David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Dana C, Frederick, Maryland — Wed, 21 May 2008 02:53:18 GMT

Before tonight, I thought it was close and that David C. had the upper hand. However, David A sent it out of the ball park. He has an incredible nigth and did everything beautifully. I will be shocked if he doesn't win.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Alyssa, TN — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:11:39 GMT

I absolutely love David Cook and I still believe he'll win. Sure, Archuleta has a good voice, but all he sings are pop ballads. I'm more of a rocker myself so maybe that's just me and I like faster songs. But, AI hasn't had a rocker win yet...he deserves it. I think Archuleta is just too naive and young to know how to handle it. I've never been a fan of him since he sang "Imagine" the way he did. If the boy can play piano, why not play it on that song? It's super easy to remember. I don't know, I just hope the fans will decide who should really win it. If Cook wins, I will know for a fact, the first time ever that it was a singing contest this season instead of a popularity contest.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Simon Says, Los Angeles, California — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:15:12 GMT

Thousands and thousands of people paid $10.00 each for a chance to enter the 2008 American Idol Songwriting Contest, And look what they got.......So how many will it take till someone calls this fraud? 1. Top 20 American Idol Songwriting Finalist (Andy Zulla) is an engineer on Clay Aiken, Kelly Clarkson, Diana DeGarmo CD's. 2. Top 20 American Idol Songwriting Finalist (Windy Wagner) is a backup singer on the NEW Clay Aiken CD. 3. Top 20 American Idol Songwriting Finalist (Ryan Gillmor) wrote the theme song for the Fox television show "Unhitched". 4. Top 20 American Idol Songwriting Finalist (Dan Yessian) wrote jingles for Ford Motors. 5. Top 20 American Idol Songwriting Finalist (Luke Ebbin) is a producer on Austalian Idol 1st place runner-up Shannon Noll's CD. 6. Top 20 American Idol Songwriting Finalist (Regie Hamm) (FYI...USAToday.com has named him the Songwriting Winner), is a co-writer on the NEW Clay Aiken CD and he's also a co-writer of the winner of 2007's American Idol Songwriting Contest Scott Krippayne......Anybody see a pattern Yet? 3 of the 2008 American Idol Songwriting Contest Top 20 songwriters get credit on Clay Aiken CD's. Out of thousands and thousands of entries, 3 out of 20 work with Mr. Aiken. and nobody has a problem with this? The 2008 American Idol songwriting winner and 2007 American Idol songwriting winner are song co-writing partners and that's fine with everybody? If not then please visit ....... http://americanidolexposed.weebly.com .......for all the facts

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Dorothy Ray — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:15:59 GMT

I still think this years win will go to David Cook. He deserves it. He is the most marketable and really is the best singer. He is the one out of all the Idol winners that I would buy his CD tomorrow!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Sherry F, Marshall, MO — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:18:34 GMT

Yes, I do believe Simon was using reverse psycology on the voters. He has said several times outside of the show that his favorite is David Cook. We'll just have to see how it all pans out tomorrow night.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Jim Loveridge, Cedar Hills, Utah — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:22:22 GMT

David Archuleta is the better performer of the two, has a better more consistent voice and clearly out performed David Cook tonight. Archie will win hands down. D. Cook however is destined to greatness!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

JoAnne, Tucson — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:25:34 GMT

I've never cared for Archie (David A), and I'd never buy one of his cd's, so I really don't want him to win. I'll be buying Cookie (David C.)'s cd when it comes out, so while I'd like for him to win the title, in the end it doesn't matter if he does or not. In fact, it might even be better for him if he doesn't. Would Chris Daughtry have had the freedom to do what he did if he'd won? It seems to me that the winner would be tied up in all sorts of obligations and have less freedom than one who didn't. Oh well...Wednesday night will definitely be interesting!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Rhino — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:36:58 GMT

If you just listen to the voice, Archuleta is the best by a mile. David Cook is a much better performer though. I have loved his originality all season long.

I am bias towards Archuleta because I'm from Utah but I love Cook too. I'm really torn on this.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Linnette — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:37:32 GMT

It was definitely David A.'s night. Based solely on tonight he would win. But based on the season, any one can win. It will depend on their fans. They both are great singers - just with different styles.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Myriah, W-B Pennsylvania — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:42:26 GMT

I was reall upset with Simon tonight. I watched him on Ellen this morning saying how much he liked Cook, and then he won't even give him a positive comment. I am definitely a big Cook fan, although I know that Archuleta has serious talent. However, in the long run, David Cook is MUCH more marketable and will do much better in sales in the future. Archuleta has a great voice, but he has not been showing change or ability to swap things around in the last few weeks...I don't understand all of the praise he is getting. David Cook has become popular for his ability to change to the music styles and every week puts his own twists on each song, which makes him great. I'm voting till 1:00 people, as I hope are you!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Mike, Salt Lake City, UT — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:44:40 GMT

There can be no doubt that both of these young men are extremely talented in their artistry...There can be no doubt that they both have potentially long and distinguished careers in the music industry. For this purpose, though, one singer must be crowned. It really is a talent contest morphing inevitably into a popularity contest. We can't help but gravitate to our favorite contestant and find comfort in the fact that perhaps millions are gravitating in the same way. The challenge, as voters, is to look past the crowds supporting one another in their choice, and to focus exclusively on the performances. I have spent the past few weeks closely watching the two Davids. When I hear a song sung, I want to be moved emotionally and spiritually...I want a goose-bump tingling feeling and I want to raise my arms in gratitude for a feast of the music. I have looked for this in David Cook and, while there can be no denying his extraordinary talent, I have felt more DRAINED emotionally and spiritually...his music, to me, takes a great deal of physical energy to appreciate. I can be exhausted after hearing him sing. By contrast, when David Archuleta sings, tears have come to my eyes and I have felt compelled to fall to my knees in awe and appreciation for the purity of the voice coming out of his mouth. Music, for me, is the antidote to the stress of everyday life and my days will end more peacefully with the melodic sounds of David Archuleta spilling gently from my iPOD...David Archuleta! American IDOL 2008!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Anna IL — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:45:10 GMT

I hope everyone doesn't jump to Simon's tune. How arrogant, calling the winner of each round even while stating it's just "his opinion. sorry!"

