ABOUT TEST PATTERN

Don't touch that dial: Test Pattern tunes into television, movie, music and pop culture links, as well as gossip and idle chat from around the Web.

Every week, msnbc.com entertainment producers Gael Fashingbauer Cooper, Denise Hazlick, Paige Newman, Kurt Schlosser and Anna Chan weigh in on topics ranging from TV commercials to movie hype to the latest celebrity blunder. We're not ashamed to admit our love for bad TV or reveal what's on our iPods, and invite you to join the conversation via your comments.



'NCIS,' I'm sorry I doubted you

Posted: Thursday, June 11, 2009 6:00 AM by Paige Newman
Filed Under:

I’m not going to lie. I watch a lot of television. But even with cable and my DVR, it’s simply impossible to watch everything. But this being summer, I decided to give four shows that I never normally watch a chance to impress me. Here’s what happened:

“Supernatural” (The CW)
It’s a bit hard to jump into this show without ever having watched it, but I have to say, I enjoyed it. The episode I watched had sort of a “Back to the Future” plot about Dean (Jensen Ackles) going back in time with help from an angel, to stop the yellow-eyed demon that would eventually kill his parents. This was a two-part episode and I really want to see part two. The show reminded me a bit of “Buffy the Vampire Slayer.” But the one thing that worried me about this show was that there wasn’t much humor. The boys (although Sam, played by Jared Padalecki, was hardly in the episode) seem to be on the same “I’m tortured, but I’ll just keep going” path that David Banner was on in the “Incredible Hulk” episodes of my youth. I may keep watching, but tell me why I should. Is there ever any humor in this show?


CBS
Mark Harmon and Cote de Pablo prove to be much more interesting than I thought they'd be on "NCIS."

“NCIS” (CBS)
Maybe it was my long-standing aversion to Mark Harmon, but I really wasn’t expecting to like this show. But was I ever surprised. Of the four shows, this is the one I will definitely keep watching. I loved all the characters, especially former Mossad badass Ziva (Cote de Pablo) and the gothy Abby (Pauley Perrette). Heck, I even thought Harmon was kind of gruff and interesting. I actually watched two episodes – one from 2006 and one from this past season – and even though I had never seen this show before, I was able to jump right in. My question for readers is: What is the best season of this show? My Netfix queue is calling.

“The Mentalist” (CBS)
When I first heard about this show, I was intrigued, but I never got around to watching it until this past week. And I was disappointed. Patrick (Simon Baker) is nice to look at, but so smug that I kept waiting for someone to hit him. It was puzzling, because I love “House,” but House is so flawed that there’s a certain amount of irony in his smugness – his narrow skill set is the only thing he has going for him. And he's pretty tortured. Conversely, Patrick seems to blithely glide from murder scene to murder scene like a game show host. The show is not helped by the ever-irritating Robin Tunney; oh, how I cheered when she was killed off “Prison Break.” Yet, this show is incredibly popular. Why?

“Two and a Half Men” (CBS)
When it comes to comedy, I’m definitely more of an “Office” or “30 Rock” person. “Two and a Half Men” is like a throwback to another time. In fact, watching it, I kept being reminded of “Three’s Company.” It has that same “what kind of misunderstanding will fuel this week’s episode” feel, with tons of double entendre humor thrown in to boot. There is a certain gentleness to the humor. No one is ever going to feel uncomfortable watching “Two and a Half Men.” It’s the opposite of something like “Curb Your Enthusiasm,” where I find myself giggling and cringing simultaneously. But what really struck me was that “Men” wasn’t all that funny. I only laughed twice, and I rolled my eyes more than a few times. It’s one of those sitcoms where you can easily play the “guess the next line” game. Is it the gentleness that keeps people watching?

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Well, of all of those I only watch NCIS - have to say it was originally because Mark Harmon is nice eye candy (sorry but true) - I keep watching because I love the show.  I also loved JAG (from which NCIS is a spin off).  I can't tell you the best season but I can tell you the best lines:
Kate:  I wonder what Duckie looked like as a young man
Gibbs: Illya Kuryakin
Best Season of NCIS is iffy -- if you are NOT going to be watching the latest episodes for the new season, then Season 1. If you are going to be watching new episodes, Season 3 but it requires watching a few episodes in Season 2 + the finale. (How Ziva becomes a part of the team.). The best season overall is probably Season 5.
The Mentalist and NCIS are on my must watch half dozen. You have to watch The Mentalist from episode 1 and understand the Patrick Jane backstory. While the character is smug and often flip, his quest for revenge and the damage he's hiding offset most of the smugness, because you know it's armor. Personally, I like the interplay with Robin Tunney, Tim Kang is very good, and Amanda Righetti, well, what can I say? If the plot slows, I can always just look at her.
You really need to see the first years of the Show!

