'Idol' auditioners: Fakes or delusional?
Posted: Monday, February 02, 2009 6:00 AM by Gael Fashingbauer Cooper
Filed Under:
TV
"American Idol," you've been scamming us long enough. The jig is up, Simon and crew. There is just no way that the bright-eyed auditioners we've been watching for the last three weeks on Fox's "American Idol" are for real. NO WAY.

Fox |
Physics major George, a Jacksonville auditioner, had to have been putting us on.
|
Look, once you're 16 or so, you know what you're good at in life. To steal a line from "MST3K's" brilliant Mary Jo Pehl, I myself am quite proficient at listening to music. Reading, eating, watching TV, chewing gum, petting dogs -- these are all skills that I am quite sure I possess.
If you have a talent, especially singing, you know about it early. Your voice soars out over the other snotty-nosed kids in Glee Club. You're asked to perform solos at church, or you get the starring role in school musicals, or you start a band in your garage. I can still name the girls who were asked to do solos at my high school, and even on my most delusional day, I would not have put myself in their league.
So why, then, do these "Idol" auditioners show up brimming with overconfidence, then open their mouths and sound like alley cats with bronchitis? And they're universally stunned --- stunned! -- when Simon and the rest laugh at them. Their family and friends have always told them how great they are, they say. Music is their life, they cannot imagine doing anything else.
On what planet do these people live? Do parents and friends really lie like that? Were they born with a selective ear problem that cannot translate their own vocalizations? If their hearing is this poor, do The Beatles and The Shaggs sound exactly the same to them? I guess this would explain why Celine Dion is popular, but somehow I'm not buying it.
People want to be on TV. That's the only explanation. These folks know that if they show up, sing horribly, and claim they think they are great, they will get camera time. And they're right, they do. What amazes me is that none of them ever drop the facade, at least not that we're shown. Maybe there's a bunch of cutting-room-floor footage where someone yells "PUNKED!" in Ryan Seacrest's face and starts laughing about obviously he can't sing a lick, but hey, now his Internet girlfriend whom he's never met can see him on TV, and thanks for the free national broadcast network exposure.
Right? Or do you think people are really this much in denial about their own voices? Have you ever known one of these delusional auditioners, and were they for real? Share your thoughts.