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Alexa, Virgina — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:47:02 GMT

Voting for Cook as we speak..it's 11:44 and I haven't gotten a busy since 11:00 :( and the votes have been one after the other. He's the best and most prepared for what comes with the American Idol title. On a side note I hope Archuleta's father doesn't win.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Craig, Las Vegas, NV — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:47:37 GMT

If you were going to pay money to buy a ticket to their concert who would you want to see?
Cook or Archuletta?
Who is the more entertaining?

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Mike, Salt Lake City, UT — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:50:13 GMT

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Janice Weber — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:55:45 GMT

I vote for David Cook. ALL David A. can sing are pop ballads. He tried one fast song and was put down. He never tried another one. He sounds like a Sinatra Crooner, a little old fashioned. David Cook was able to make every song his own. I know as a music teacher that David Cook is more versatile and marketable. He could be a new "Beatle" in the future.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Dawn Eymard, Edgewood, New Mexico — Wed, 21 May 2008 03:56:35 GMT

David Cook is an entertainer, whereas David A. is boring. He has no stage presence, and always closes his eyes and licks his lips when he is singing a song. David Cook can sing any type of song, whereas David A. sings ballads. David A. cannot sing up to date music. He attracts tweenyboopers. I think David Cook deserves to win, but if he doesn't he will out sell David A. in the long run.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Adee AL — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:00:40 GMT

As much as I love Cook, I think Simon said what had to be said. You have to admit that while the Cook's final song was extremely well done, it was a really odd choice for his last song. And coming off of the chicken s### he was forced to make into chicken salad, he really should have chosen something a little better.

Archie did what he always does... belt the predictable power ballad. This time he did it with just a little more passion... and since this contest is tailor made for the unoriginal, Cook got slammed because he didn't blow the doors off like he has in the past.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Taz, Texas — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:01:55 GMT

The only reason David C. got "emotional" and cried was because of the reviews Archuleta was getting from the judges. It was a self-articulated PITY party. I have a gut feeling that it is going to work much to Archuleta's demise. Is it fair? NO! Will it work to get him sympathy votes? Probably. I voted over 300 times and had 6 others voting too. Maybe, just maybe, the real winner will prevail...and Cook can go back to bartending at "DICKS" with David Hernandez.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Garry Houston, TX — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:03:46 GMT

The greatest 'Idol' talent is Chris Daughtry. Carrie is 2nd, Kelly 3rd and David Cook is 4th. David Archuleta is an extremely talented young man, but Cook will sell out concerts and make humongous $$$ when it's all said and done.

Chris ended 4th, and went Platinum his first release...which was only the 4th time in history.

DA is a prodigy, but more along the Brian Adams lineage.

Cook is 'Daughtry Lite'...he'll never be Chris, but he'll be darn close.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Santa Claus, Long Beach, CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:11:40 GMT

I'm so sick of this predictable BS, David A sang 3 songs, one he already sang before and the other 2 was also slow tempo songs, so far he has sang 2 up tempo songs this entire season and screwed up on both of them. On the other hand David C sang a song by U2 which nobody dares touching since there is nobody that can do a song like that justice and for the first time this season I had goosebumps, how long did I have to wait for that? Then he does some different and pick a 3rd song which he hasn't done so far he takes that chance coz that is how champions are crowned. And to Alexa, i'm trying to get through and have not been able to get through on voting for David C i'm in LA, so don't worry, even if he doesn't win he's going to make it BIG. Idols is becoming just as fake as boops in LA

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Frank, Washington DC — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:11:41 GMT

Archuletta is a teeny-bopper who sings safe ballad-y songs and plays the audience. Cook is a true muscian who follows his heart and sings it. Archuletta may win because of the teen girl vote, but if the contest is for the better musician, Cook should be crowned the winner.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Shawn, Seattle, WA — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:13:32 GMT

I totally agree with Alyssa from TN. I would buy D.C.'s cd on day one. Archie is really only good at ballads and who wants a whole cd of ballads. Archie reminds me too much of Clay Aiken. I am sure Archie is destined for broadway too.

I do wonder if David Cook doesn't want to win, so he isn't tied to a contract with Simon Cowell.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Judy, Norfolk, NE — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:14:43 GMT

They are both great talents, however, David Cook has the ability to expand the depthness of his talent with his arrangements and style of singing. I hope the voters will see that and hear it in his performances. I would be voting for David Cook.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Elizabeth — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:18:43 GMT

if Archuleta wins we'll have a younger version of Clay Aiken. How special. Yes I'm being snarky.
I prefer if Cook wins. Yes both sing well but I want something other than ballads on the radio.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Ellen, Pittsburgh, PA — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:24:10 GMT

Doesn't matter to me who wins, just pleased to be aware and enjoy David Cook's talent. I almost think HE doesn't care if he wins the AI title, he's won by all the exposure and respect and love for his talent and will definitely be a star.