Start at the Begining, Sasha Alexander was Great as Kate Todd! I Love Cote too. so much back story that is carried on from the start.
The first 3 seasons of NCIS are great...actually they all are...you need to watch from the beginning especially with how Ziva came on board.  It's a great show, I am a devoted watcher and love the dynamic of all of the characters.
As far as NCIS, all the seasons are great - if you start with season 1, there is definitely an ongoing storyline all the way through.  Season 1 had Catherine in it, though instead of Ziva.  I, personally, liked her better, although I do kinda like Ziva.
Supernatural is often very very funny. I mean, they had an episode called "Cris Angel is a Douchebag." What's not to like?

I thought the first couple of episodes of The Mentalist were good, then they went downhill.

NCIS is strangely addictive.
You have to watch the Mentalist a little more. He is flawed, tortured by the murder of his wife and daughter. Thats why he seems cold, so he doesn't have to relive it at every murder scene, he just cathes the bad guy.
re: NCIS...any season without Lauren Holly is a good season.  She was utterly miscast as the team's director (no tears shed here when they killed her off last year).  Or you can just fast-forward past her scenes since she didn't add much anyway.
NCIS is one of my favorite shows, next to The West Wing.  It's the way it's written, story lines, and the whole cast that makes it a winner in my book.  If there is one show that I make sure I set my DVR to record it's this one.  I even enjoy the repeats and marathons on the cable channels.

A+ show in my book.
Yeah, Supernatural has tons of humor.  There's an episode where Dean is infected by some kind of fear thing, and it's hilarious.  The show makes fun of itself regularly, too.  Probably more humor in later seasons but definitely keep looking if you want to see the lighter side of the show.

And the Mentalist I really enjoy.  He's just so charmingly manipulative, but when he tells the boss his intentions about when they catch Red Simon, you can see just how deeply damaged the man is, too.
I just discovered NCIS a few months ago and am now watching everything I can find.  It has both great character development and the ability to just drop in.  Brilliant.  I discovered JAG only a couple of years ago and am delighted that it is still on the air.  I also love Mentalist, but you have to see the first episode and be intrigued with the whole body language / subtle clues thing - which I am.  While I have loved the CSIs, I am getting tired of gruesome scenes so this is a nice break.  Also love Burn Notice and In Plain Sight.
OH yah, and When you do start watching previous episodes of NCIS, be sure to pay attention to the geeky assistant of Duckie's.   Turns how he's quite the sex addict.  There's a few episodes of him having sex in the morgue!  HA!
Best season by far of NCIS is this past one. The story lines were gripping and the character development was awesome. You can find all of the new season on hulu. I gave up cable so I view online a great deal.
NCIS is a great show.  To bad it airs opposite Nova on PBS.  Oh well, that's what VCRs and other tv recording systems were invented for. Donald P. Bellisario knows how to make a great tv show.  He has an excellent track record-Magnum PI, JAG, Quantum Leap.
You started on an odd episode of Supernatural. Give it another try with an episode from a previous season that involves both brothers interacting. It's one of my favs. (Specifically, there is a really toungue-in-cheek episode that takes place on a movie set from either last season or the previous. I wish I could remember what it was called.)
I cant say the best season but I can tell you some of the best episodes:
Season 2- Call of Silence
Season 3- Kill Ari 1&2, Hiatus 1&2
Season 4- Escaped, Twisted Sister, Deadman Walking, Angel of Death
Season 5- Requiem, The Ex-file
Season 6- Legend 1&2, Heartland, Cloak, Dagger

Some of these focus on Gibbs backstory, but everyone else is an open book so when you see what makes him tick it is more impactful and very enlightening.   He is the driving force of the team so his backstory effects how he and his team work.  I think Tony is one of the best characters he is a player, but you see there is a lot more to him than that.


I love NCIS and have since the beginning, it's one of my must see shows. I also love love love the Mentalist. As others have written, Patrick's "smugness" isn't really. It's his way of protecting himself. His backstory is that he pretended to be physcic to make money and smugly(!) taunted a serial killer on the air. He went home to find his wife and child brutally murdered by this killer. He had a breakdown and was institutionalized. Now he only searches for killers and hopes to find the man who killed his family. If you know this, I think it is much easier to understand his attitude.
Like Susan, Denver, I liked NCIS from the start as a JAG spinnoff with Mark Harmon eye candy. I have enjoyed seeing Michael Weatherly's growth of the DiNozzo character. He made a two-dimensional, skirt-chasing Tony into a man with real character. I'm just sorry he had to get his heart broken in the process. As much as I like the Ziva character, her presence at NCIS is unbelievable, so I have a bit of trouble with it. We'll see what happens next season!!
Supernatural is very angsty, yes, and you picked a particularly angsty episode to start with. While the humor is often dark, it is there. Season 3's "Bad Day at Black Rock" and "Ghostfacers" were pretty funny, and season 4's "The Monster at the End of This Book" is possibly the best thing ever.
Mentalist - I could watch Simon Baker all day - mentalist or not. Robin Tunney on the other hand is the reason I don't watch unless there are no options. Love NCIS though!
Toby, you mentioned West Wing, and Mark Harmon's role on NCIS came directly out of his several episode appearance on West Wing as a Secret Service agent.  Paige Newman must be one of the few not to like Harmon, he is one of the most popular actors on TV.  

