ABOUT TEST PATTERN

Don't touch that dial: Test Pattern tunes into television, movie, music and pop culture links, as well as gossip and idle chat from around the Web.

Every week, msnbc.com entertainment producers Gael Fashingbauer Cooper, Denise Hazlick, Paige Newman, Kurt Schlosser and Anna Chan weigh in on topics ranging from TV commercials to movie hype to the latest celebrity blunder. We're not ashamed to admit our love for bad TV or reveal what's on our iPods, and invite you to join the conversation via your comments.



'Housewives' rebuilt itself this year

Posted: Tuesday, May 12, 2009 6:00 AM by Gael Fashingbauer Cooper
Filed Under:

(Warning: Possible spoilers for "Desperate Housewives" finale.)

Back in September, I wrote about the new five-year jump on "Desperate Housewives."


ABC
Creepy Dave was a great addition to this season of 'Desperate Housewives.'

I know that not everyone liked the time jump, but it worked for me right away. And now that the show has just one episode to go this season, I think it's made for one of the best seasons yet -- and possibly rejuvenated the show for upcoming seasons.

First off, the kids have been astonishingly quiet this season. And that's a good thing for a show that's called "Desperate Housewives," not "Desperate Offspring." Lynette's son, Porter, had an affair with a friend's mom and later was arrested for setting her husband's nightclub on fire. Other than that and a few aiming-for-humor plots about Gaby's overweight daughters, the kids have been mercifully quiet.

Speaking of Gaby, her resurgence has also helped the show.  Even if you can't relate to her  designer-label mania and incredible vanity, she comes off as likable and good-hearted. Her money-grubbing is funny, because she has absolutely no shame and doesn't care who knows it. Her storylines usually wind up with her learning a lesson in the end. Putting her back together with the easygoing Carlos (actor Ricardo Antonio Chavira is possibly the show's most underrated star) and presenting her with two daughters only gave her more plotlines.

I'm also a huge fan of Martha Stewart-wannabe Bree. It's only natural that she'd start a catering empire and it would both find enormous success and cause her personal life numerous trials. I like the affable Orson, despite his weird past, but their divorce was probably inevitable. It's interesting that Bree so condemned Orson's kleptomania, but it didn't take her long to resort to stealing herself, working with divorce lawyer (and Susan's ex) Karl to rob their own house.

The worst decision of the season? Killing off Edie. Like Gaby, she lent a light side to a show that could often be too depressing. (All of Lynette's plots and most of Susan's drag the show's tempo down, in my opinion.) Edie stood out as the one "Housewife" who wasn't really accepted, which gave the show a little depth. The other woman judged Edie, which made them less-than-perfect, and less-than-perfect characters are always more interesting. Plus, Edie's wild side lit up the often-boring suburb, and her unexpected bond with Karen McCluskey was sweet.

But Edie's newest husband, Creepy Dave, was a real find. Neal McDonough somehow manages to look both all-American innocent and like a guy who can't be trusted. The show was smart to not keep his real past hidden too long. Most viewers figured out that the horrible car crash had to come back into the plot eventually, and it would have been frustrating if half the audience knew he was the father of the dead family and half remained clueless. Integrating him deeply into Wisteria Lane by making him Edie's husband helped, too -- he was always around, and had a good reason to know the other block residents.

The preview for the "Housewives" finale looked ultra-promising. Dave's now set his sights on Mike and Susan's son, MJ, to make them experience the loss he felt when his daughter was killed. Orson may turn Bree in to the police for theft, which would be a satisfyingly juicy turn of events. And just to resurrect a plot we kind of forgot about, Lynette's cancer may have returned. That's murder, revenge, and illness, all swirling around in one show finale. It promises to be a satisfying end to what's been a satisfying season.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I hated the five year jump. Maybe I was in the minority but I despised it enough that I finally quit watching. I just didn't care after a while. (I happened to LIKE Lynette's little kids. They added some much needed comic relief.)