As for Archie, everything he sings sounds the same and is not my personal "cup of tea". But for all the tweens who love him, ENJOY :)

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Cassie Stanley — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:26:40 GMT

David Archuleta deserves to win season 7 by a mile. He is so consistant and has so much devotion for each and every song he sings. His emotional level is by far higher than Cooks and actually has feeling and expressions when he sings unlike Cook with no emotion or reaction whatsoever. If Archuleta doesn't win then this show is no longer worth watching.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Ed, Minneapolis, MN — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:27:54 GMT

My favorite is Cook, and I'm voting for him, though I think he will do very well as an artist whether he wins or not. He's a much more versatile and marketable performer, IMO. I do think that Archie has a gorgeous singing voice, and should do well in the teenybopper market. (Is there still such a thing? Menudo, anybody?) Actually, I think both Davids are great, but it's time we had not just a Pop Idol, but a true American Idol, in the true American Rock 'n' Roll tradition: David Cook!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Cathi, Fort Worth, TX. — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:32:27 GMT

It was a tough night. Both David's were terrific. DC was obviously struggling with his voice but seemed to use it to his advantage and IMO it worked. He's a Pro, a gentleman and a very talented and ingenious young man. I'm pulling for him now, more than ever, especially after Simon's snarky remarks. Oh yea. He did say "phenomenal" after the first song. The safest song of the night. For me, DC only got better after that. But the judges were almost condescending in their praise. Archuleta was great. No doubt about it. He brought it all tonight. It's anyone's guess but DC is already a winner in my book. I wish them both luck.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Misty Joy — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:43:29 GMT

The article talks about the "Cowell Curse." I think your co-worker Paige is correct about that. Today on the Ellen show Simon said he felt David Cook was going to win, now tonight Archuletta pulverised.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Angela. Tampa, FL — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:43:53 GMT

Both guys have excelled during this year's competition. I pray that that the people will not be swayed by Simon's comments. We must remember all of the past performances during this year's American Idol, not just the finals. David A. did surpass David C in tonight performance (finals), but the people know that the title belongs to DAVID COOK. He is a risk taker and a very talented artist.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Cook fan! Pennsylvania — Wed, 21 May 2008 04:53:35 GMT

TAZ, in Texas, you should be ashamed. Every other person on these boards was at least civil. Cook did not cry because Archuleta got good reviews. That was the end of probably one of the toughest times in his life, his last performance before teh votes, in front of 7,000 people, living his dream. The bartender hit was pretty low too, congratulations. I have been voting for 4 hours, and I hope with all my might he wins for your sake. Congrats on being the designated rude of the posts, way to be a stand-up fan.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Ricardo, Riverton, UT — Wed, 21 May 2008 05:17:05 GMT

The first time I heard David Archuleta sing I was stunned at how pitch perfect a voice he had. If the judging happened on voice alone, Archuleta would win. Unfortunately, people are voting for Cook and it has little to do with his ability to sing. Archuleta is Groban II while Cook is a boring, unoriginal wannabe that will be as quickly forgotten as the gray haired dude from a few years ago.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Another Cook Fan, Minnesota — Wed, 21 May 2008 05:19:00 GMT

Good for you, Cook fan, PA! As Simon himself said, DC is a genuine nice guy. I don't doubt the sincerity of his tears for a second! Did you other Cook fans catch the story about his wrist band for the young cancer patient? This guy is the real deal. Deserves to be an idol.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Yol,Sacramento,CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 05:42:49 GMT

I'm rooting for D.C. He has been my favorite since the beginning of the show. I've been voting for him for the past hour.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

mercedes thompson, keyport nj — Wed, 21 May 2008 05:44:24 GMT

Ever since david cook sang hello,he had me at hello.He is an awesome singer.He deserves to win this american idol.Last night he rocked the place out and DA should not win this.He is more a teen idol,and this is american idol DC has what it takes to win it all.Simon is old fashioned and should be a judge for the opera.Sorry DA but I realy hope for DC to win I would definately buy his first album.He has talent,he can take any song and sing his heart out to it.DC you are the number one singer I have seen and heard since american idol started.You are the one baby.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Patti Ontario Canada — Wed, 21 May 2008 05:44:29 GMT

I truely think David Cook should win..Sure David A had a good night tonight. I do not believe he has the maturity for what it takes to be # one David Cook has been true every week no matter what song he does he makes it his own I would PAY TO GO SEE HIM. David A feels like a disney singer good but kinda boring ..always sounds the same.Wish we could vote here in Canada. Good Luck David Cook..you have earned the title ..

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Shirley Brown, Las Vegas, NV — Wed, 21 May 2008 05:48:19 GMT

I think David A was definitely the winner tonight and I am voting for him as I write. If David C would have sung better I would have voted for him. I think they both have great futures ahead of them. PS David A has lots more than teens voting for him; I'm a 62 year old Grandmother.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

J.D., California — Wed, 21 May 2008 05:52:28 GMT

JD Hear. I'm not into rock,and it comes down to the wire. DC did take risks and was good, DA also took chances. I didnn't do drugs growing up, so I still believe in the system that has worked for me. Ballads have always united the world. Look at history and enjoy his innocence as long as it lasts. DA gets my vote.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

mercedes thompson, keyport nj — Wed, 21 May 2008 05:53:08 GMT

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Kevin, Branson, Missouri — Wed, 21 May 2008 06:00:06 GMT

I really enjoy Cook he can put out a great record tomorrow.Archie would do well singing for a Disney Movie Theme or the Ice Capades..

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Idol turns Karaoke, SC — Wed, 21 May 2008 06:03:55 GMT

Did anybody notice the KARAOKE BILLBOARD in the middle of the audience that shows the words to the songs that the contestants sang. Check it out, you can see it when David Cook is singing his second song if you recorded the show. Amazing. I guess they didn't want anyone to mess up.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Beijing, China — Wed, 21 May 2008 06:14:32 GMT

Both David's can sing but David Cook can sign all types of song and make it his own. I vote for David Cook because he is a much more versatile and marketable performer.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Sandy, Vancouver, WA — Wed, 21 May 2008 06:42:06 GMT

taz in texas: How interesting that you have voted for David A. over 300 times. After three hours there are those of us Cook fans that still can't get through to vote. I wonder why it is so easy to vote multiple times for Archuleta?

