ABOUT TEST PATTERN

Don't touch that dial: Test Pattern tunes into television, movie, music and pop culture links, as well as gossip and idle chat from around the Web.

Every week, msnbc.com entertainment producers Gael Fashingbauer Cooper, Denise Hazlick, Paige Newman, Kurt Schlosser and Anna Chan weigh in on topics ranging from TV commercials to movie hype to the latest celebrity blunder. We're not ashamed to admit our love for bad TV or reveal what's on our iPods, and invite you to join the conversation via your comments.



Paternity established, but Anna Nicole case drags on

Posted: Tuesday, April 10, 2007 6:14 PM by Gael Fashingbauer Cooper
Filed Under:

People on their vacations in the Bahamas actually tore themselves away from the beach to mill around a courthouse today and wait for news in the Anna Nicole Smith paternity case. They'd have been better off soaking up the sun. The results were what pretty much everyone expected: Larry Birkhead is baby Dannielynn's father, and give him credit, he at least seems legitimately thrilled about the news.

A cynic could say "sure he's thrilled, he just won the lottery." Well, that's only if baby Dannielynn is ever proven the heiress to any of J. Howard Marshall's millions. Her mother was never able to claim that money while she was alive, so maybe baby Dannie shouldn't count on it, either. Birkhead seemed to care about making a life with the baby -- even though it's unclear if he attempted to be a part of her life before Smith died.

The crowd was undeniably on Birkhead's side. Those who had watched the courtroom testimony earlier thought he came across as honest, and most found him more likable than Anna Nicole's longtime companion, Howard K. Stern.

And as a somewhat new addition to this soap opera, Birkhead didn't have the nagging baggage of Stern or Smith's much-reviled mother, Virgie Arthur. People will wonder forever why Stern couldn't stop Smith from abusing prescription medication, or at least get her help.

And Virgie Arthur just needs to step out of everything. She wasn't in much contact with her daughter while she was alive, and it seems highly hypocritical to see her now, cooing about how she wants to be the baby's grandmother. Her lawyer has indicated she may even fight for custody, which is just ridiculous. Let the baby live with her father. In fact, Dannielynn's adorable face is about the only bright thing in this whole mess. She knows nothing of money, or custody suits, or Playboy Playmates, or prescription drugs. Some day she won't be able to escape this whole mess that surrounded her babyhood, but for now, she's a precious innocent -- the only one in this whole case.

In Charles Dickens' "Bleak House," an infamous and interminable legal case drags on and on. It'll make someone incredibly rich, if it only ever ends. But in the end, court costs eat up all of the enormous estate. Sound familiar? Dickens wrote his book 150 years ago, but apparently we've learned nothing from his cautionary tale.

 

