a sudden - you have to come to a complete stop. Even a good driver has trouble with that. Crazy.
It's pretty pathetic that some of those people get away with a lot because they are a celebrity or a pro sports player. If they were not paying attention to what they were doing, then they need to be charged the same way as if a regular person would have been charged, the free rides those people get should come to and end.
Apparently, Bam Margera has taken distracted driving to a really disturbing extreme. http://www.radaronline.com/exclusives/2007/01/mtv-stars-drivers-education.php (Consider this a content warning.)
When you hit a stopped car from behind, 99.9% of the time, it is YOUR fault. It really is that simple.
I think that everyone who has posted so far is under the assumption that Brandy intentionally caused the crash (either directly or indirectly as in being distracted). Has anyone paused to think that there may have been a problem with the brakes on her vehicle. Until the 'black box' is evaluated, this cannot be ruled out.
I live in LA and drive on the 405 all the time. It is one of the busiest and most dangerous highways in America. This type of accident could have easily happened to anyone including the driver whose life was unfortunately taken. Accidents like this happen everyday in Los Angeles. No one is a perfect driver 100% of the time. Think of how many near accidents you have almost caused or avoided. How many times are you distracted by your radio or maybe you just turned away a split second too long. Brandi was not under the influence at time. Think about how many times you hear about stars like Halle Berry, Nicole Richie, Mel Gibson, Lindsay Lohan, or Paris Hilton driving under the influence. These are the people who should have their license suspended, pay fines, and serve jail time not Brandi. She as well as the victims family will have to live with this the rest of their lives. It is an unfortunate event. No matter how much you think you can control a siuation bad things will happen to you in your lifetime and if they haven't just keep living.
I'm surprised no one is mentioning the fact or expressing astonishment at the fact it took weeks for this to become public knowledge, and why did the CHP drag their feet in getting Brandy charged - you an I would have been charged in a heartbeat. It's a shame someone was killed needlessly, but it troubles me more that it DOES appear celebs (and I use that term VERY loosely with Brandy) do get some preferential treatment, and their scuzbag lawyers will do ANYTHING to arrange to get their client off - makes me sick!
This is a case for the courts to judge and not the public. We have due process that works in a democracy. Let the Lawyers and Judges do their jobs
I am so sorry to hear about this dreadful accident. It saddens me that someones mother, daughter,sister,cousin and so on is gone. I to have had an accident where i hit someone from the back, but i was slidding down an icey snowy hill and tapped the car i hit to where the damage was minimal on both cars, my question and concern is how fast was brandy going to where her car hit another and then into a divider, thats alot of distraction. About a month ago i was in traffic were it was at a standstill and my van was the last to approach the traffic and in my rear view mirror i could see another suv comming up behind me fast. this SUV missed hitting me by maybe a half o foot and had to swerve into the shoulder to avoid hitting me. I am angry at this whole thing because these stars never really pay for their actions and I am sure that this will be another sweeper case
This stretch of freeway is notorious for stopped traffic. You must be hypervigilent through this half-mile part of the 405, it's like an obstacle course. There's countless people cutting in front of you at the last second because they don't feel like waiting in a mile-long line. This is a major freeway interchange with two lanes at a standstill on the right, and people trying to go 80 mph on the left. It's been such a problem that they've recently put up a HUGE yellow sign warning drivers of stopped vehicles and are trying to improve the interchange itself. I wasn't surprised when I saw where the accident occured, it could've been anyone.
It's amazing we're even discussing this. The only reason we are is because she's a celebrity. Accidents happen everday across the country and they are not plastered across the news pages for everyone to see. They are not discussed in forums or on message boards. Both sides to this story could be correct, but we'll never know for sure. Brandy could be at fault for being a distracted driver and nothing more. Or Brandy could be at fault for being an 'above-the-law' celebrity and for being a distracted driver. Who knows what the real truth is and, honestly, who cares? I feel terrible for the family of the deceased and wish them all the best in dealing with their grief. Let the LA police and persons and witnesses involved in the accident figure it all out. Any comments and opinions we post here are nothing more than mere speculation and down-right ignorant for us to do so.
Rowan's comment makes no sense. Of course it was the fault of the driver that struck the car from behind, not the driver that struck it after it was shoved into the center divider. That car may have dealt the blow that killed the person, but that was after the initial collision. If it hadn't been for Brandy, the car wouldn't have been in that situation. It is definitely Brandy's fault.
It is unbelievable to me that some people can judge without knowing all the facts....and that racism and anti-celebrity bias is so transparent in these glib, thoughtless comments. That section of the 405 freeway has more accidents than any other stretch of freeway in SoCal....it is a steep downhill grade, and the two right lanes are always congested. Drivers tend to wait until the last minute to merge into those lanes, often stopping completely in high speed traffic. This kind of accident is a daily occurance there. It could easily have been the fault of an impatient driver who stopped to merge and is completely oblivious to the tragedy they caused. Everytime I drive down that section of freeway I tense up, waiting for just such an occurance! Wait for the facts....
Why is it never anyone's fault? If you swing a hammer in a crowd and hit someone, you will be charged, but if you propell a 3000 lb car carelessly down the road, it is an accident? The stopped cars have some responsibility here as well, if they had left a proper space cushon between them and the car in front of them, they would not be pushed into it if someone rear-ended them. It seems that far too many people have too little respect for the complexities of driving.
My heart goes out to all involved because this could happen to anyone. We need to stop judging and pray for what has happened, place yourself or your family here in the picture. Now what do you see!!!!!
I just read on MSNBC that the deceased driver's family is suing Brandy for $50 million. Grief makes people react in vastily different ways, but how quickly tears and anger turned into dollar signs. Would that have happened if she wasn't a celebrity?