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Matt, Boca Raton, Florida — Wed, 21 May 2008 06:46:41 GMT

DAVID COOK ALL THE WAY!!! I VOTED LIKE 100 TIMES

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

David Cook wins! Chicago, il — Wed, 21 May 2008 07:39:38 GMT

David A. is too one-dimensional, if he wins his concerts will be boring. David Cook is edgy and reminds me of Daughtry. My vote is for DC!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Gloria Derby Ks — Wed, 21 May 2008 08:37:32 GMT

David Cook is the whole package. This yr most of the contestants lacked stage talent. I am 55 and female and I would buy a CD of DC's. David A has an awesome voice but he sang the same type of songs over and over and he has the stage talent of a slug. He would be great on the Disney channel. He will be another Josh Grogin? If David Cook does not win then I am too old to be watching teeny bopper idol.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Dan, Oakdale, Mn — Wed, 21 May 2008 08:59:52 GMT

I think Jason Castro will win this whole thing. Now, Melinda Doolittle was good tonight, but Jason hit the homerun. Many think Amanda Overmyer was victor last week against Jason and Melinda, but you just can't sing "Mary had a little lamb" and think your going to move to the final two! Of course, Jason singing his 6th straight Bob Marley tune may not help though he does fit the image...you think???? Jason Castro Will win tomorrows american Idol!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Dan, Oakdale, Mn — Wed, 21 May 2008 09:00:45 GMT

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

JB, Binghamton, NY — Wed, 21 May 2008 10:04:49 GMT

During the whole season and through the show last night, everyone was saying in order to be the AI, you have to have guts and take chances. David Cook has done that with his song choices ALL SEASON LONG. David Archuletta always played it safe with boring ballads. I hope America could look past all the Archuletta smoke the judges were blowing last night.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Phyllis Santos, Keizer, OR — Wed, 21 May 2008 10:12:04 GMT

It makes my heart feel good to see all the people who so respect the musician in David Cook and just who he is. They got their Country American Idol who has been unbeleavable in her career... now it is time for the Rocker, because he has earned it. He composes, writes, takes risks so he can learn.... and to sing Rock then Music of the Night.... No doubt who the star is to me

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Jonah, Tampa, FL — Wed, 21 May 2008 10:27:02 GMT

David Archuleta, without a doubt, will win this season of American Idol. He has the best voice and is the most musically talented contestant that was on the show this year. His voice is like velvet, is face & smile is that of an angel. A lot of Cook fans continue to criticize David Archuleta for his age or his song choices, calling them only ballads, but if they looked at Cook's selections, none of his songs are great vocal arrangements, but whining whispering screeches lamely attempting to sound like Bryan Adams or James Blunt. He is trying to sell sex appeal, and although I do find him sexy, he would do well to audition for a role on a soap opera. Is this an explanation of why his first album is not being sold? Or is it because he is on the show illegitimately in the first place? Maybe he could do gay porn with that hair cut.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Georgia, Columbia, SC — Wed, 21 May 2008 11:10:02 GMT

David C already has a career whether he wins or not. Both young men do. David A is by far the most talented and he has the most pure voice. I hope that David A wins. This has been by far the most talented year for American Idol. I wish I was in their position - both are winners.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

mike s, minnesonka mn — Wed, 21 May 2008 11:27:13 GMT

DA can only sing ballads and his voice is too clean-- it missed the emotion and depth of an Elton John or even Cook. Cook showed range with ballad and rock. i was disappointed the judges were so taken by DA's notes that they missed the context. A DA album would be a remake of Bread.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

J, San Antonio, TX — Wed, 21 May 2008 11:32:15 GMT

Who will win depends entirely upon what they're being judged on. If it's best vocally talented, then all you have to do is listen to the 2 biggest and highest esteemed powerhouses in the music industry, David Foster and Clive Davis and you know that David Archuleta is the winner. If you're basing the contest on "revenge" for a previous season or the ability to play the guitar, or very talented, but not the best talent, then it's David Cook. They're both very gifted, but who has the "it" factor vocally is David Archuleta..........

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Hank — Wed, 21 May 2008 11:33:41 GMT

The Judges are entitled to their opinions, but the show is called American Idol because the only opinion that counts is that of the majority of the voting fans. That majority will confirm that David Cook is the American Idol of Season 7. David Archuleta is very talented, but David Cook is a unique and special musician, singer and entertainer who will be a superstar.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Lanie — Wed, 21 May 2008 11:39:39 GMT

Truthfully, it really doesn't matter which one of them "wins" ... unless someone screws up big time both are going to go on to have fantastic careers. AI now is just a launching pad for talent regardless of where a contestant placed. Both of these guys deserve to be where they are and both are going to bring many years of enjoyment to many people.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Frank P, Warminster, Pa. — Wed, 21 May 2008 11:41:44 GMT

David A. was my favorite from the beggining but David C. has grown on me each week. I'm lucky because I like ballads and rock so I'll buy both of their CD's. Cook fan in PA. you are right Taz in Texas needs to get a life...

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Cook Fan too! Ohio — Wed, 21 May 2008 11:49:44 GMT

I think that David Cook is much better, however, when I finally got thru on the phone lines last night, I had a problem. I called 1-866-436-5701, David Cook's first number, the recording on the phone said "Thank you for voting for contestant #2"!!! I didn't vote for DA, I voted for DC, how sad is it if they have to "fix" the results? DC is better off without them, I've watched for years, but this might be the thing that makes me never watch again!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Donna, McKinney TX — Wed, 21 May 2008 12:13:11 GMT

If David A. is not the next American Idol it will be proof that the contest is not the American vote but the producers votes that matter. David A. has consistently had the stronger vocals and should win hands down. If he does not it will not be for lack of talent, but how the producers feel about his Dad.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Donna, McKinney TX — Wed, 21 May 2008 12:13:43 GMT

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Bruce L, Charlottesville, VA — Wed, 21 May 2008 12:19:01 GMT

David A. has been the choice of the judges and producers since the very beginning of try-outs, He is s inmature and will not sell records or concerts. David C. is someone that will definitely seel records and will be another Daughtrey. If anyone bothered to notice David C. was much more varied in his song choices, while David A. did the only time song he can do. The real problem I had with all of this is the fact that in trying to vote for David C. last night I was not able to get one single call in on my cell phone, but could dial the same number on my land line and get through. I tried all three numbers with the same result fr over two hours. In years past I have been able to use my cell very well. I want to know what FOX had cooked up to make sure David A. alias (the nerd) won this contest.