 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Maybe Stern didn't want to stop Anna Nicole because he himself is an addict. If you look at his behavior it certainly raises many doubts about that man. I suspect before this is all over we'll learn a lot more about that will which names him as the executor and her son Daniel as the only heir (regardless of future children). There's a deal here between Stern and Birkhead and it involves millions of dollars... will be fun to watch.
I'm so sad for Dannielynn, happy that she legally has a father, but dissapointed by the actions of the evil mother of the late great Anna Nicole. The ASOLUTE only reason that this woman is interested in this poor little baby is for the $$ signs that she's seeing. When Anna Nicole was alive, she made no quams about making it known that her mother was never a GOOD MOTHER and repeatedly called her "Mommy Dearest" if that doesn't give you a clear picture what does?? The focus should be on the best caregiver for that beautiful little girl, and she should be with the person who will ALWAYS put her needs first ahead of they're own. I hope that this will end soon, and Anna, Daniel, Dannielynn, Howard and Larry can all get on with they're lives. Good luck to Howard and Larry in the upcoming custody battle!!! Save this little girl.
There should not be a custody battle. Larry Birkhead was unjustly denied the opportunity to be in his child's life by a mother who was at the very least unable to make decisions that were in the interest of the child. She used the child to meet her own sad needs. Howard Stern further abused the child by holding her hostage to attempt to perpetuate his train wrecked gravy train. Nicole's mother is not worth my time discussing.
who gives a crap about all these self absorbed morons . as long as the kid is taken care of, the sooner we never hear about these drama freaks again the better.
I do feel very sorry for poor little Dannielynn, while everyone seems to be trashing the grandmother, I believe that she raised Daniel for some years and other than his 'ill-fated' trip to the Bahamas did a fairly good job of raising him. I'm sorry, but Daniel dies IN the hospital visiting his mother and she couldn't see he was sick to get him help and then Anna-Nichole is left in a hotel room with a 'nurse' who doesn't check on her for hours while Stern is out scoping out a boat and both deaths are ruled 'accidental overdoses'? Larry Birkhead while more likeable, abandons Anna-Nichole to Stern and drugs in the fifth month, maybe adoption to get her away from all of this would be the best thing that could happen to Dannielynn! Moral: leave a good Will!
I totally agree...good luck howard and larry. its easy to tell that this baby will be loved no matter which of these two gentleman rasie her .i believe she will be raised with love...God bless and good luck guy.
After what seems years, but in reality is only months, this is finally OVER! Birkhead is the daddy, Vergie is the Granny, Howard will be the Godfather and all live happy every after spending Anna Nicole's money. ONLY in American can you see such a disgusting display of greed in the name of love for a child! God help us all and black out the TV from any more coverage of this awful family!
I wouldn't want to be Howard. He is the only person grieving. Everybody else is just after the fame and the baby. He lost all of his family members within a seven month period. Everyone should be counting his or her blessings!
My fondest hope for Dannielynn is that Larry takes her away somewhere where they can "disappear," even change her name if necessary, so that she does not grow up to be constantly referred to as the daughter of "tragic Anna Nicole." I wish her a normal life.
I don't have very many nice things about this mess, only that I'm glad that Larry Birkhead is the father, he seems like he has a head on his shoulders. Anna's motherd needs to step out of the ring. She's not a very nice woman. Stern isn't any better I don't think. This saga will always continue, as Anna Nicole's daughter grows, the media will get wind of things, you know? I'm proud for Larry =)
The $400 plus million Dannielynn may (or may not) inherit will probably be moot, if the Marshall family proves that Dannielynn, who isn't a blood descendent of their family, isn't entitled to that money, and should only get the $8 million the court awarded to Anna Nicole. If the courts ever straighten out Anna's own estate, the child will get that money, but not the Marshall fortune, it seems to me. Good luck to Larry Birkhead and to Howard K. Stern, as they work on plans for this child and her future.
Gael, How can you say "Birkhead seemed to care about making a life with the baby -- even though it's unclear if he attempted to be a part of her life before Smith died."? He's been attempting to establish his paternity since Anna gave birth. It's the one thing he's been seeking from the very beginning. I think he genuinely loves his daughter and just wants to be with her and do the best for her.
This is finally over. It was so obvious that Larry Birkhead was the father of baby Dannielynn. If Howard Stern was why would he fight against the DNA test? It is wonderful that Larry is willing to step forward and take responsibility for his child. I can't understand why Howard would try and keep Larry from his child. It is Larry's right to have his daughter and raise her. I understand that Howard loved Anna Nicole, but by taking the approach he did he made her life in to a circus act for all to see. Good luck to Larry and Dannielynn. Give her a fighting chance.
