ABOUT TEST PATTERN

Don't touch that dial: Test Pattern tunes into television, movie, music and pop culture links, as well as gossip and idle chat from around the Web.

Every week, msnbc.com entertainment producers Gael Fashingbauer Cooper, Denise Hazlick, Paige Newman, Kurt Schlosser and Anna Chan weigh in on topics ranging from TV commercials to movie hype to the latest celebrity blunder. We're not ashamed to admit our love for bad TV or reveal what's on our iPods, and invite you to join the conversation via your comments.



Has 'Lost' found itself?

Posted: Thursday, May 17, 2007 2:36 PM by Gael Fashingbauer Cooper
Filed Under:

If you're going to be vocal about the bad, you'd better be ready to speak up when things go well. I haven't been shy to say I've found "Lost" a bit of a turn-off this season, what with too much emphasis on unknown Others, Nikki and Paulo style characters turning up only to bite the dust, and so many of the original castaways left to do nothing but build sand castles on the beach. Last night's "Lost" episode turned things on its head, and in my mind, we're back now to the thrilling "Lost" that hooked me in the first season.

Charlie has never been one of my favorite characters, but his flashback -- really, numerous small flashbacks -- was one of the more engrossing ones of the season. As he faced possible death (did his brave underwater swim have anyone else remembering Shelley Winters in "The Poseidon Adventure"?), he decided to list his five favorite memories for sweetheart Claire. Viewers got to go back in time and see Charlie's favorite memories, and they were not only lively, but relevant.

He remembered Dad helping him overcome his fear of water, which was not only touching,but pertinent, as he prepared for a very scary swim. He remembered his brother and bandmate passing on a family heirloom. He remembered his pride at being called a hero for protecting a woman being mugged -- and, in true "Lost" fashion, the woman turned out to be Sayid's true love, Nadia. And he remembered his first night on the beach, introducing himself to a pregnant and lonely Claire. Even the non-romantic hearts in the audience had to say "aww" at that one. Sometimes on "Lost" the flashbacks slow things down, but not tonight.

The non-flashback parts of the show were all clicking, too. Who wouldn't root for a steely-eyed Rousseau stepping out of the jungle, prepared to share her knowledge of explosives with the castaways she'd once fought? And the idea of stocking tents with explosives when the Others expected pregnant women was both intriguing and exciting. Finally, the much-put-upon castaways, who've been caged, tortured, and made to eat fish pellets, might be getting their revenge.

Jack was back, Sayid was back, Desmond and Hurley all had decent-sized parts. We even saw those beloved lovers, Rose and Bernard, who fascinate old-time "Lost" watchers, but rarely get a line. There's another Dharma station, this time an underwater one, The Looking Glass. We learned how Rousseau's broadcast of more than a decade has been eternally blocked by the Others. There was even one of the famed "Lost" twists, when Charlie clobbered Desmond with an oar to ensure he got to at least attempt his sacrifice.