I can not help but believe that this show has become very corrupt and has it's own agenda. If avid A. wins I believe that it will hurt the show. It will be strike three over the last three years. If you look at it the winner hasn't necessarly gone on to do the best. Season two is a prime example, Rueben hasn't come close to the accomplishments of Clay.

It's about time this show shut it down before it becomes a laughing stock, especially if it is going to rig the voting process. By the way it wasn't the phone because I tried two different cell phones. Something is very fishy about all of this.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Guy Linn, Nashville, TN — Wed, 21 May 2008 12:26:32 GMT

David Cook is by far the better performer and singer. He has the better voice and is certainly more marketable. Archie is BORING, plain and simple. I would never buy his cd unless I needed music to committ suicide by. Not to mention the fact that he's too young and too self-centered. Last week he (Archie) was only concerned that he wasn't voted off, Cook was truly concerned with Syesha.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Debbie Diamond — Wed, 21 May 2008 12:31:52 GMT

David A. deserves to win this hands down, he is soulful, adorable and will continue to sing to the hearts of all of us, including the guys, he isn't just a teenage heartthrob, he will truly be extremely successful and definately desrves this win BIG TIME!!!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Mary Jane, Wasaga Beach, Ontario — Wed, 21 May 2008 12:34:13 GMT

David Archuletta made a very wise decision to remain pure in his performance, and focused entirely on his vocal gift without playing the piano which, if you remember, he does extremely well ... Evidently he didn't feel the need of a 'prop' instrument - even Cook said he felt good "playing" in front of 7,000 people. When did the standard of a vocal competition change to suit his agenda? I like that Archie isn't cocky, self righteous and conceited, and believe he is the most sincere, humble and talented vocalist I have ever heard. I wouldn't buy a ticket to see Cook if my life depended on it - there are already wannabe's with glued hair, undersized jackets and false smiles everywhere already!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Lauren, Augusta, Maine — Wed, 21 May 2008 12:43:21 GMT

Yes David A. did a very good job tonight and there's no denying that he has talent. However, these ballads get rather boring after a while. David C. makes the songs fresh and different and interesting to listen to. I would buy DC's music anytime. But whether he wins or not, he is going to have a MUCH more successful career than David A. I agree with some of the others, I think DA could have a great career on Broadway. Best wishes to both guys!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Carla G, Peoria,IL — Wed, 21 May 2008 12:59:23 GMT

People should just get over it. David Archuleta had the desire and passion to win and came out with some of his best peformances. As far as David Cook being original, how original is it to take other people's arrangement and sing it. He just makes songs suit his style which Archuleta does as well. They sing what their voice is suited for. I think last night proved David Cook could not sing anything. It was almost like he didn't even really try. He sang all of his songs very plainly and didn't do anything original or unique to it. And He sang the song he chose from the song writer's list like you would hear anyone in a bar somewhere. David Archuleta has a distictive voice. If I were to hear David A on the radio I would know it was him whereas if I heard David Cook, I wouldn't be able to tell the difference between him or another so called rocker.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Nikki, West NY, NJ — Wed, 21 May 2008 12:59:27 GMT

Does anyone else feel that a child who still lives at home should not be allowed to be exploited in this competition? I cannot believe that the AI producers can place a maximum age limit on competitors, but no one raises an eyebrow when a high school student whose primary experience is performing in the school or church choir is placed under this type of pressure and allowed to miss his/her studies. What's next? A ten-year-old winner? I'm so done with this show.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Bobby, Jackson, Mississippi — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:06:23 GMT

I believe David Archuleta is and has been the best singer in the competition. He has been the one that has been most consistant and really never had an "off" night. Youth has nothing to do with it...they train athletes from a young age to perfect their skills and that is exactly what David Archuleta has done and now it is paying off!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

LIza, Fayetteville, NC — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:10:46 GMT

This is a singing competition,not a favorite or fan of who you like better. I give my votes to David Archuleta because he went out there to win and he did what American Idol is all about, giving your best and ofcourse his voice is outstanding. This is not a performor audition, it's singing audition!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Laurah in NY — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:13:47 GMT

I remember Clay Aiken singing "Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me" about 10 times better than little David. I wonder why Simon never called him out on the fake humility like he did to Melinda Doolittle last season. Personally I have not cared so little about who was going to win since Fantasia vs. Diana.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

IDOL Minds — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:13:58 GMT

This is getting all to predictable...the producer's, judges, and host promote who they want to win and everyone else was at a disadvantage...doesn't matter at this point

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Heather, PA — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:15:04 GMT

It doesn't really matter who wins. David Cook will ultimately sell more records and be more successful. Seriously, who would buy an Archuleta CD? Not me!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

chatty cathy-major cook fan owingsmills,md — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:18:05 GMT

I am going for david cook.not because I love him but he is mature and classy enough to get through everthing,I am sure that he has a contract already.david A is a child hanging by the heels of a dominering father and a controlled one.I feel like the look david A gets when he wins says to me I better win or my father will punnish me for not being good enough to win.His eyes bother me so much!!.I bought all of chris daughtrys cds and I will by David cooks to.I agree with taz David cook did not cry because of david a this was the last night a long season and he sung in front of 7000 people which he never thought he would especially since it was originaly his brother going to audition.I just hope david cook wins and lives his dream.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Tracy Martin — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:23:51 GMT