Mentalist is a good show but I never get to watch - they keep putting it opposite something else.  Now it has been moved directly opposite Burn Notice, so forget that.  Simon Baker is good in the role.  I loved his old gloomy role in The Guardian, and I'm surprised I like his cheerful role so much this time, but I do.
Start watching NCIS from the beginning; Abby's attitude was calmer and she was not so hyped up on caffeine drinks, Gibbs actually smiled more than once an episode, and Ducky was not so Ducky! It's great to see how the tweaking of their characters made them become the extended family that we can all relate to. Without those changes I don't know if it would have made it...now it's not to be missed!
I agree with the other comments about The Mentalist.  You have to see the other episodes to understand why Jane acts the way he does.  It's not a show you can jump into and "get".  
Supernatural is often funny, if you have a twisted sense of humor.  :P  Most shows don't have EVERYTHING laid out and included in each and every episode.  You should know that by now.
NCIS should probably be started from season 1.  Though, you learn a lot about each character in different seasons, so it depends on who you want to know the most about.  Tough call.
I can't stand the actors in Two and a Half Men, won't watch a thing with them in it.  Yuck.
You have to start at the beginning with Supernatural--this was a season 4 episode, and so you missed the character dynamics and the hows and whys. My husband started watching this show with me, and he enjoys it almost as much as I do.  If nothing else, go to IMDB.com and check out the show quotes and trivia.  There's humor throughout.
I absolutely LOVE NCIS!!! I didn't really have too much of a prob with Lauren Holly, and I think that Mark Harmon is awesome!!
I think every season of NCIS has been great. I really like Ziva and Abby, the way they handle the guys comments.

Simon Baker on the Mentalist has the most sexy eyes...keep watching.
NCIS is my favorite.  I just love Abby, but I could do without all the Tony jabs.  My favorite eposide is "Dog Tags."
Being a women studies professor, I usually don't watch "guy shows."  The strong female characters in NCIS are a welcome relief and I never miss this show. Abbey is my favorite; a woman who unapologetically does math and science AND computer technology. WOW! Watch all the seaons.
NCIS is by far one of my favorite shows.  Yes, I do agree that Mark Harmon is great eye candy. I guess to really understand all the dynamics, you need to watch all the seasons, although my favorite was this past season. I think it is one of the best shows on TV at this point.
I watch all of these except for Two and a Half Men.  Love them all.  Supernatural is a riot sometimes - you just caught one of the "darker" episodes.  Give it more of a chance - it really is addictive.  NCIS is fabulous with the exception of the Tony/Jeanne season which was only tolerable.  The first three are probably your best bets.
OMG! I love NCIS, I dvr every single episode, I originally started watching it also because of Mark Harmon, I have carried a torch form him since he was in this show called 240 Robert, with John Bennett Perry & Joanna Cassidy, after that I was hooked and watched everything he was in. However, NCIS is my favorite Harmon venue.  My favorite line is when Tony is describing wat a rio is and then said its also known as a gib 1 B and Kate asks why Gibbs needs 2 adn he says the other stands for bastard.. Although I started watching because of him, I love all the characters they just blend so well together...
The Illya Kyriakin line was classic also.. Sadly though I dont think anyone under the age of 25 actually understood that...
Oh man, the best season of NCIS?  I don't know if I can pick, but I say to start with the one where Ziva came in.  I LOVE her character, and the storylines throughout are just so interesting.
I've always liked Mark Harmon so NCIS was a must for me.  I love it and every main character.  I was so disappointed when Kate died, but Ziva's character is just as good, if not better.  The best season????  They're all good!
NCIS - start with the last season, then when you have time, watch all the other seasons.  Lauren Holly was not the best director, but she had a great exit.