If the producers wanted the show to go in this direction, they had seasons by which to take it. If I wanted "time jumps", I'd watch science fiction. For me, this ruined a good show and lost one household of viewers.
I don't watch this show anymore either. Susan just acted dumb way too many times for me.
I agree that this is one of DH's best seasons, and the time jump helped that.  Loving Gaby and Bree's storylines, and Creepy Dave is great to watch.  I really hope Lynnette's cancer doesn't come back though.  That made the show way too depressing for me.  We can get our fill of illnesses on the medical dramas, we don't want it on DH!
I watched two episodes this season. The first episode turned me off so much I stopped watching. When I heard that Edie was killed off, I watched the next episode out of curiosity. It wasn't bad, but not good enough to make me want to start watching again. It is too bad - up to this season I enjoyed the show so much I never missed an episode.
I thought this season was a vast improvement over last year's.  Creepy Dave is really creepy and I'll be glad if he doesn't return next season.  Susan's new romance with a much younger man seeking a green card is typical of Susan's character...not thinking it would mean an end to her alimony. Mike should really be with Susan....he was a good influence on her and I think that would prompt all sorts of new scenes for future episodes.  I miss Edie, but maybe someone new will replace her in the neighborhood.
I would have to agree that Susan could be killed off and no one would really care. She's way too dumb. But I still do enjoy DH and look forward to next season.
I'm with you Amanda especially regarding Lynnette.
I did like the jump!  I, too, will miss Edie.  I thought she added comic relief, but also able to protray her true feelings through her comedy.  I really liked her interaction with Mrs. McCluskey (she's one of my favorites)!  I think it's been an interesting season!
I did not like the 5 yr jump at all, but in the end it all worked out and this season has me hooked again. I can always relate to Lynette and her kids, when she left them on the street corner I could definately relate to that urge.  I once threated my 3 sons with the same exact thing.
Lynette is not having a return of the cancer...she is pregnant.
Wouldn't that be a hoot?
Creepy Dave has been a wonderful addition to the cast and I will hate to see him go.
Bree and Carl will be a fabulous couple. Good Riddence, Orson.
I had stopped watching until they did the "time-jump". I think it brought the show back to life and I wish a few other ABC shows would consider doing something as dramatic. This has been my favorite season of DH, and moved the show to the top of my "must-see" list.
I don't think Lynette's cancer is back, I'm predicting she's pregnant again.... Wouldn't that be funny.
This has been an up and down season for me.  I can't stand Jackson, thank you Creepy Dave for turning him in to the INS.  But episodes without him weren't bad.  It was easy to ignore the time jump after a few eps and MJ not being a baby is actually a good thing.  What I just can't understand is how Gaby's daughter is older than MJ (I really hate continuity issues).  I admit, I have watched faithfully despite not loving the show.  I guess since there's nothing on on Sunday's at 9:00 it's better than nothing but I haven't loved all the changes.  
I like when DH is more serious. When the show falls into slapstick, I sit there watching and thinking "why am I watching this crap".

Of the time-line, I really liked what the writers did with Gaby. I enjoyed seeing her look more down-to-earth; I guess I could relate to that. I did not like that they had Carlos blind. He really is my favorite character and I'm glad the writers gave him his sight back.

I'm really sorry that the writers have made Katherine not interesting. I liked it better when she had "secrets".

Lynette and Tom could drop off the face of t.v. earth and I wouldn't miss them a bit. And, they could take their boys with them. I get tired of Lynette's screeching and Tom's helplessness. I just get tired of the boys.

Susan is annoying. She can go with Lynette and Tom! I do like her attorney ex-husband, though.

I like Bree and Orson and their storylines. I think the writers show, very well, Bree's struggles to be perfect. I like that Orson has thrown a wrench into her life.
Please we all know Lynnette does not have cancer again, she is pregnant again!!!
The two overweight daughters side theme seems a bit cruel to the two real children. They grow up with enough issues to cope with without characterizations running into reality.
All I know about Desperate Housewives is that that Marcia Cross has got to be the most interestingly gorgeous woman on the planet.  Have you seen her in those Mott's ads?  She is stop you in your tracks stunning.  She could make a gay man straight.....
I'm completely w/Gael. I love Gaby and Bree and I hated seeing Edie killed off, and yes, her friendship with Karen was very sweet. I can't really watch Susan for too long she drives me nuts and Lynnette, well, I'm just not a fan. I'm really liking Karl's character and Carlos, I've always been a fan of his.  
I agree that the "time jump" was a very creative, successful move to redirect the show. However Susan is becoming tiresome with her unrealistically stupid behavior and killing off Edie was not a good move; she added an important element to the mix.
I hated the time jump- I felt like I was completly lost and the show I knew was gone.  I think killing Edie of was a mistake- she had a light, funny element to her that carried the heavy load.  I think the show just got stupid with the leap and I quit watching it and when I catch it here and there I turn it off- it has not improved with age.  Just watch people- they will pull a Dallas on us and it will all be a dream next season to bring Edie back to life and to undo the stupidity of this season!!
At first, I didn't agree with the time jump.  Last May when I watched the season 4 finale, I was tempted to throw objects at the tv when I discovered Susan with Jackson.  I personally have  never liked Gale Harold to begin with.  So seeing him with Susan really irritated me.  Why ruin a marriage that so many people waited so long for, and so many people loved?  Ever here of "ain't broke, don't fix?"

