ABOUT TEST PATTERN

Don't touch that dial: Test Pattern tunes into television, movie, music and pop culture links, as well as gossip and idle chat from around the Web.

Every week, msnbc.com entertainment producers Gael Fashingbauer Cooper, Denise Hazlick, Paige Newman, Kurt Schlosser and Anna Chan weigh in on topics ranging from TV commercials to movie hype to the latest celebrity blunder. We're not ashamed to admit our love for bad TV or reveal what's on our iPods, and invite you to join the conversation via your comments.



Highlights -- and lowlights -- of "Dancing With the Stars"

Posted: Monday, March 19, 2007 9:16 PM by Gael Fashingbauer Cooper
Filed Under:

I admit it, I watched Monday's premiere of "Dancing With the Stars," despite the fact that the show's about ready to be renamed "Cha cha chaing with the C-Listers." I mean, really, did you know who Shandi Finnessey was? Was anyone out there clamoring to see more of Leeza Gibbons? Are we anything but angry at Billy Ray Cyrus for bestowing "Achy Breaky Heart" upon us? And Ian Ziering?  Ian Ziering?

Viewers will have to wait a whole week to find out who gets voted off, although MSNBC.com contributor Linda Holmes has some pretty sharp guesses here. As goofy as the show is, however, it's somewhat soothing. The stars are millionaires whether they win or lose, for the most part, and they're generally pretty comfortable before the cameras. Nothing's on the line for them except a really ugly trophy. These are not the nervous teens of "American Idol" putting it out there every week. Even the judges and the hosts seem to know better than to take the show too seriously -- goofily accented judges Len Goodman and Bruno Tonioli trade off trying to be goofily accented, caustic Simon Cowell, but neither of them have his harsh edge.

If I had to be serious about it, I'd note that Ian Ziering wasn't half bad, Paulina Porizkova is elegance personified, and Anton Apolo Ohno has, unsurprisingly, some really fast feet. If I had to pick who's likely to get booted next week, I'd say Billy Ray Cyrus or Leeza Gibbons. If I had to pick an early winner, I like Laila Ali's chances.

But I don't have to be serious, and so here, then, are some of my own personal highlights -- and lowlights -- from the "Dancing" premiere.

Dorkiest outfit, celebrity version: Heather Mills' weirdly two-toned raspberry and vanilla dress, which even she admitted made her "feel a bit like an ice-cream sundae."

Dorkiest outfit, pro dancer version: Two-time champ Cheryl Burke appeared to be wearing a fishing net covered with those googly eyes you buy in a craft store.

Unwisest choice of music: Ian Ziering and Burke cha cha cha'd to "Mony Mony," which has been known to spark an obscene chant when played in public.

Funniest age joke: Paulina Porizkova's partner, Alec Mazo, told the classy supermodel that "my dad has a lot of pinups of you."

Age joke that backfired: "Cheers" legend John Ratzenberger, almost 60, joked that he's about to turn 72. No one in the audience thought he was kidding.

Dance move that most resembled domestic violence: Country singer Billy Ray Cyrus had to make multiple attempts before successfully, and scarily, ripping a fake mullet off the head of his partner, Karina Smirnoff.

Worst nickname: Joey Fatone's partner, Kym Johnson, helpfully chirped of the former boy-bander, "Joey Fat One's not going to be his nickname any more!" OK, but Fatone didn't help his cause much when he followed up her statement by yelling "I need a bra!"

