ABOUT TEST PATTERN

Don't touch that dial: Test Pattern tunes into television, movie, music and pop culture links, as well as gossip and idle chat from around the Web.

Every week, msnbc.com entertainment producers Gael Fashingbauer Cooper, Denise Hazlick, Paige Newman, Kurt Schlosser and Anna Chan weigh in on topics ranging from TV commercials to movie hype to the latest celebrity blunder. We're not ashamed to admit our love for bad TV or reveal what's on our iPods, and invite you to join the conversation via your comments.



'Housewives' takes a big risk, and it works

Posted: Monday, September 29, 2008 6:00 AM by Gael Fashingbauer Cooper
Filed Under:

"Desperate Housewives" took a big risk with Sunday night's season premiere. Instead of picking up where the May finale left off, creator Marc Cherry rebooted the show, setting it five years ahead. And, miracle of miracles, it worked, at least for this viewer.


ABC
In the newly accelerated "Housewives" universe, Gaby and Carlos have two daughters.

(Warning: If you don't want spoilers for last night's season premiere, stop reading now.)

To me, the "Housewife" who was affected in the most interesting way by the five-year jump is Gaby. Since the show started, she's struggled with her transition from sleek model (and Eva Longoria is lovely, but at 5-foot-2 she'd never have been a couture model) to suburban housewife. She and husband Carlos fought, broke up, got back together, and endlessly seemed to have issues about children. Should they have them? Would they adopt? Use a surrogate mom?

Now, in the new world, they have two daughters. The five skipped years meant we didn't have to go through pregnancy and birth scenes, the inevitable water breaking at the baby shower scene, or the boring days when the writers realize they have no idea how to write an infant into the plot. Their oldest daughter, Juanita, is nearly five, and mom Gaby is worried about her child's weight. Of course, in true Gaby form, her idea of encouraging weight loss isn't to cook healthy and play outside with her children -- it's to make Juanita chase after Gaby's snazzy car, fully dressed in her princess costume. It should be interesting to see how "Housewives" deals with the controversial issue of overweight kids, and how Gaby's parenting foibles are further exposed.

Lynette's storylines should also benefit from the five-year jump. Her kids were kind of indistinguishable little Dennis the Menaces when we left the show in May. Now...well, they're still indistinguishable, being that two of them are twins, but they've graduated to high-school hijinx, such as running an underage bar and casino out of Mom and Dad's restaurant.

Susan, seen with a newborn in May, now has a five-year-old, a wrecked marriage and a new hunky boyfriend. I can't stand Susan, and I'm not on the SUSAN-N-MIKE TRU LUV 4EVAH team, so I don't really care about that. (Hope Julie's OK, though.)

Bree, though, may be my favorite "Housewife." In the new world, she has a catering business with Katherine, and the son Bree raised for daughter Danielle has been taken from her. And husband Orson is living with Bree, but things seem to have changed since we last saw him. He's kind of lurking in the shadows, as if Bree is embarrassed of him or hiding him, probably due to the all-but-forgotten plot where he ran over Mike. Certainly this plot will develop, and I for one am glad Kyle MacLachlan is still around as Orson.

The underrated Edie seems to be at the heart of the street's latest mystery, involving a new husband with a mysterious and violent past. Edie-less episodes are like days without sunshine as far as I'm concerned, so I'm hoping this plot bodes well for more Nicollette Sheridan this season.

When I first heard about the five-year jump, I wasn't sure it would succeed. Imagine "Grey's Anatomy" jumping ahead and making moody Meredith a mom, or "House" leaping into a future where House and Cuddy are married. But Wisteria Lane is just wacky enough, and has enough plot strands that can be twisted in enough directions, that a time warp doesn't seem all that contrived.

Did you see the "Housewives" premiere? Share any thoughts on what you saw -- or hope to see in upcoming episodes -- in the comments.

 

 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Not having read in advance about the 5 year jump, the promo "5 years in the making" was not immediately clear. However, once clear, it worked for me and clearly it opens a lot of new story lines. Clever ... and successful
I really liked the jump forward, instead of the usual soap fare, where everyone just changes partners, so that by the end  everyone has slept with everyone and the show has no place to go (cough cough Grey's Anatomy).  This was very creative and opens up a whole direction, which the show really needed. Suddenly I'm interested again.
I personally thought it was great!  I agree, I didn't really want to have to watch Gaby thru pregnancy and babies.  This is much more interesting.  I thought it worked really well.  I love this show and will be sad to see it end.  
I liked it!
Loved it...great idea!
I thought I heard somewhere in the lines, that Orson had done his time in jail. That was the requirement set by Bree, in order to take him back.
And mysteriously missing were Julie, Lynettes daughter and I thought one younger son? Hope it's not like "life with Bonnie" where the just fire a kid and never speak of it again!
Never thought, being a man, that i would ever be a fan of this show but my girlfriend made me watch when it first started and now i can't stop. Great writing and plotlines have kept me watching since it's beginning and i think the show is better for the five year jump. Things had gotten a bit stale and even i was tired of Gaby's schtick and the whole supermodel thing. To see her as just another slightly frumpy, albeit still cute, housewife was a welcome change. Edie, on the other hand looks like an anorexic pornstar. She used to be voluptuous but what's with the weight loss? Anyway, good show, never fails to make me laugh or surprise me.
I loved it.  Most of the women seem to have experienced what growing older is like.  Can't stand Susan either and don't like this guy she's with...I don't particularly like the "Susan and Mike love story" either.  Loved that the "gay" neighbors just non-chalantly took a picture of the hunk climbing out of Susan's window like it was a normal thing.

