ABOUT TEST PATTERN

Don't touch that dial: Test Pattern tunes into television, movie, music and pop culture links, as well as gossip and idle chat from around the Web.

Every week, msnbc.com entertainment producers Gael Fashingbauer Cooper, Denise Hazlick, Paige Newman, Kurt Schlosser and Anna Chan weigh in on topics ranging from TV commercials to movie hype to the latest celebrity blunder. We're not ashamed to admit our love for bad TV or reveal what's on our iPods, and invite you to join the conversation via your comments.



Favorite moments from TV finales:

Posted: Friday, May 23, 2008 10:34 AM by Gael Fashingbauer Cooper
Filed Under:

Almost all the TV finales have aired ("Lost" comes next week), and looking back, only a few great moments stick out in my mind. (What about "CSI," you ask? Well, I'm not a devotee, but we're already having that discussion here -- and I'm not sure a brutal shooting of a favorite character counts as a "favorite moment" anyway.)

"Grey's Anatomy" -- Meredith lights up her house plan
The SuperCouple issue has always dogged "Grey's Anatomy." Meredith and McDreamy were set up to be together from the pilot, but like every good romantic drama, they get together, they break up, they date others, they vow never to see each other again, lather, rinse, repeat. Yet the final scene of Thursday's season finale, where Meredith used luminarias to lay out the floor plan of the couple's future house, was a romantic scene to weaken the knees of even the most jaded. (Although I live in Seattle, and I had trouble getting a dozen luminarias to stay burning for a party a few years back -- it rains and blows here, Hollywood!)

"Grey's Anatomy" -- Alex shows his vulnerability
But to me, the best scene and acting performance on the "Grey's" finale came from Justin Chambers as Alex Karev. Torn in many different directions as he tried to help a troubled Rebecca, he spilled the fact that he'd taken care of his troubled mother when he was young, and he insisted he could care for Rebecca. Seeing this powerful, cocky doctor break down and admit that he was unable to help his mom, but insist that now he was older and could do the job, was a real tear-jerking moment.

"The Office" -- Holly and Kevin misinterpret each other
I'm a huge Jim/Pam fan, but since Jim's proposal was stymied by Angela/Andy, I can't give that a "favorite moment" award. Instead I have to say the one plotline that had me laughing for the entire episode was how new HR rep Holly was led to believe that Kevin was working for Dunder-Mifflin under a special-needs type employment program, and Kevin's naturally ultra-laid-back personality did nothing to dissuade her from that belief. Meanwhile, Kevin had his own misunderstanding -- thinking Holly's solicitous attitude towards him meant she wanted to date. More Kevin, please. Less Jan. That's just my opinion...

"My Name is Earl" -- Earl gets back to the List
I love the gentle, goofy humor of "My Name Is Earl," having watched the first two seasons in giant chunks while on maternity leave. This season started off promisingly -- with Earl in prison, where, as it turned out, he knows a heckuva lot of other inmates and is quite adept at getting along behind bars. But when he left prison, landed in a coma, having 1950s-sitcom style daydreams of being married to Billie, and then came out of the coma and really married Billie, I started to lose interest. Now that the annoying Billie has joined the Camdenites and Earl and Randy are back to actual list business (as creator Greg Garcia promised on Television Without Pity), next season looms bright as Camden County's endless baking sun.

Share your favorite moments from TV season finales in the comments.

 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The finale of Newhart. hands down.  2nd place-Will & Grace
I, too, was very pleased with how Grey's Anatomy ended the season.  It definitely made me happy that I watched it :o)  I liked the moments you chose, but I also liked the "revelation" that Dr. Bailey is a sci-fi geek...It made me laugh to hear her go through the whole Han Solo story while the other doctors just stared at her...It kinda reminded me of my husband, who is also a bit of a sci-fi geek...
This year's "NCIS" finale was surprising...not the death of Jenny Shephard (who else would be expendable?) but the last scene where the new director reassigns everyone and gives hands Gibbs a new team!  Didn't see that coming -- should make the next season interesting (although I hope they don't repeat "House" plotlines).
The series finale of 'Newhart' is a classic. It was both a wonderful tribute to the original 'Bob Newhart Show' and a terrific jab at the horrible 'Dallas' 'Bobby-in-the-Shower' resolution. .
How about the House season finale?! WOW! I'm still getting over that one!