Mentalist - not sure why it is so popular except the cast works great together.  Although you will find 99.9% of the time, the killer is the first person you see on the scene.
I love NCIS and Mentalist, I have never watched the Supernatural but I will deffinately give it a shot as it sounds interesting.  I am not a fan of Two and a Half men.  NCIS has a new spin-off this fall, they introduced the characters a few weeks ago and it was interesting as well.
I just wanted to say that it is a little hard to watch Supernatural starting with the newest season.  While the episode where Dean is sent back is a good episode, it doesn't have a whole lot of humor.  And all of the humor in the show is more Dean's little one-line zingers.  "Demons, I get.  People, not so much."  There was also a great episode that was pretty much making fun of Ghost Hunters.  So try it from the beginning of a season, and pay attention to the first few minutes where they give a recap of previous episodes that are relevant to the one they're showing.  It's a damn good show, I got my girlfriend hooked with a single episode from season 4 and then she insisted on watching the first 3 seasons.
NCIS is one of the few series I pay for DVD collections.  It's not cheap but worth the moola. I am glad to see it stands up well in the ratings always going up against American Idol in the spring.
A favorite episode: Season 2 - The Meat Puzzle - good blend of drama, humor, fear - something NCIS is so good at.
start watching the end of season 2 and watch season 3
NCIS, is the SHOW to watch. I have seen every episode over and over and over again. "Eye Candy", Harmon and Weatherly, both qualify. But I am a "Ducky" man and watched him as Ilya Kurikin also. Was in LOVE with him then and now. Soo, Gibbs or Ducky?? Hard choice.
All seasons the best, but the end of this one the most reviting I do believe. Can not wait too see how they finish this one!!!

 Mentalist?? Well watch but don't really pay attention, not too bad. 2 and half men, sucks in my opinion, don't care for either of the actors.
There is no better show on TV than NCIS. All the characters are great, i just dont like the new director. I hope this show beats 10 seanson on the air. SIMPLY THE BEST.  
It's so hard to pick a favorite season of NCIS, though I do agree with others that it just keeps getting better and better.  There's no bad season, per se, so you might as well start at the beginning.

And though I don't have a favorite season, I absolutely have a favorite episode - Call of Silence from season 2.  Particularly touching if you know that the guest star, Charles Durning, is a WWII vet who was on the front lines for some of the most heroic and horrific moments of the war (Normandy and the liberation of one of the concentration camps).  Also, it's prime example of Gibbs full devotion to ensuring justice for the men and women in uniform.
Supernatural is an awesome show... my favorites are the bad luck rabbit foot one and the funniest was the ground hog day one where Dean keeps getting killed...
Wow, I didn't realize there was so much passion for NCIS. Personally, I think it is one of the worst shows on television. The characters are over the top and very annoying. The way they solve cases is next to impossible most of the time. The two agents that work under Harmon are complete dopes and would never hack it in a real investigative agency. I understand it's a  television show but I cringe every time I see it.
NCIS is a good show with interesting likable characters but has a "majorly" flawed plot line.  Since when does any military organization have any, I say any, jurisdiction off a military base or reservation?  These people are out sticking their noses in places where they have no business.
there are always several eps in the supernatural season that are designed to be funny (and are) and there's a lot of subtle humor in most of the episodes.  I love the show and highly recommend it.
NCIS has been one of my favorites since the first episode. Any show that offers Mark Harmon and David McCallum has to have something on the ball, and the other cast members are mostly great too. The new NCIS:LA I will probably pass on. To me, the ensemble cast of NCIS is as much of a draw as any storyline they can come up with. I wasn't impressed with the cast of the spin-off and I don't care for shows that feature constant action.

The Mentalist is also one of my favorites. Patrick Jane is like House in some ways: they are both damaged and wear a coat of protective armor. I like to watch Jane bob and weave his way through the storyline. I'll continue watching both shows. And I am delighted that CBS is picking up Medium, which I enjoy. NBC's loss; CBS's gain.
I disagree with 2 1/2 Men. The show is usually filled with double ettendre and cute quips. Watch the reruns the earlier seasons were the best.
Hands down I choose NCIS as my all time favorite.  Started watching re-runs earlier this year and have become addicted. The Bellasario Team has some of the best writers, and actors on TV. Like the way Gibbs works his team.  And that Michael Weatherly (Tony) sure helps me get through my days even with my cataracts I know EYE CANDY when I see it! . Everyone of the actors is outstanding.

One of my favorite lines was from the episode at the airport while the team is waiting to go through TSA  security with their weapons.
Gibbs: "We're LEOs". (Law Enforcement Officers to those in the know)
TSA Guy:" I'm an Aquarius and today is a . . . . . . Blah, Blah Blah.
Also like the reference to Ducky when he was in the Man From U.N.C.L.E.
My husband would never watch NCIS with me until this last season.  He became as addicted and has since watch every episode prior.  All of the seasons are definitely worth watching - over and over.
NCIS is one of my favorites alone with Bones, Burn Notice and Psych.  Leverage is begining to grow on me though.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://testpattern.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1959155

Syndicate This Site

Add Test Pattern to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google