It's unfortunate that someone had to die in this terrible accident. However, it was only an accident. Brandy did not intentionally mean for an innocent life to be taken. This is the reality all drivers face when they operate a car or another vehicle. What is ridiculous on this blog is that the responsibility for causing this accident has been questioned. According to a new article Brandy was driving her Land Rover on Interstate 405 on December 30 when traffic slowed and her vehicle struck the back of a Honda driven by Awatef Aboudihaj. The Honda then hit another vehicle, slid sideways into the center divider and was then hit by another vehicle. I'm sorry but Brandy was the catalyst in a horrible chain reaction. And, if people think that the deceased woman should have been able to stop the momentum of the crash then they should have to take a course in physics to retain a driver's license!
What happened to all involved is tragic, it was an ACCIDENT. If you read above, from people that drive that streach of the 405 freeway, it happened in a bad spot that has always been known to be problematic. Just driving in that area period is a zoo, you get no common driver courtesy. We as people need to pull our heads out of our butts and get off the judgement wagon. This could and can happen to any one of us that drive, we have all had moments when we have been distracted and done something that could have caused an accident. To all of you people that would judge without knowing all of the facts and just being judgemental in general, may God bless you and keep you on your ride home tonight in traffic.
thats sad how people are blaming brandy on all of this it was an "accident" she didnt mean it ...people these days over react on things a way bit too much especially when youre famous
dang...all of this reminds me of when Lisa Lopes from TLC died in 2002 sad isnt it
Suing Brandy for 50m, now that is greedy!!..What if the accident was ther other way round, will the victim's family got 50m to pay too?
The bottom line. She caused the accident. She set the accident in motion. She did not leave enough space between her and the other car in front, even in slow traffic to come to a full stop. She must be charged accordingly....Get a slap on the wrist and unintentionally killing someone. OH NO.
I live in the LA area and I know the San Diego Freeway all too well. When one is coming up over the hill, it's a bit steep and most often than not, there are stopped vehicles due to a freeway change so I myself will never, EVER be doing the speed limit of 65 mph. Everyone needs to slow down AND pay attention to what's up ahead that you can't always see. This is going to take awhile to investigate. Let the police do their job. Brandy caused an accident - yes, that's a given but she didn't do it intentionally. It's unfortunate that's the way it happened. Because of our justice system, she has to be held accountable for her actions.
Brandy seems to be a very sweet and compassionate individual. She should not unfairly charged because of her high profile status. There are accidents daily equal to the one she was involved in, and no one is charged. It would be very sad if Brandy is taken advantage of because shes a public figure. It is horrible that someone lost their life, but they should not take another mother(Brandy) away from her child, as it would only be another tradgedy. Please don't make a example out of a good person. Yes,I feel that out of the goodness of her heart she should absorb all burial cost, and be obligated to contribute a generous dollar ammount to the future of the now motherless child. In no way should the entire Aboudihaj family be supported by Brandy Norwood.
I don't think anyone is saying she should get a slap on the wrist. Most of these cases (for a non-celebrity, anyway)usually result in probation and community service. There was no malice, there were no drugs or alcohol involved. It was simply a case of not paying attention. Speaking of celebrity injustice, do you think that if Brandy were an average Joe making $50,000 a year she would be sued by the parents for $50 mil?
I have to say 50m seems like an awful lot of money. I can't imagine that if this was not a celebrities fault that the family would be asking for so much money. It is awful that this mother died and there needs to be compensation but 50m dollars? And just for the record no where have I read anything about Brandy saying that she was not responsible. So for all of you complaining about fault remember that nothing has been decided as of yet. So quit your speculation. After a verdict is given then you can gripe all you want.
What a horrible catastrophy for the families to have to endure (especially the family that lost their loved one) I think about - what if I were in Brandy's place? I can only imagine the private hellish nightmare she will endure because of her carelessness...ultimately, due process will take it's course and the courts will decide the penalty.
#1 What ever happened to "Defensive Driving"? Why weren't the OTHER drivers looking out around them? I mean, maybe cause I am from Jersey, and have seen the California drivers from LA to San Diego, (OY VEY) but seriously, you really need to be aware of ALL of the surroundings to avoid accidents. I feel bad for Brandi because if my memory serves correctly, years back, before she had her baby, she was in another sort of accident. I dont think she was at fault tho, anyway, she is a sincere celebrity and does not deserve the scrutiny that she is under right now, my prayers are with her and the family of the passed.
I don't feel as thought Brandy's celebrity status should have anything to do with the crime at hand. The point is, whether she is famous or the average Joe Smoe she killed someone, a mother of one, thinki about if the sho was on the other foot, and the driver killed Brandy, they would give her like 30 years for vehicular manslaughter so why should Brandy only be given a misdeamenor charge.
Sueing brandy for 50mil seems to be a slap in the face of the dead women. How does greed help anything, what does it teach anybody by trying to profit from death. I would be a shamed of my family if they tried to sue 50mil for my death, it tells me they care nothing about me but their wallet.
It was an accident, i have been in both scenerios. The first time i was stuck in traffic and a ford truck was going 65 mph straight at me on the 5 freeway, it was coming and it did not stop i decided to drive my car to the side and luckily it gave him time to stop 5 inches from the car in front of me. The other scenerio was last week when i looked left on the 22 and suddenly the traffic was a stand still luckily i stopped in time and had the next lane free to slow down.
She needs to do life in prison! She took a life! She needs to surrender hers!!! Thats the PERFECT answer. Thats the RIGHT answer.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://testpattern.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=44455