 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

They need to quit advertising this show as having "a dancer with an artificial limb". I think I heard this phrase 4 times in the 2 hour special. This makes Mills sound like she's a freak show at the circus. Totaly un-cool of ABC.
I think this program is a real winner. It has pretty girls in pretty (sometimes scant) clothes and men dressed very elegantly. The music is very lively and pretty and I enjoy the barbs, insults and other bantering between the judges, the MC and the participants. I think the audience really get engaged too.
Yep, it's a guilty pleasure here. No pretenses of it being "real" anyway and all they win is an ugly trophy. Big whoop. It's just a popularity contest in the end with dancing by C-listers.
I think that Dancing with the Stars is a great way to entertain people. Watching people you have never heard about, who have millions of dollars dance professionaly with people who have danced all their lives is hilarious. Emmit Smith from last season did a great job of learning the steps and it teaches the "spoiled" stars of America to work hard at something.
I was a bit disappointed in the ladies- except for Laila Ali. If she isn't in the final two, I will be very surprised. I figured Billy Ray wouldn't do too well. I think having Ian and Cheryl open as the first dance was fantastic- they definitely set the tone for this season. Joey was a good surprise- it appears that all those years rocking onstage to teeny-bopper music might be paying off. I enjoyed John's dance the most- he seemed to be enjoying it more than the rest of the contestants. Even if he doesn't make it far- his effort and attitude make him one of the better dancers and most enjoyable to watch.
We enjoy watching the show but Shandi's comment about being glad about not having a Russian partner was out of line. It shows us Canadian fans how truly ignorant some Americans can be and how they can not hold their tongues. We feel that she should make a public apology (not that we would believe it) and please have someone on the delay button if she can not control her comments, Sheila Louise New Westminster B.C. Canada
And to Sheila Louise... Though I agree with your comment regarding Shandi.. I thought she was out of line. However, I am an American.. and you can not tell me that all Canadians are rocket scientists and hold no ignorance. How judgemental of you.
Leeza Gibbons looked GREAT out there, too bad NBC's Natalie Morales or CBS' Hannah Storm or Access Hollywood's Maria Menounos won't do the show..... That would be so cool! As far as A-List Actresses being on there, I like to see Lauren Graham, Gillian Anderson, Audrey Tautou, Scarlett Johannson, or Catherine Zeta-Jones strut out there!!!
The overexploiting Heather Mills and her artificial limb while stating her occupation as a professional charitable whatever is a little over the top as Ms. Mills appeared last night. Send Billy Ray back to Hannah Montanna where at least he can let Milley carry him before Karina skins him alive with her temper. Poor Liza Gibbons looked pertrified, she is gorgeous, but came off maniquin like last night. The former Ms. USA wants to be seen but she's a little over the top like the current Ms. USA Tara Connor. Cheryl is the best pro dancer, but Ms. Ali is the hands down fav starting out at the gate!
Billy Ray has to go. He can then be followed by Leeza. I agree that Shandi's comments were beyond stupid but stupid is as stupid does and I don't think she is in danger of winning a nobel prize any time soon. And given her dance quality I'm sure the other professionals are thrilled that they are nor not saddled with her. I think that the show has to be careful because last night was the worst dancing that I have ever seen on the show - by sheer number of dancers. They either need to give them 6 weeks to get up to speed or they need to be more selective. It will kill the show if people come out each week and stink. Joey, John, Appollo, Ian and Laila will all be fun to watch. The rest could pretty much go home now. I think it is harder for the women to be good at this and this is the weakest batch of gals out of any season.
I think it would be better if they used the traditional music as professional Ballroom dancers do. The songs are like your at a bad wedding. It just makes it cheezy. I'll stick to real Ballroom dancing on PBS.
The show was exactly what i needed- lighthearted fun. Come on, how could you NOT love watching Billy Ray Cyrus & Clyde Drexler try REALLY hard, despite being way too stiff. Those people are the real reason you watch DWTS, and hope they become an Emmitt Smith over time. I hope you're wrong & cyrus & Gibbons arent the first to go..that honor should go to Shandi Finnesy who was not only boring, but seemed intent on garnering votes with a forced attraction to her partner.
First and formost, it doesn't matter where you go, you will always find ignorant people who can't hold their tongues... it's ignorant to sum it up with Americans. But as for dancing, I've been Ballroom dancing since i was four. I'm incredibly proud to see it creeping into the public as strongly as it has in the past years. It really is a very vigorous sport that should be taken more seriously then it has been. For that, i am glad for DWTS.
I am finding myself increasingly surprised at the number of people who say "Who is Shandi Finnessey?" Yeah, maybe she hasn't had the face time in the media that most of the others have had, but I kinda feel like you'd really have to have lived under a rock for a few years to have no idea who she is.