I hope the courts allow the Dannilynn to stay in the Bahamas and Larry and Stern can share custody.I know what its like to take in a baby for 6 months and have the parent come after all that time and take her back its heart breaking and that is something I wouldn't wish on no one
I think everyone in this case only wants to raise Dannylynn because they know that baby is worth money, Larry (the biological father) i think doesnt really care to much about the baby, I think the baby should go to Howard K. stern she should live with him, Larry knows nothing about the baby Howard has been raising the baby and I think that they should not confuse the baby, she is already use to Howard k Stern and that is the way it should stay.
DDC laboratory director Dr. Michael Baird announced the results of the highly contested paternity test in Bahamian court proceedings yesterday. With over 11,500,000 to one odds of paternity, Larry Birkhead is considered the biological father of Anna Ni..
I am so happy for Larry...He knew all along Dannielynn was his. It's a shame that he had to go through all of this just to be with his daughter. I truly believe that Howard knew she wasn't his. Now I sincerely hope that this precious angel will grow up with a 'normal' life, whatever that is in the crazy celebrity world. Vergie should go back home to her disfunctional life. And let's finally end this circus!
And God forbid, if Dannielynn "mysteriously" dies, then what?
While I am glad the biological father of Dannielynn is now public information I am very sad for Howard K. Stern. The media has been reckless, at best, in their assumptions of Stern. He has been made out to be a murderer, a liar, a money hungry man, when I believe he truly loved Anna Nicole. An addict is an addict, whether it be prescription drugs, street drugs, alcohol, etc. We call tell them to stop, wish for them to stop, and hope they will stop! In reality they have a sickness that only they can "fix"... I'm not impressed with Birkhead's 'prank' as he tried to be a clown when announcing the news. As for Vergie Arthur....she needs to trot her tail back to Texas and leave them all alone! She's not the "Mother of the Year" nor the "Grandma of the Year". She should be ashamed! There's someone looking for money.
Well at least now they know who the real father is. Even though I really don't know much about Larry Birkhead I am glad that he is the father. There is just something about Howard K Stern that I feel he should not be trusted. I found it so funny that al of a sudden everybody wanted to be the babys daddy I am sure glad that the truth is finally out did Howard K Stern really love Anna Nicole or was it her money that kept him in that relationship. It's obvious that she did'nt love him or else there would be no other babys daddy but him.I pray that whoever keeps the baby will give her true love.
Only in America, can war, ecological collapse and our inability to provide decent health care and education for our citizens take a backseat to the exploits of a surgically enhanced substance abusing 2nd rate model (and 3rd rate actress) and her kin. I keep trying to imagine real journalists like Walter Kronkite or Edward R. Murrow devoting so much attention to a nothing story like this and I can't do it. The Anna Nicole feeding frenzy typifies the disgraceful deterioration of journalism in America.
I wish that all 3, (Larry, Howard & Virgie) can get together and work for the good of the baby Dannilyn. She will be needing all the love and support that she can get and for a normal and secure life.
If there was no $$$ involved, Would there be a fight over the baby? We don't really know all of the in and outs. there is good and bad in everyone. the only question that will be answered is what is this custody fight over really?? In just a few years, when everything is settled no one will even remember this child. unless she turns out to be just like her mother.
It would be nice if things worked in favor of Howard Stern. He was obviously Anna's choice, and really, isn't that what matters. I hope things work out for him. I feel nothing for Larry Birkhead but disgust. "I TOLD YOU SO" who says that? Only a smug idiot. All in all, as long as the baby is ok, I guess that will have to suffice.
I have felt all along that Mr. Birkhead was the father and should have sole custody of his daughter. I do not believe that Anna and Howard ever had a sexual relationship, which may be discovered at a later date and the statement he made to Mr. Birkhead about Anna Needing the pills to live still haunts me. I believe there is still alot more to this case than we know.People tend to make a lot better grandparents than they do parents so Mrs. Arthur should be allowed to be a part of Dannielynns life.
All I have to say about this case is I hope the poor kid has some semblance of a normal life. Otherwise she and Suri will be sharing therapists down the road between media attention and parental antics.
I don't think the public will ever forget Anna Nicole Smith. She was one beautiful woman. I for one will never forget her. I wish there were more photographs of her beautiful body. I certainly will buy the latest current issue of Playboy, and any other photograph pictures of her!