I liked the idea of aging the Scavo kids, giving their family some drama.  Except Porter still dosen't know that Anne Schilling was lying to him about the baby.

To my way of thinking, Edie's death was inevitable.  She wasn't involved in the season 2 finale, season 3 she falsely attempted suicide, season 4 she was exiled from "the lane"---the writing was on the wall so to speak.  It's unfortunate only because Nicollette did such a great job with Edie, especially with no real story to work with.  Edie was never given a fair shot at being a "houswife" until her last season.  Then Marc Cherry kills her.  Way to go.

I would love to see more story involving Bob and Lee's characters.  It was so controversial bringing them on last season, yet they recieve virtually no screen time!!  I know they're not really housewives, but they could use some drama.  I personally would love to see a Bob/Tom/Lee triagle!!!  OOH LA LA!!  Break up the perfect Tom/Lynette duo, partner Bob with Tom.  Let's face it, some men are closeted their whole married lives, and then have to face the truth about themselves.  I think this would be a great avenue to explore.  And a guy like Tom would be perfect.  He's very straight-acting so it wouldn't be an obvious plot device. Unlike if Orson were to come out.

I think Gabby's story is in dange of becoming repetative.  She went from being a bored, lonely, wealthy houswife who needed a young stud to make her life meaningful to a mother of two who struggled.  Guess what.  She's back to being wealthy, Carlos' is working again, and Gabby's getting lonely again.  If I were Lynette, I would keep Porter FAR, FAR away from the Solis household!!!  History could end up repeating itself.  

On a semi-unrelated note, it would have been interesting if John Roland was Carlos' son.  Over the year's, Carlos has been said to have wanted a son.  John's mother Helen worked for an adoption agency.  I would lay odds that John is an adopted child. They could go back in time to when Carlos was younger (probably 17 or 18) he knocked up a young teenage girl, she maybe died during child birth.  Carlos never knew he had sired a child.  Meanwhile we have the Roland's who are desperate for a child...  Fast forward you now have a story where Carlos is the father of the man who once slept with his wife!!!!  That's good drama!!
Loved the time jump and don't mind if Lynette's cancer comes back. I'm a cancer survivor and find Lynette's character as a survivor of everything very reinforcing...not depressing at all.
Personally, I'm disappointed with this season.  The mystery that used to keep us hanging every season was put out there before half the season was over.

The episode of Edie's death finally brought back some of the suspense and the Desperate Housewives I loved in the beginning.