Fun and lighthearted entertainment! My hubby and I enjoy the dancing and music. However, I must say, if you don't like the show, think it's sanky and you're not a fan, please spare us your negative comments and simply change your television to another station you do like. As far as Shandi's comment goes, lighten up Canadian and get a grip. If people weren't so narrow and close-minded these days, they would recognize that Shandi's a jokester and was simply being playful. Good Golly Miss Molly, I think the whole world needs a good stiff dose of Preparation H to ease their staunchness and soften their minds. Thanks ABC for Dancing with the Stars!
I was really suprised by Ian Ziering...he was pretty competent on the dance floor. My pick to go the distance is Joey Fatone...since NSYNC was always my guilty pleasure, he fits right in with the show. However, Shandi Finnessy needs to go...followed by Billy Ray Cyrus. In a quick response to Sheila from Canada...please do not judge all Americans by the actions of one "celebrity."
Does anyone remember Billy Ray singing his one song and trying to move at the same time?
I'll apologize for her. It's sad that the few who can't keep their ignorant comments to themselves are the ones who end up on television. Or in control of our country.
I do not think that the stars have much input about the costumes or the music. I have heard that they review some things with the coordinators, but do not originate anything. How could they have the time?? I like the show for the simple entertainment it provides. Although, I was happier with it when I actually knew who the stars were.
I love the show, which shows I'm not too cynic. I agree that Heather Mills is probably on as a gimmick (shame on her) and I loved Laila, Ian and Fatone. But we know, in the end, it's not their dancing ability but their popularity that counts.
My husband and I really enjoy the show. The one thing that I thought was (over played) was the fact Heather Mills has a artificial limb.Even the judges made a comment. I'ts Dancing with the Stars!!!! I hope more focus will be on the dancing intead of her leg. Donna Kay Memphis,TN.
Who chooses the music for the dances? If the judges are so concerned about dancing "properly," then how does the cha-cha fit into a disco theme. Why not dance to true cha-cha music to make it really authentic?
I wasn't too sure about the stars (didn't know some of them) but other than the comment about the Russian partner and the artificial leg...I really enjoyed it..I love to watch people dance...I know it would be silly..since we know who the winner is but will DVD's be coming out for Dancing with the Stars.
I enjoy watching Dancing the Stars, and I must say that I pick Joey "Fat One" Fatone as winner! His boy band talents were oozing in his dancing last night! The rest of the dancers looked liked stiff boards trying to surf on the dancing ocean of, "Why I'm I here??" Top wanna be dancing stiff surfers are Billy Ray Cyrus and Heather Mills, They will be first to go!!
Guilty Pleasure? Absolutely! But I love this show. It makes me smile every time I watch it. Billy Ray's dance was truly cringe inducing but I really enjoyed Laila, Joey and John (I missed Ian & Cheryl) But couldn't they have found another description for Heather Mills other than "Celebrity Campaigner"? I'm not even sure what that means....
I agree with Sheila Louise about Shandi's comment. It's a fact that the Russian dancers are much more successful than the American ones anyway. And honestly, I just found Shandi and her perma-smile partner bloody annoying the whole time! I hope they get sent home quickly!
I resent Gael Fashingbauer Cooper for blasting Dancing With The Stars. I think it is one of the best shows on TV and Gael called it "goofy". There are thousands of people that watch it every week and I personally could hardly wait for the new season to start. I suppose all the killing, sex and violence is more appealing? The more I think of the comments that were made by Gael the more upset I get. Gael needs to get a life.
I really like Dancing with the Stars but if you are using music that is not even remotely traditional ballroom...like the disco song they used...is it really ballroom dancing??? That dance was a disco number not a cha cha! It should have been judged as such. JMHO....
As bad as Shandi's Russian comment was, it's no near as bad as the uncomfortableBilly, albany, GA creepy banter bewteen her and Chuck Wollery on Game Show Network's "Lingo"
Gael Cooper, If you don't like the show. then don't watch it. It amazes me that you would spend four years of your life to aquire a degree in journalism and this is the only kind of crud you could come up with.
No leaders this time around. Ian, Apolo and Joey lead the pack for the men. John was fun to watch as the obligatory older guy. Laila is the leader for the Women, however I think Paulina can improve, Shandi could get better as well......I love to watch for the outragous costumes I think Heather Mills was the winner this week with as she described the Ice Cream Sundae dress!
Sheila Louise New Westminster B.C. Canada it works both ways my dear. You Canadians are always quick to jump on the America bashing just to make you feel better about your self righteous ways. No one cares if your Canadian we are all fans of the show just deal with it.
Sheila, you'll have to start watching 'The Amazing Race' if you want to see Americans being truly culturally insensitive. In other lands. Please believe that not all of us are so shamefully boneheaded! (As for the apology, it'll never happen; Russians aren't one of the groups du jour that you aren't allowed to say mean or insensitive things about.)
This is my ULTIMATE guilty pleasure!!! I have been anticipating this new season since the end of the last one!! It was an interesting start, but I miss the comic relief of past seasons (Jerry Springer, anyone?). Being a Joey Fatone fan, He's my pick to win.....but I also enjoyed Laila Ali and Paulina Porizkova. Karina needs to keep to the rules, though, or she and Billy Ray will be gone.......
I was totally shocked by Billy Ray's performance. It bordered on assault. he should be the first to go.