If David Cook does not win I will never watch AI again! It will finally prove to me that AI has no credibility. They haven't discovered a real American Idol since Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood. Little David as I call him sounds the same on every song. What happened to "making it your own?" He has no originality and is so naive! The only reason he is getting any votes is the market of 10-13 year old girls. But for the rest of us who would like to actually listen to the winner on the top twenty we have been disappointed for the past couple of years. Daughtry showed them what a huge mistake they were making! Besides, why wouldn't they have each contestant sing the same song so they can judge them equally. Little David could sing a rock song or alternative song if his life depended on it. He will always be a little Catholic Choir Boy in my eyes. And mark my word ratings will never be the same if he wins!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Tracy Martin Virginia Beach Virginia — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:24:19 GMT

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Cinbad — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:28:24 GMT

I have been an Idol watcher from season two, but this year's been so boring I've only seen about five episodes and I was rooting for Sayesha. I didn't even watch last night. Both the Davids are good singers, but I'm pulling for Cook. Archuleta seems like a nice kid, but his shiny wet lips gross me out...

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Allan — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:29:54 GMT

Who wants someone who can sing the phone book. Archuleta is a great predictable singer of ballads. Lets not forget that he is one of the few to make it to the finals after forgetting his words early in the season. Cook is the most versatile singer of any that has ever been on Idol. He can sing rock and then belt a ballad like Roberta Flack. The only two times Archuletta stepped out side his genre he blew it. Cook all the way. Archuletta will be a great Michael Buble or Harry Connick Jr.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Tammy, Washington DC — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:41:09 GMT

Taz, from Texas,

Why hate on Cook? So what if he got a little emotional, it was the first time ever,Do you look down on Little Archie, cause he looks like he is gonna cry every freaking week, It that genuine? probably cause he is still a BABY!!! I mean really, we are down to 2 and if the realization finally did hit Cook, and he watered up a bit, well I think that only means he is human. Its common knowledge that whether he wins the title or not, he is the most talanted singer this season. His career with take off with flying colors with or without the American Idol title.

Sure Little Archie might have a few ballads, because, being truthful... that is all he can sing. and they will probably be a great success too but they will only make it big on some easy listening channels, However, Cook is going to be marketable, and HIS cd will sell right from the begining, and it will be played on every Pop,and Rock station as well as the contemporary stations... I am just keeping real. You dont have to like Cook to know he is obviously more talented....unless of course your the type who just jamms out in his car to Josh Grobin Hits...Is that what you do Taz? if so, I totally understand your weird defense of Little Archie

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Nikki, Amarillo, Tx — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:41:24 GMT

Not to sound disrespectfull or anything, but
DA sounds more like a Christian singer than a pop star. If he does win we all know who will have the bigger Fame. Like some one else said he tried to do something different and forgot his words..... I dont remember David Cook forgeting words.... I think Cook should win... but I guess we'll just have to wait and see.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Diane Scavona, Denham Springs, LA — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:57:41 GMT

I love both David A. and David C. But though David A. has been my pick from the very beginning, I could not take it away from David C. I based my votes on the best performance last night. Sorry but David A. was the very best by a long shot.

This thing about who is the most marketable is about the most craziest thing I've ever heard. The contest is about who is the best singer. American Idol makes the money, so why let them take our ideas of who is more marketable, who cares... let the best man win.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Elizabeth Toledo, Ohio — Wed, 21 May 2008 13:58:38 GMT

David Cook will win tonight! All season long he has been original, consistent and worked thru all the crap songs they have given him. I have never been more excited for a performer, and every week David Cook has delivered. All you Archie fans you know I'm right. How can you be excited about a one dimensional performer? Please help me understand this?

Good Luck David C!!!!!!!!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Bill — Wed, 21 May 2008 14:24:28 GMT

If you can look past the emotion of last nights performance and evaluate both contestants body of work it is clear that David Cook is the more versatile talented artist. David Archuleta is better at singing the slow melodic emotional ballads and went with his strength on all three songs. I personally felt that Cook's performance on the first and third songs were better and demonstrated his depth and talent. Fortunately or unfortunately, the younger viewing audience cannot appreciate the maturity and breadth of what Cook brings to the stage and will ultimately choose Archuleta as the winner. He (Archuleta) is truly an unusual talent for someone so young but may or may not ever develop beyond a broadway stage type of performer. Good luck to both.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Sam, Traverse City, MI — Wed, 21 May 2008 14:24:34 GMT

Whoever said that David A was a better performer has a screw loose. David C is so much better. David A has a lovely voice but he's 17 and acts younger than that. Most of the time he reminds me of a dog that gets hit with a stick too often. He's not ready for this and I hope for his sake he doesn't win (although I hope his Dad doesn't kill him emotionally if he doesn't). David Cook is the well rounded performer. His voice may not be "as good" as Archie's but I don't know too many people who just want to listen to sappy ballads all day. Cook is far more marketable and will sell a ton more albums. I predict that Archuletta eventually ends up a Christian music balladeer. Cook will follow the route of Daughtry and be on the mainstream charts. I was disgusted that the judges just showered praise on Archie. Sure, praise him for having a beautiful singing voice and hitting the notes right, but I'd get after him for having no dimension whatsoever. Nothing but ballads is sad. He can't do anything else

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Lorrie Motyka, Hatfield, MA — Wed, 21 May 2008 14:26:05 GMT

In my opinion David A. should not have even been in the finals! Week after week with boring songs that his Dad helped arrange. People should vote for the true musician and singing talent of David Cook. Cook picked his own songs and rearranged them all on his own from the beginning. Now that's talent! I would buy his CD in a heartbeat! Cook was and has been the most consistent performer of the season and I predict he will earn the most money out of any AI contestant!
Hands down Cook is the ultimate winner whether he gets the AI title or not.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

mk, Spokane, WA — Wed, 21 May 2008 14:30:09 GMT

DA won the talent show. DC will win the popularity contest.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Peggy Trobee — Wed, 21 May 2008 14:39:47 GMT

I am just one person, but my vote goes to David Cook..I would pay and set through a concert of his and I will buy a cd..Clive Davis will work the little bugs out of the songs...David A.. sings the same tone voices all of the time...he is a good singer but not someone I would buy a cd...as Simon says he's forgettable..I am 72 and David Cook could make me rock.....He's done great on Idol.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Peggy Trobee — Wed, 21 May 2008 14:41:00 GMT

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Cook FAN also, Charlotte, North Carolina — Wed, 21 May 2008 14:42:39 GMT

I agree with COOK FAN, PENNSYLVANIA

David Cook is the best, I would buy his CD today not Archie..