Welcome back, Gael!! I just found your column again today! I'm so happy! And congratulations on your little one!! Mine turns 2 next week. I can't believe it!
The best moment in "The Office" finale was the last moment, featuring Dwight and Angela in a very passionate embrace.  Kevin and Holly were fantastic, think Kramer and Mel Torme in that Seinfeld episode a decade back.  I could have done without Jim/Pam and the Andy proposal.  Just filler writing.  Season four was a mixed bag of so-so writing with some interesting plots.  I wish the writers could reach back and capture the fun of the first three seasons.
I thought the whole 2 part finale of House was fantastic.  Great performances by Robert Sean Leonard as Wilson, Anne Dudek as Amber and the always terrific Hugh Laurie as House.  For the first time, House showed some emotion as it was apparent he really cared.
How I Met Your Mother - The LOOK that Barney gave Robin when teased about the things that flashed before him when the bus hit him.

Grey's - Finally, Mere's free(er) of her mom-Derek issues.  Let's see if they can be together without being annoying.

Ugly Betty - That was some cliffhanger!  I think Betty will go the "I choose me" route, a la Kelly Taylor.
On the Office finale, Michael Scott and the new HR person, Holly, are sitting in the floor talking and Michael uses a goofy "Cookie Monster" voice. Holly gives him a "look", which subdues him for a moment, and then Holly responds to Michael's comment in the same goofy voice. The look on Michael's face was priceless. Holly seems to be a perfect match for Michael Scott (I guess it's true - there really is a match out there for everyone). We're worried sick about Jan screwing that possibility up for Michael by involving him in her pregnancy.
No kidding you're not a devotee of CSI, when half of your moments are from Grey's Anatomy.  BLAH
...and let's not forget the series finale of "MASH" - by far the best and most watched finale - ever.  although i disagree with the consensus mentioned. '...Earl' is not what i would deem to call good television.  it's just me.  I don't like the show.  I find it panders to the dumbing down of the nation.  As for 'The Office,' - see the above-mentioned comment.  And of course you notice, no one has mentioned the season finale of 'Criminal Minds."  Now that one is a cliff-hanger.  And to think I have to wait until September to find out who and why.  
The ending to Star Trek Deep Space Nine was great.  to this day, it is still the only Star Trek series to actually have a real finale.
The Gilmore Girls, Macgyver and Will & Grace , I liked the last episode of Newhart too, that had to be the most ingenious one.
Although not really part of the topic and I apologized, but I loved Crossing Jordan and really hated how they ended.
No not Men In Trees!! I loved that show, I was talking to my wife about that show. I hope they think again about that show. Leave it on.
What about ER?  Who actually got into the ambulance that was blown up?
Criminal Minds had an absolutely awesome cliff-hanger.  I don't want to see any one of them go!!  I was so disappointed about the non-Jim/Pam engagement: it reminds me of how I felt when my now-husband didn't propose the weekend I was expecting him to!  Well done by the screenwriters.
House definitely had the best season finale by far. It was probably the most intense, powerful, poignant and heartbreaking hour of television I have ever watched. And the acting was incredible! Hugh Laurie was fantastic as always, but Robert Sean Leonard and Anne Dudek blew me away with their amazing acting. I was especially impressed with Leonard's acting. Wow!!! I was in tears by the time the episode was over. Definitely the most memorable finale of them all.
--> Cinbad, that wasn't Cookie Monster Michael was channelling, it was Yoda.
I'm giving away my age by by nominees: "Newhart" nailed it. "MASH" was pretty good. Don't forget "Mary Tyler Moore".
Cheers had a great ending, but the best finale would have to be "Newhart"
I can't choose between Grey's Anatomy and Criminal Minds. They were both awesome. Grey's Anatomy was a relief with Meredith and Derrick reuniting (Rose was nice but too insecure for me) and Criminal minds was suspenseful with the SUV explosion. The split screen was awesome.
(@cinbad... it was a Yoda voice. not Cookie Monster. similar, yet different.)
Supernatural.  I figured they'd go with the usual TV formula and have Dean saved at the very last minute.  Jensen Ackles was excellent.  The only thing that could have made this finale better would be a Big Daddy Winchester cameo.
I am so happy you're back!!  I missed your blog immensely!  Congratulations!!!!!!!!
Newhart, MASH, and Mary Tyler Moore for "oldies", and Lost, Criminal Minds, Ghost Whisperer and House for the "newbies".  Don't watch NCIS or Earl.  And STOPPED watching Grey's - Can't stand MEREDITH!  Who would want this snively, whiney, nothing of a person?  yuck!  :-)


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://testpattern.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1058212

Syndicate This Site

Add Test Pattern to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google