Birkhead is an idiot. When we first found out Anna was pregnant he implied to the media that he has no idea who the baby's father was and that it could have been any number of men AND THEN went on to say that probably wasn't his and that he didn't want it anyway...This isn't some game, it's a childs life and leaving her in the hands of a man who denied her when she was first concieved and then holds a press conference to brag "I told you so" when he is proven to be the father, is just crazy. The man is a moron.
I would like for the baby to stay where she is with Larry and Howard sharing custody. As a foster parent, I know how Howard is feeling about a baby being ripped out of your life after raising it for 7 or 8 months. The baby has bonded with him and I think it would be a shame for Dannilynn and Howard to break off contact now. Larry is the bio dad but Howard is the "father". Anyone can be a dad but it takes a man to be a father.
This will never end if the media continues to write stories everyday about it.
I, like millions of others, knew from the beginning when Larry Birkhead requested DNA to prove he was the father, that he was the Father. Howard Stern appeared as a snake in the grass and never lifted his eyes to the camera after Anna Died. I never trusted him at all. Now it comes out that the truth is what I thought from the beginning. Larry Birkhead may not be a millionaire but he loves that little girl and he wanted Anna to quit drugs for the child's sake. Anna wanted the drugs more than she wanted to have Larry so she went over to Stern to provide those drugs for her. That is really why she stayed with him because he provided her drugs. I wonder about Daniel - was that a murder by Stern slipping him drugs since he was in the will as the only heir??? Could be. Anyway, it is time for Dannielynn to be with her read Dad, Larry. Time for Stern to get out of the Bahamas millionaire house and try to work for a living. They say Howard Stern never had a client except for his family members and ANNA. That tell you what kind of lawyer he was/is. I'm just glad Larry is the father. He seems like a nice guy who does care and tried to do his best. He is the only one who deserves to care for Dannielynn.
You can do your part by not mentioning them in your blog again, which is the only reason the case is on MSNBC's homepage this morning.
NO, the stupid Anna Nicole case will NEVER end because the news outlets won't quit talking about it. This is the first Anna Nicole link I have clicked on in weeks, but I had to comment on the irony of you asking that question. GIVE ME A BREAK!! People are dying in Iraq. We are at WAR and when you go to MSN, CNN, ABC, NBC, and CBS, there are all these stories about blonde drama - Anna Nicole's baby & boy toys, Brittany shaving her stupid hair off. WHO CARES? There are people dying. Our country is facing very real problems. I would like to see the networks shift the focus to more important issues, so that the American people can deal with them. So irresponsible. CUT IT OUT
The solution is let Angelina and Brad adopt the baby. Shiloh will have playmate and the baby would be brought up with a house full of children. And they do not need the money that the reast are fighting for!!!
I am happy for Larry Birkhead. It appears he is thrilled to get his baby daughter. Howard Stern should be out of her life. He helped her mother die by enabling her to take all those drugs, and he was taking them also most probably. Virgie should just back out of the picture. If Larry wants her to be involved with Dannilynn, he will do so, but not Howard. I am really disqusted that he would not get Anna some help so she could be off drugs. Its a miracle that Dannilynn is okay after all the junk she put into her body while pregnant. Couldn't this cause the baby problems as she grows up????
Hopefully soon, he'll (Larry) have custody of the baby. They'll all go their separate way, and in ten years, one of the networks will do a feature on Dannielynn during nightly news, or 20/20, or Dateline. Until then, we'll occassionally hear about the progress, or lack of progress on "the money".....and will have a zillion other celebrity stories to keep us absolutely riveted to the TV, and on the edge of our seats.
So Larry is the father, a pretty smug idiot if you ask me He denied being the father at first and didn't care enough when he did find out. He doesn't deserve that little girl. HS was there for Anna and he obviously loves that little girl like his own. Give him a break. The media has been ruthless and as always they see only what is on the outside and not the whole dang story so they read into it what they want. Anna was a drug addict and no matter how much you love someone an addict is an addict and will say and do anything to get what the body craves. At least HS was there to TRY TO WATCH OUT FOR HER, In the end the drugs won. plain and simple. As for Virgie Arthur go home. You weren't there for daughter in life, now all you are really interested in is the money Danny Lynn could get. Do you think we are all stupid. Wouldn't it be great if the court ruled that Howard was the best one to raise the baby. Jokes on everyone else then. Let him be. He was nothing more than a man in love with someone who was addicted to the wrong things.
I feel that we all need to pray for a spiritual intervention on behalf of this baby and her daddy.It will be very difficult for them to have any type of normal life. It would be great if they could disappear with new identities but the vultures won't let that happen.
Dannielynns father is now known..so be it. Let the soul of Anna Nicole Smith rest in Peace. Give the billions to the one who really is entitled and rightfully deserved the money while the baby or until Dannielynn can decided for her own future. And Let us all Pray...everyone involved has her/his own reason, motive, intention, good or bad we really dont know...live and let die!