Where is Lynette's daughter?  How are Gabby and Carlos making a living?  
I thought it worked fairly well, though i am tired of the show focusing on the "do Susan and Mike Belong Together" angle.  That's the only part that feels a bit forced.

I thought it was great to see a different side of Gabby, and the conflict that Bree has been infused with is adding some additional depth to a character that was beginning to seem shrill.  I'm excited for the new season.
This plot device was dumber than the dream season on Dallas.  They lost me as a viewer after last night's episode!
I liked the show.  But Gaby's kid being 4 - give me a break. That girl talked, walked, acted like about an 8 year old.  please - that just didn't work.
I enjoyed the episode last night and it was nice to see the housewives struggle with real issues.  Usual laughs happened with Gaby & the daughter chasing after the car playing the new "game", Lynette's twins still getting into trouble and Bree trying to keep up her perfect image.  I agree and hope that a good storyline is in store for Edie this season. I always felt that Nicollette Sheridan was overlooked on the series.  Did they not watch Knots Landing where she played both a vixen and back stabber?  GO EDIE!!!!  We've seen enough of Susan's oh whoa is me character.  Really - how far can they go with her? And where is Julie?  No mention of her at all last night.  
I thought it was great. I am wondering about Julie though. And I am totally freaked out by the new man in Nicolette's life. Yuck
Susan needs to get a grip.  As usual Miss Namby-Pamby thinks everything is all her fault because of the accident.  Go to a shrink already and don't put us through this rediculous supposed affair between her and some rediculous younger man.  I guess he will be blackmailing her next.  She should have left well enough alone and let Edie have Mike, but since she supposedly loved him she married him.  Well so much for her.  Gabey is still just as wacko as she was before, but in a better way.  She cares for her children, she just doesn't have any idea what to do with them.  Carlos doesn't have any more of a clue than Gabey.  John needs to get his life back on track.  The cool John is completely rediculous.  The twins need to be sent to a military school as they have no respect for their parents or anyone else. Lynnette has all the patience that Gaby needs.  If I was her the twins would have been sent to a shrink 5 years before when John's daughter was there.  They could have had a group rate.  Bree is still Bree.  She needs to lighten up and stop being this rigid supposedly perfect housewife and mother.  Anyone that knows her knows it is a front for all her insecurities.  As for Edie, I just hope that "nutty" husband of hers gets caught before anything bad happens to anyone.
It was a hoot!  I like the jump in time too!
Just lost at least 3 viewers that I know of.  We waited all last year for Mike and Susan to get together and now the writers do this.  Not worth watching anymore, I was not impressed with the season premire at all.
I was not happy about the 5 year ahead jump.  Having watched the show from it's start, i enjoyed watching where it left off!  I hope it is all a dream and they wake up to what comes next in the scheme of things!
I loved the jump five years ahead!! Hope to see more of the gay couple as I think they add to the fun on Wisteria Lane.
loved it i thought i was the best season premiere so far can't wait for all the stories started
Hated house and Grey anatomys primiers.
Looooooooooooved it.....
What happened to Tom and Lynette's daughter Penny?  What about Edie's son?
What about Tom's bratty illigitimate daughter?
They need to bring back the wacky humor that the first year had. It made the show so much more enjoyable.
I did not like it. 5 years, wow who wants to see the sexy and superish gang in 5 yrs.? Not me atleast not for 5 yrs. Please put Gabby back...//. and why is Linnette still in a wig give us a break already. and just how old is Mrs. Mcclusky any way
I really enjoyed the future Wisteria Lane. It gives new life to a show that was stale. I think it also allow the writers more flexiblity to be creative. It is almost like watching the first season--it sort of feels "new".
I am glad Gaby is still herself even though she is a mom. She can't help being vain.
Susan and Mike will eventually reconcile in the end, mark my words. I like Eddie having a mystery finally. It will allow her more airtime. Unfortunally Bree and Lynette bore me.
I couldn't disagree more.  I disliked it from start and hated it by the end of the episode.  I hate using this term but the show has really jumped the shark.  They have make a cruel joke out of Gaby, buried Lynette in the same old subplot (enough already!) and made Susan unwatchable.  I understand wanting a chance to start anew five years into the future, but this is just an unwatchable and I predict a quick ratings decline.
I thought the show was GREAT!! and I think this  season will be fun to watch to see how they all got to where they are now!!!
excellent idea
I think the 5 years in the future was a smart move...I mean really every year for the last four seasons some amazing drama has stirred up Wisteria Lane...at that rate the show could've become unrealistic...with the five year time lapse, it makes me imagine 5 years without drama in the hood...now that's realistic!
Are you kidding-this is some of the worst tv writing I have seen in years. After all the good years-it is goodbye for good for me and Wysteria Lane-this reviewer must be an idiot.
I  think that the plots will develope well over the season.  I agree with you about Susan--my least favorite "wife".  Also, I think that the actresses playing Gaby's children are too old for the 4 & 3 year old's that they are playing.  
I think the five year jump did not work, and I hate Gaby's role now. You have completely changed her character, and it just does not work. I think to take a great show like "Desperate Housewives" and completely change every character to the degree you have, is too much change.
I haven't watched Desperate Housewives since the first season.  I've got to say that last night's premier was good...but like any soap style television show...it's easy to pick up even after seasons of not watching.