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Carol, Bridgeport, CT — Wed, 21 May 2008 14:44:40 GMT

While both Davids were good last night, I'm voting for David Cook. I was glad he didn't play it safe and sing Hello or Billie Jean. He truly is a versatile, talented, musician. I would buy a David Cook CD or see him in concert, not David A.The problem with David A is that he always sings predictable ballads, we never hear anything different from him. David C can sing anything and make it his own, he's fantastic!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Jay, Ohio — Wed, 21 May 2008 14:46:55 GMT

If David Cook wins it'll be because he's a rocker and not based on talent because David Archuleta blew him away last night.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Margaret, Pensacola, FL — Wed, 21 May 2008 14:53:38 GMT

Cook will win, b/c Daughtry didn't win in 2006. He is Daughtry with hair--no other difference in the two.
The producers desperately want a rocker to win, even though they have acted as though Daughtry won two years ago. Simon's comments last night were made to fire up the Cook fans. I believe it may have worked.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Susan, Greenville, S.C. — Wed, 21 May 2008 14:56:35 GMT

I agree with alot of whats been written. I love David C. and in one way I hope he wins just so David A. doesn't win. And Taz your remarks were way out of line. He is one dimentional. And when he stepped out of that he did get bad reviews. Then like some else said David C. won't be tied up with the AI stuff. Two of my favorite Am. Idols are Chris Duaghtry and Bo Bice and neither of them won. The best AI winner has of course been Carrie Underwood. Like Paula say's after she hear David C. she wants more and so do I. I will buy his cd.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Annie, Austin,Texas — Wed, 21 May 2008 14:58:35 GMT

both are fantastic singers and they will probably have singing contracts. I'ts hard to pick the one but lets be fair, age and experience should not be a factor in putting Archuleta down.I don't agree he's a little Clay AIKEN and by the way he has done excellant in his career. SO BEST OF LUCK TO BOTH!!!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Karrie, Muskogee, OK — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:00:54 GMT

Please correct me if I am wrong but wasn't David C the only contestant Randy ever said was ready to sell records now? I don't think that was just a comment about his singing. Randy is a producer and knows it takes a lot more than just a good voice to make it in music today. In 5, 10, 20 years do you see David A selling out large venues? I don't. I would would drive several hours to see David C in concert. I am afraid I wouldn't drive across town to see David A. I think he has a good voice just no stage presence yet.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Lucy Arkansas — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:02:13 GMT

I think Simon was playing up for tonights finale to boost Archy for a let down . He did say on Ellen that Cook would win. He also "WINKED" after Cook told him he respected what he said. I think its in the bag COOK is the winner. And I will be in line to buy the first CD. I am a big fan!!!!!!!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Lindsey, Sqn Francisco, CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:06:33 GMT

David Archuleta came out to win on Tuesday. For a 17 year old he showed poise, confidence, talent and the desire to win. I thought David Cook, although talented in his own way, was self-indulgent and really didn't show he cared whether he won or not. For me, it's not about either singer--it's about the fans and David Archuleta showed more respect for his fans and much more professionalism than his counterpart. And my David Cook fans, that is exactly why David Archuleta is the next American Idol.....

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

J. Fromm — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:07:01 GMT

David Cook gets my vote. He just has a presence and a unique talent. David A. only sings 70's-90's ballads and moves (can't quite call what he does on stage dancing) so stiff and ackwardly. Its nearly uncomfortable watching him trying to "dance" or sway to his own voice. You would have thought his father would have noticed that misstep. David Cook brings a mature, secure stage presence and a voice that has sung a variety of tunes, never selecting the easy or obvious choice and made the most of whatever material he has presented. If David A. wins, I predict he'll be another Reuben who? And, just like the second place finisher that year, Clay Aiken, I am sure David Cook will be signed to a recording deal, and develop a mature, loyal, fan base who'll actually be able to drive themselves to his concerts.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Louise, Sharon, Pa — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:09:06 GMT

I think it was disgusting how the judges made it clear who would win the Idol spot. If David A wins I will never watch that program again for since day one the judges favored David A. There were many more singers better than him. I guess the teeny boppers were probably his biggest fans - and callers! I don't usually call but for the last two weeks I have been a phone call-in junkie. Hope fans of David C stayed up till 1 am calling. He deserves the win - not a 17 year old "kid"

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Sarah, NY — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:10:53 GMT

David A has a good voice but he is completely boring. He can sing only one type of song, slow ballads, and that's it. Can't imagine paying to see him in a boring, slow 2 hour concert! He definately does't have the "pop" sound to him.
David C. on the other hand rocks!! He has a great voice, he is entertaining, can sing fast, slow, and everything in between. I am hoping that he wins tonight!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Sharon C Spokane Wa — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:13:55 GMT

I have been a huge fan of David C's all season long, because he brings something original to all the songs he sings. David A is great in his own right..I would buy David Cooks album tomorrow!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Sarah, NY — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:17:20 GMT

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Gloria Gonzalez, Bayamon, Puerto Rico — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:20:05 GMT