This was a "Lost" episode that satisfied on all accounts, and it only took them most of a season to get to it. With just the season finale remaining next week, I'm hoping that "Lost" is back on track for good.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I completely agree with you! This brought me back to the edge-of-my-seat excitement of the first season. I literally could feel the tension. I'm highly anticipating the finale next week.
Where in the hell have you been? Lost has been roaring back ever since "The Man From Tallahassee". You might not have cared for the Nikki and Paulo espisode, but that episode aside Lost has been "back" for a while now.
I agree with S.L. Last week's scene with Jacob literally gave me goosebumps.
I too feel this episode satisfied on all accounts. I didn't realize Charlie had encountered "Nadia" in the alley! Another thing.....they were told the Looking Glass station had been flooded. It seemed fully operational and dry.
Lost ROCKS! I agree, ever since "The Man From Tallahassee," Lost has been back on track. It just sucks that we're going to have to wait so long for next season
I agree! Lost is amazing now and the Season Finale is going to be epic
It was a great show. I loved it. Even had a couple of twists at the end. Charley's gone from one of the least liked to one of the most loved characters. Come to think of it, same thing happened with what's her name after she hooked up with Sayid. You know just before she was shot.
I agree with S.L., I've been thoroughly enjoying Lost since it came back from break! These eps have been GREAT!
Did anyone else think the mugger looked like Boone?!
LOST is the best show on television, hands down. And they have such good actors/actresses. The powers that be I was thinking didn't realize what gems they had in Dominic Monaghan and Naveen Andrews but now I'm starting to think differently. Save Charlie, save the world!
I agree with all of you,the show was back to it's best. Too bad this isn't the start of the season. Could Jack get his woman? Sayid his peace? or are they really playing out life in hell? Did the women in The Looking Glass the same ones in bed w/Charlie in that flashback???
I think we can all thank writer Brian K Vaughan for setting Lost on its way to being found. http://www.bkv.tv/pages/news.html
I think every episode since the hiatus has been great. It is great momentum going into next season.
Lost has been kind of blah for a little while. I was frustrated how they drag stuff out and not really solve much. But the last few episodes have been great! It's picked up to what got me hooked in the first place. It's just too bad they didn't get to the action sooner. Only one episode left and I want more. Bummer. Best show on TV? Almost. I think Battlestar tops it IMHO ;)
I am huge fan of Lost, but last night's episode to me, was weak. I hear all the good stuff being said about the episode, but it just didn't do it for me. The whole show seemed slow compared to the last couple of weeks. Moreover, the whole thing was so stale and predictable. We have been waiting and waiting and waiting on Charlie to die, the build up is almost anti-climatic, like, Charlie will never die as well as we have been built up to expect. Moreover, what is the deal with him saying he 'doesn't swim' earlier in the series, yet, comes clean w/ being a swimming champ, etc? I still think this show is being written based on viewer feedback and reaction.
It is unfortunate that the Lost writers feel it necessary to point out over and over again that they don't understand anything about radios. From the guys who claimed you need three people to triangulate a source, we now have ... an completely submerged radio transmitter! How do these howlers get on the air without a SINGLE person involved noticing???
My hat is off to the producers, writers, and cast in bringing exciting tv back into my life. I don't think the series has let me down at all. I am astonished by the creative twists and turns of the show. I am not one of those people who have to try to make sense of everything. I just want more of "Lost". I am somewhat saddened by the fact there are only 48 episodes left. I can't wait for the finale and hope to live long enough to see the show to the conclusion. How can you be critical of a show that has made you looking forward to Wednesday nights!
Charlie didn't come clean with being a swim champion, he was lying to get Jack to OK his taking the mission. Watch it again and pay attention to Juliet's reaction.
Not only is the Looking Glass station not flooded, it's stocked with hotties!!!!!!!!!!
Have ya'll been watching the same LOST as I have been watching???? This show rocks and rocks. Gosh, I don't want it to end for the season...I will be going through serious withdrawal...thank God for TIVO and ABC allowing us to watch on line. Keep up the great work guys.
I, for one, had to dry my eyes a few times during this episode. I even got a little choked up when Charlie hugged an unknowing Hurley. But I had to wonder, why didn't anyone think of cutting the power cable to the looking glass station, therefore cutting off their ability to jam the signal? Not enough drama, that's why.
Also, I am thinking we might be re-introduced to Walt and Michael at the very end of this season to bring us back for the next. (As if we weren't already.) Does anyone find their absence conspicuous? I'm pretty sure it wasn't permanent: These characters seemed far too important.
I agree with other posters, LOST has been back on track for the last 3 episodes! I think folks get frustrated not to know EVERYTHING yet, but if we did, what would the show have left to show us? Last night was great, i'm so glad to see Jack back! He remains one of my favorite characters. The finale looks good, and hope to carry us through til next year.
I think its great. EVERY character minor or major that we know is alive was in this episode. Karl, Alex, Danielle, Rose, Bernard, Sawyer, Kate, Jack, Sayid, Jin, Sun, Charlie, Desmond, Ben, Tom, Richard, Claire, Aaron, Pryce... probably more. Every single person had a part. And it was intense 'We're going to blow them all to hell.' was absolutely epic. Phenominal episode. Almost better than the Locke episodes (Man from Tallahassee, The brig, man behind the curtain) and that's saying something.
Hey Everybody- Don't get too sure of yourselves as the ABC people put some of THE Biggest suprises and turn abouts in the series history. They are going to twist mine and your minds until the end. So keep your eyes open for the keys to solving this for us.
Nope disagree. This episode was nothing but filler for the finale. We already figured out why Daniel was getting the explosives, and what Juliet and Jack were up to. Nothing happened in this episode. We didn't even get to see Charlie drop dead. I wish they'd stop taunting us with that annoying subplot every 3 weeks. If you're going to off Charlie than do it ALREDY.