I've never watched before, but it's the first show that had me smiling for 2 hours....and isn't that what entertainment is all about? Heather can't dance and didn't look like she was having any fun, so I assume she should be the first to go followed by Billy Ray. Everyone else was having a great time...and I can't wait for next week. I thank ABC for a few hours of fun.
Watched DWTS for the first time last night and was hooked. Very enjoyable and fun...no serious cutthroat contestants..just everyone having fun. As for those who don't like the "new" songs used for the dances...well, the last time I looked ..you dance to the beat not the song...so yes even the newer "disco " songs can be cha-chas....It's the beat not the song that makes the dance. I think it's refreshing to use "new" music that we all like and know..adds to the enjoyment.
I did enjoy the show and belive it or not TV can entertain with out Police chases, death, and murder. It was a lot of fun and if you did not see that you took it way to serious.
I think it's time to get off the "celebrity charity worker stick" how about changing it to Gold digging jezebelle??? She's just using the USA because all of Europe has booted her out already.
I love this show! I saw the tour when it came to town and I thought it was great. I think the band and singers don't get enough credit. They are WONDERFUL!
Ok, I watched it too -- Now, I take ballroom dancing and have for about 15 months -- it's hard, very hard -- and if I had 6 hours a day 6 days a week I'd be must further ahead -- I agree with some of comments concerning the music -- several of the choices are absolutely ridiculous -- maybe the folks in charge don't believe beautiful ballroom dance music or appropriate Latin music will be appreciated -- I disagree -- Part of the beauty of watching different kinds of dance is the music which accompanies varied kinds of dance -- nothing like seeing a REAL Cha-Cha to fab Latin music -- whoever is in charge of those choices is nuts --
I thought it was great fun! True, there were some agonizing moments (Billy Ray) and most of the ladies foxtrots could have put me to sleep (I missed Laila, but overall I enjoyed it. I thought John did way better than anyone would have expected and he, more than most of the celeb's, looked like he was having a ball out there. I think Heather Mills got some sympathy points and will get sympathy votes. I would have called her gold digger, but then, that's just me. My early bet is on Ian. He seems to have the ability plus he's paired with Cheryl and she's a two time champ.
I thought it was great fun! True, there were some agonizing moments (Billy Ray) and most of the ladies foxtrots could have put me to sleep (I missed Laila, but overall I enjoyed it. I thought John did way better than anyone would have expected and he, more than most of the celeb's, looked like he was having a ball out there. I think Heather Mills got some sympathy points and will get sympathy votes. I would have called her gold digger, but then, that's just me. My early bet is on Ian. He seems to have the ability plus he's paired with Cheryl and she's a two time champ.
Anyone notice how Heather Mills dropped the "I'll give you a million bucks" line last night?
Heather was awesome. Her humor is refreshing. After last night I can understand why Paul fell for her. She is not about pity, and I hope her disability will not be mentioned again. She is there to have fun. She knows she is not going to win. I admire her greatly. Laila will, and should, take the prize. She has control of everything around her, and exudes beauty, talent and poise.
I love DWTS!!! It's the only 'reality' show I'll watch. To Sheila in Canada...not all Americans are the same as I'm sure you'll agree that not all Canadians are the same.
I think the one to watch for will be Ian. He seems to have the ability and he's got Cheryl for his partner. I thought the was fun to watch. I love being an armchair-dance-critic. I could never do the stuff they do. My hat goes to John R. I thought he did a great job and seemed to really be having a blast out there. As to Heather, I'm afraid she'll get sympathy votes from people which isn't fair to the other dancers. I don't know why they call her a campaigner, I think gold digger is more appropriate.
It's pretty obvious that Heather Mills in on the show to improve her public image after the nastiness of her divorce with Paul McCartney. But you gotta give her points for taking the risk with her leg. (BTW, they say she's a Charity Campaigner, not celebrity campaigner, which means she raises money for causes).
I've been watching DWTS since show 1, season 1 and I think it's great entertainment. That's what it is - entertainment - not a ballroom dancing contest. Please keep that in mind. Unfortunately, I agree with Lisa in that it's more-or-less a popularity contest. However, I think the fans are for the most part pretty good in deciding who the better dancers are, with minor exceptions. "Celebrity Campaigner"? Give me a break! Also, nobody has mentioned Tom Bergeron. I think he's great! I've been watching him for at least 20 years, ever since he got his start on WBZ-TV in Boston. Also, the orchestra and singers have enormous talent. Good going ABC. TV entertainment at it's best!
I swore I wasn't going to watch this season...but it didn't conflict with my husband who gave up his viewing so I could watch, last season....sooooo...I'm in it again but only on Mon. nights. Last season the leaders were very apparent, but not this time, and I think I like it better that way; for me anyway. And as for the music, it is an improvement over the last two seasons. But as I have said a million times: I would love to see one of the dances done to "Dance With Me" by Michael Bolton.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://testpattern.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=94625