Well Danilynn will finally be where she belongs with Larry and her biological father. He won out right as should be Howard and Anna ran to the Bahamas to hide from him and Larry was the real man in the whole thing. He came and stuck out to get what is legally his..He is the only one who has never mentioned the babys money and had filed for his rights even before Anna's death...For Howard to try and keep that baby knowing he isn't the real father would be criminal... Larry and Virgie will work it out as she said she wants to be Grandma and as long as she gets to know her granddaughter I'm sure they will reach an agreement...Howard needs to back out of the picture and let Larry bond with his daughter.
I was glad to hear that Larry was the father of little Dannielynn, but not surprised. I think he will make a good father. As far as Virgie goes, just shut up and go back to Texas.
I think that Virgie needs to back off and let Larry be the daddy. I think all Virgie is worried about is the money. Where was she all this time when Anna needed her mother the most. All she is after is the money. Somebody needs to give her a reality check.
If Anne really thought her mother was so horrible and abusive why did she allow her mom to raise Danny for several years. Doesn't anyone get it when you take drugs like Anna did it messes with your mind and your attitude. Also, she is the grandmother and obviously did care about her daughter and her grandson. Maybe it was just Anna's drugs, influences, and life style that were causing her to be angry and stay away from her mother.
Comeon now..Virgie did raise Daniel for several years Shelly is right.Then Howard came into the future and frankly Virgie was shut out of Anna life because of the Drugs.Maybe she wants some sort of grandmothers rights so that hopefully Danilynn won't end up like Anna and Daniel...I really doubt Larry would ever let that happen.Just a tip to him if he arranged for Virgie to sit down and hold her granddaughter would likely go along way to settle all of this. When Virgie got the opportunity to see the baby Howard never allowed Grandmother to hold her Grand child... If Larry would let her sit and spend a few moments with the baby might go along way to end all of this. Especially since Larry has control now would show Virgie that her Granddaughter won't be ripped away from her like both Anna and Daniel did...
Bottom line...Someone tell Larry to allow Virgie a few minutes with her grandchild not to just look at her but hold her and cuddle her granchild...Might make all the difference....Use some commen sense Larry and it will all come out in the wash just like my father use to say...
Wake up Tiffany in Kentucky...Virgie has a granchild she has never been allowed to hold in her arms..Thats what she needs right now Virgie has a stable income why would she worry about the money...Let her sit down and let her hold that baby that she will get to be a grandmother again still believe that will help settle the whole thing.... If Howard doesn't like it he can go take a walk while it happens...
Let's examine Vergie's parenting skills - Exhibit 1 - Vickie Lynn AKA Anna Nicole. That should close the case. She has proven she is a horrendous parent and shouldn't be allowed to raise pit bulls, much less a precious child.
I think Howard Stern genuinely loved Anna Nicole and I believe that he cared about Dannie too. I regret that he is being vilified so much in the media as the bad guy in this matter as he was the only one who was always around to do Anna's bidding. He has done a fantastic job taking care of Dannielyn and I hope that Larry will let him play a role in the baby's life and will not completely exclude him out of the baby's life. After all, Howard would have been married to Nicole by now, and they actually made a commitment to each in a commitment ceremony before she died. He is grieving and yet not many people seem to have any sympathy for him. He has lost everyone he loves and I wish him the best.
I have to agree with Kim from NC. In my opinion Vergie would not be a good role model. I mean look at her. To begin with she used to party with Anna when she was younger. That right there is a BIG mistake. She has been married 6 times, let Anna's body sit in the hot sun the day of her wake while she tried one last time to stop her from being put in the ground and let to rest.And who knows what else she has done. She needs to go home and leave that poor baby alone. If Larry wants Vergie in Dannielynn's life at some point it should be up to him, not in court papers. I know many of you will not agree with this , but I also think that Howard should be part of Dannielynn's life. After all he did spend 12 years with her Mom and knew her very well. He has been been with Dannielynn since birth. He has taken care of her and has been one of the main people in her life. you can tell he really loves that baby. Even Larry has said Howard has been such a big help with the transtion. This is just my opinion... thanks
Oh Howard has been a so called Father Figure for what 7months...and during that time he had a Nanny doing the hard work...Doesn't make him an athority on Father hood. Just someone wanting to control everything in everyones life.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://testpattern.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=128926