That being said, I'll watch and again next week.  They seem to have infused some new life into the show.
I hated it.....
I think it was brilliant. It provides the show with juicy new storylines immediately without the wait. More shows, but certainly not all, should consider it.  
I thought the jump was genius!  I am actually excited about the season this year. I am curious about Julie, and Lynette's other two kids.  Hopefully they will appear in later episodes.
I would like to see Susan and Mike back together.
I also think Linette should boot her husband out, she should tell him to be a man instead of another child.
I think Carlos should get his eyesight back SOON.
After watching soap operas for the 30 years, this wasn't much of an adjustment.The "soaps" re-invent their characters many times; bringing them back from the dead! Enjoyed "Desperate Housewives" last night.
Afterall,this is what makes many of these TV programs
like these so much fun to watch. They are purely
entertainment!
Too depressing and over the top.  Getting rediculous like usual.  Always some killer lurking in the neighborhood (Edies new husband).  Give me a break.  Where is the humor in this show anymore.  I think I will pass.  It is starting to resemble a daytime soap.  What I started liking about the show was the friends coming together.  Now it seems like the old crazy  Bree again.  Gabbys obese kids and blind husband.  Wow,  I sure want to watch that depressing situation more. NOT! And spoiled delenquint teenage boys. I think I'll turn on the comedy channel for some stress relief.
Hated it.  It was a jump the shark moment and I won't be watching this season.  My Sunday's are now free for football and Army Wives.  
I really didn't see much humor in the episode.  The overweight child story is hideous.  It was just plain ugly and cruel.  I don't see much fun for this year.  The mystery looks promising.  Hope it gets better.
I thought the season premier was hilarious!  I loved every minute of it and the 5 year jump was not what I thought it would have been.  Definitely interesting story lines for the new year with twists that we can all relate to.  And what a last minute clip to keep us coming back for more.  Who is this mysterious man and WHAT or WHO is he after?
For me the time warp was perfectly timed. Having dealt with cancer in our family it was too hard to watch the Lynette story line. I took a season off last year and really didn't feel like I was too out of the loop as I rejoined the current season last night. Edie and Gaby are the most fun to watch and last night didn't disappoint at all!
Save for Gaby's stupid "game" with her daughter, this was a great episode.  A big risk...but a big payoff, too.
Sorry but I hate the five year jump ahead, I want to know what happens all the time with the housewives, not miss five years of their lives. Why have you not restored Carlos sight? the whole show stinks now I dont like it one bit, Gabby should be glamorous as usual, Mike and Susan should be together. I bet you lose a lot of viewers
I'm not sure if I like the new Gaby (she's always been my favorite) but I'm anxious to see how she plays out. I wish they would've showed more about the Susan and Mike break-up b/c i'm lost.
I actually enjoyed it, thought I wouldn't, but did. Hope Carlos doesn't stay blind the whole season, and where is Lynette's younger daughter?  I would like to see Mike and Susan back together and was glad he didn't die, which is what I thought in the beginning -really enjoyed it and can't wait for next Sunday.
I was completely disappointed with the show last night.  The changes in the characters' lives were too far-fetched in some cases and there was too much not explained.  The Susan/Mike thing, Bree/Orson....
I was left wondering if I would still even watch the show.  this viewer is NOT HAPPY!
I agree...  Carlos and Gabby are the best!  Gabby is so "goofy" in her perceptions of reality... good thing she has Carlos to keep her grounded.  (Sort of like me and my hubby!)
I thought it turned out to be a smart move jumping forward 5 years. It allowed us to skip the 'in-between' (ie: Gaby preggo) but still allows for the possibility of flash-back scenes to fill in any missing gaps. Overall I thought the writers did a great job and I'm looking forward to the new season!
I'm only watching this new season for Gale Harold aka Susan's hunky new boyfriend. I know a lot of people who have never seen one episode of this show is only watching this season because of him. I've seen all the previous seasons (except the last, but I have it on DVD) and I'll probably just DVR this season and play catch up with it when I can. But, if any Desperate Housewives writers happen across this blog... MORE GALE HAROLD! It is what the people want!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://testpattern.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1437890

Syndicate This Site

Add Test Pattern to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google