Like Gilligan's Island, there won't be any rescue for 45 episodes or the show is over. Toying with us with a freighter 80 miles away that can't rescue them is just ridiculous. 48 episodes is way too many left. They should have finished it all next season in 16 episodes. I do want to see the back story of the Russian guy with the eye patch.
The best move the producers and writers of Lost made was deciding to bring the series to an end. All good stories must end. How they get to that ending will be very interesting.
Well, I , for one, have stayed with this show since it first aired. I like dramas. I like shows that are DIFFERENT. LOST fits that bill for me. It's true that ABC goofed up along the way..with the interruptions and scheduling. BUT the writers have put together a good MYSTERY. That's it plain and simple for me.
I am a Lost addict. I cannot get enough of this show. I think Michael and Walt will be back next week. Next week's episode will not tell you what you want to know, but it will keep you in great anticipation for next season.
Awesome show. This year has not been quite as good as the first two seasons but it has improved greatly over the past few episodes. I am still a HUGE fan of Lost. It sucks that we have to wait until mid-season next fall (January?) to see new episodes and then only get 16 per year. ABC, wake up and smell the coffee and quit screwing around with the schedule!
I definitely think Lost is back on track. The last two or three episodes have been great, and left me wanting more. A feeling I haven't been getting for a while. It's good episodes like this last one that make you realize how disappointing some of the other ones have been. I hope they continue to keep the exciting stuff coming.
Its still no "Office"
To all of the fair-weathered Lost fans out there that only say the last three episodes have been good... are you kidding? This entire season has been unbelievable! Why are people only interested if something is "blowing-up" or major plot secrets are revealed in every episode? It's not just about revelations and conclusions people, it's about the journey there! This whole season has rocked!
Does anyone else care that Maggie Grace is the most beautiful creature this planet has ever seen? Wht did she have to die?
Where is Lock? Must bring him back!
I agree with Russ about Walt and Michael. They just got on their boat and vanished. They need to come back with help or something. But the last episode was a good one. I didn't realize the woman that Charlie saved (in his flashback) was Sayid's love, Nadia, until someone pointed it out to me. It was also great to see Bernard and Rose again. They seem like such a sweet couple. It would be great to see more of those two. I hope next week's show answers some questions and wraps up a few ends. I also think the writers need to address Danielle's character. It would be nice to see Danielle's flashbacks and her story and history. After all we saw Desmond's story, so why not Danielle's?
I thought it was a fantastic episode. Got back to the people we've gotten to know since episode one, to the heart of them all. That's not to say I disliked season three. I loved the twists and the new characters and the history it showed us. I think the table is set for a good season three closer. Now, to just know that Locke isn't dead ...
I loved Wednesday's episode, but what's up with putting a new episode on THURSDAY night????without warning us!!! I missed it! It was probably a re-hash but it was titled "Answers"--I read this after the fact in a TV-listing. Thanks a lot, ABC, for letting us know this was going to be on!! UNFAIR! It was not even mentioned after the show on Wednesday. Could they at least rerun it, and let us know when??? RJ
Lost has been back on track since "The Man From Tallahassee", but I've loved the show all season long and enjoyed watching the characters develop as the season progressed. "Greatest Hits" just kept the ball rolling, and as far as Charlie being swimming champ, he was lying.
Lost stinks. The show is truly "lost," it's completely disconnected and boring with too many loose threads. The writers are making it up as they go. You people are in for A BIG let down, Just another in a long line of let downs. What a yawn.
Let's bear in mind that it was Juliet who told us that The Looking Glass had been flooded so whether she lied or was lied to by Ben us up in the air. We don't yet know who she's really working for. Though I don't trust her or Jack as far as I could throw Hurley.
If you haven'tfigured it out by now, EVERY episode is important. We may not fully comprehend what we are seeing at the exact moment, but it will be explained and shown it's importance at a future point. The Nikki and Paulo episode, although seeimingly pointless, will be brought to light in one of the remaining 3 seasons!
To Russ - Walt will not be abck. He had to be sent off the island simply because they are running in real time (therefore it is still 2004 in LOST time). Walt has aged 3 years in real life and not even crazy island logic can explain why he is rapidly aging...
I have been hooked on Lost since the beginning, but interest waned when Mr.Eko died. However, the last episode was worth hanging in there for! BEN and the black smoke are still the great enigmas. Why is he so twisted and what does he REALLY want from everyone? Why are the others still subservient to him? Who/what is Jacob? I can't wait to find the answers--hurry back, LOST!
does anyone think locke is done for? and where exactly is walt and micheal? will they be welcomed if they show up again? so many questions, so little time!
Prediction - Charlie's brother Liam is the father of Claire's baby. That's why Charlie has been unknowingly drawn to them, and that's ultimately how the "DS" ring that Charlie left in the crib will get passed down to Liam's first born son.
Charlie had to be able to swim in order to flip the switch. He wasn't lying so he could do the mission. It was an obvious inconsistency with Charlie's history. He "doesn't swim" in season 1 and now he is a swim champion. Maybe he lied about being a swim champion but after he jumped in the water...he WAS swimming. BIG MISTAKE BY THE WRITERS!
Who is Nadia?
? The past 6 epis or so of Lost have ranged from great to superb. Thursday's was NOT. (1) Charlie episode: ugh, can he die already? Other than Claire, he is by far my least favorite/least interesting character. Yeah, we get it, you were in a band, eventually got hooked on drugs, and never really did anything with your life..Yawn. (2) The epi was nothing more than a filler. It did not progress any storyline at all; merely setus up for the finale. No new info other than a description of the attack plan. Bleh can't wait to the finale but ugh, i hope it's a million times better than thurs


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://testpattern.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=194794