This season feels like it is tying up loose ends with no thought.  If this season finale doesn't catch me, I may no longer be a fan.... :(
I think this season of DH was one of their best too. Unlike Grey's Anatomy. They lost me with "Dead Denny" and I finally stopped watching.
I think Lynette is going to find out she is pregnant AGAIN!
Just started watching DH this season and I love it.  It has taken a while to figure out all the plots and I'm still not sure I understand everything.  I agree, the one mistake they made was killing off the slut of Wisteria Lane, Edie.  I loved her honesty and down right trampiness!  The show lost an important dimension in killing her.  I'll be watching next season to see if Bree really does kill off Orsen, whether Susan and Mike get back together and whether Lynette actually has cancer - I hope not - what a drag.  Her character is so much more interesting when they play her as the powerful, business woman.
I have been a fan of DH since it started.  I have hated this season.  I do not like Dana Daleny with Susan's ex.  I thought Susan and he were a better match.  I also like the Lynette's "brat" boys.  Thy reminded me of the mischief my brother did growing up. Can't the next season by like Dallas was (just a dream?)  I really don't know if I can stand another season of DH if it is like this season.
I really would have liked to have seen Gaby as a mother of a new-born. How did she deal with the dirty diapers, spit-ups, colic, diaper rash, and other daily happenings when you have a baby?  More details on the break-up of Susan and Mike would really be helpful in understanding their relationship. I really didn't care for the time-jump!!!!!!!
Don't you stil wonder what the truth was behind Kathryn's 1st husband, daughter, her Aunt that died, and her exc-husband was?  What was the point to introducing them to the show and then not telling anyone the rest of the story?
I would have to agree with Amanda, having the cancer come back is just too depressing! Plus, Lynette is a boring character anyways.
I was going to give up on this show, but then I heard Gale Harold was joining the cast and I freaked out! He is an amazing actor and I was happy to see him on the show. Once he's gone, I'm gone too. This show is too out there for me.
I absolutely love Desperate Housewives! I really love the new season, and I only wish that it wasn't over so soon. I've watched every single episode since the beginning, and I will watch it till the end. DH is my favorite show of all time!
Are you serious? No, no, no. The fifth season has to be the weakest season by far. Dave Williams has to be one of the worst villains yet. His mystery isn't even a mystery and it has dragged from the season opener. Katherine is practically wallpaper and the storylines are stale, repetitive and downright bland. Quite frankly, I believe "Desperate Housewives" is beginning to lose its appeal and that is sad. I have been a devoted fan since its debut in 2004. I think the writers should go back to to the drawing board for season 6, because this show is no longer juicy.
I loved the 5-year jump.  Expected great things.  Then they under-used Edie; and then killed her off.  They presented us with uninteresting plots that left Gaby as the only character entertaining enough to watch.  Stories are getting resolved and started in ridiculous ways.  Seriously, when I saw the first few moments of Bree sitting down with Karl to plan out her divorce, I turned off the show a soon as Bree agreed to rob her own house.  The suspension of disbeleif is totally gone for me with this show.   I'm done.
Can we kill of Susan please!!!  She is sooooooo annoying.
A few weeks after the rough transition, DH settled back into its regular level of interest. It has built up well to the finale. I look forward to it--and I hope Mike doesn't really marry Katherine.
I think Lynette should die next & Bree should find another husband that loves cooking & decoratiing & turns out to be a closet queen.Tom will cheat on his wife & end up giving them both AIDs.Susan will find comfort in Dave until he confesses to killing her son,Mj,Bree's new husband will admit he just wanted a trophy wife for his growing food business.
I quit watching the show due to Susan's antics, she is seeming to be unbeiveably self centered and not too bright...(more than the others...) and Lynette's personality just goes in too many directions.  She was strong once and focused.  I like all the men in the story.  I liked the 5 year jump and have now started watching again...
I liked the jump, but I really hate the whole Dave storyline, and I also don't enjoy seeing overweight children being used the way the young girls playing Gaby's daughters. It just isn't funny to me.
I couldn't watch DH anymore and though I really like all of the actresses--it got boring. It was at first, quirky and fun but then in the long run it is really just a soap opera and was tiresome.

Sometimes it's just not possible for the writers to keep up the sizzle of the lst or 2nd seasons because it's hard to top the uniqueness over and over again.

I too love the jump and hate that they offed Edie...she was my favorite.  I don't like creepy Dave and have seldom liked Susan's stories.  Lynette is the most real except that we seldom see her brood.  I only have 2 kids and they are ALWAYs around!  Gaby is forgivable as a climbing witch...but Carlo's miracle was ubelievable.
I also hated the time jump. I stopped watching and I had been a faithful viewer. I keep track on the internet, but it just isn't the same show. I want Mike and Susan back together, and I don't think that Edie should have been killed off. She is better than Katherine as the extra housewife.
I think that they will jump back to the past and Edie will once again be on the show.
If they were going to kill off a character, why couldn't it have been the boring, whiny, annoying Susan?
I love DH and it took a couple of shows to get into the 5 year leap.  I loved the little kids and the chaos they caused, it kept the show real and reminded us why it was called DH.  I'd like to see Susan grow up and be not so whinny.  I wish it would "back flash" 5 years every so often to better explain some of the confusing story lines.  
I love the show. I have watched every episode. Yes, I agree that Susan is a little ditzy at times, but she is sweet. I hate that Edie had to die but the show still has good writing as far as I'm concerned. I will continue to watch. Gotta go it is coming on right now.
I did not like the time jump either and to beleive that neither Susan or Mike had seen a picture of "Dave" as the grief stricken husband and father as laughable as splitting up their marriage because of a car accident.  Don't really watch the show anymore either.
Love the show and the 5 year jump!
I didn't think I'd like the 5 year jump, but I did.  And creeyp Dave was predictable, but a fabulous story!  Tonite's finale was great; please be Susan, please by Susan!
Indeed! Edie shoudln't have been killed and lynette's kids were more fun when they were young...


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://testpattern.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1928504

Syndicate This Site

Add Test Pattern to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google