I think that both Davids are excellent performers. But, in my opinion, David Archuleta is the best. His vocals are exceptional and most of all, he is so humble about it. I hope that millions of people share my opinion and that tonight he can be called the 2008 American Idol. I will be the first in line when his CD comes out. DAVID, I LOVE YOU, THE WORLD IS WAITING FOR YOU.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Cindy, CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:22:30 GMT

It was an interesting night last night. Simon, who has been all over the media predicting David Cook to win absolutely threw him under the bus last night. Was there reverse psychology there, hoping to anger fans into voting harder for him? Perhaps, but the reality for me is that the "knockout" was really that for me. If you love ballads and that's all you want to listen to, then perhaps David A. could win. However, who is more marketable, well-rounded and has the greatest star potential??? Absolutely David Cook, he's destined either way for superstardom. What a nightmare it would be for 19 Ent. to have to work with Jeff Arculeta, I'm sure the producers are hoping for David Cook to win as well. I voted for over 3 hours last night for Cook and only got through about 10 times, his lines were jammed. Best of luck to both of them!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Jen, Casper, Wyoming — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:22:57 GMT

I just want to know why Randy Jackson feels the need to repeat the same comments week after week? I.E. "You could sing a phone book, Archie." Basically, each Archie performance is about as boring as listening to him actually read the phone book.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

maryellen k,Boston,MA — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:33:12 GMT

I think it's funy so many people are saying because David A sings ballads he is not as marketable as David Cook. Not Marketable???.....I'll bet that would make "Josh Groban" laugh all the way to the bank!! Styles of music come and go over the generations but a beautiful voice will always be in demand whether you're 18 or 80!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Tanya, NM — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:48:55 GMT

Well it's Weds mid morning and I am sure hoping that David Cook wins. Whoever said David A would be good on Disney was right. If I have to hear another "gosh" from him I am going to puke. What 17 yr old in this world says "gosh" Please get real. If A wins it is because it was fixed. But then again look at the success of the last 2 yrs contestants, NOT The last real winner was Daughtry. I am so sick of Randy and his "yo dog" comments and his falling all over Archuleta. Talk about picking a favorite early. Seems like noone else's songs ever worked for him this season. Randy needs to go next season.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Mark, Los Angeles — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:49:25 GMT

First time viewer to AI. Cook by a mile baby! Archuletta, go back to the minors bro. Cook is a far better singer with much more stage presence. Archuletta needs to go work for Disney.

footnote: Viewers commented on Simon's calling it in favor of Archuletta as being inappropriate. I agree, that is not fair. The judges should offer praise and constructive criticism, but should not declare a winner. Let the people think for themselves.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Tanya, NM — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:54:17 GMT

I hope that David C wins because I can't stand to hear David A. He is so young and can't sing anything other than ballads. He forgot the words and they let him pass on that. He is to young and to inexperienced. If Cook doesn't win this will be the last year I watch AI. After the last 2 seasons and them getting rid of Daughtry they are basically a joke. It is not a singing contest. How sad.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Sean, Los Angeles, CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:54:23 GMT

I'm sorry - I thought David Cook did not sing that well last night. David Archuleta did a better performance with all three songs. Cook was just doing a lot of screaming and yelling. But from what I have been seeing a lot of people are getting into Cook's corner. I tell you if Cook wins, it will be just like Studdard over Aiken. Just like Clay should of won American Idol - so sould Archuleta.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Mark, Los Ang3eles — Wed, 21 May 2008 15:57:27 GMT

Tell me guys and forgive my ignorance... what makes David Archuletta a prodigy? Do those using that term know what it means? Look it up. David Archuletta is no prodigy. Period!

So stop using it.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Sue, Niceville, FL — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:07:05 GMT

David A is has the better voice, but he's boring. David Cook is definitely the better all around entertainer. Young David just sings, no personality!
My vote is for Cook!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Paula Sims, Cadillac, MI — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:13:28 GMT

I LOVE David Cook's voice!
He is Original, Versatile, and and Edgy.
He will sell Lots of Cd's and album's because he is very talented and isn't afraid to try new thing's.
Whereas, David, A. stayed in his comfort zone and didn't sound any differnet than anything he's done all season! Which is very Boring to me! It proves that David Cook is the most 'professional' and daring and as hesaid tonight,it is all about Progressing for him, trying new things.
He is already an American idol to me and will go on to do Amazing thing's!
You Rock David Cook!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Amanda, ID — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:13:36 GMT

Yes, David A has a great voice, no one can take that away from him...but same ol' every time. Boring! I wouldn't buy his record, it would have the same stuff on it. David Cook on the other hand, I would have bought his cd right after I head his first audition. He rocks! Plain and simple. Even if he doesn't win (knowing that the majority of voters are 14/15 yo girls, he might lose) but his career will take off more so than little David A!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Dawn L., Spokane, WA — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:16:29 GMT

I am so sick of David A. Yes he can sing, but can he sing anything but a sick sappy song. He reminds me of boy band sick drippy singers. I dont think he has the maturity nor the thick skin to be in this industry, heck last night he looked like he was going to cry or pee his pants waiting for the judges, how do you think he is going to stand up to a producer.
They both are talented hands down, but my choice is David Cook. He is orginial, he fresh, he has a great voice and I think he is mature enough to go the distance in the music world.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Patty, St. Louis, MO — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:21:21 GMT

Both Davids belong where they got - the 2 finalists. However, I am for David Cook because he has originality, he's an entertainer that always delivers his own style & he's always unpredictable. Where David Archuleta in my opinion was just the same as how he always was all season - predictable. I didn't think he sang last night any better than any of the other weeks. I want a true artist to win like David Cook, plus he's from Missouri which is where I'm from. Go David Cook!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Karen, Ocho Rios, Jamaica — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:22:10 GMT

David A ALL the way!!! He has been very consistent. He is very pleasant unlike David C. David A can sing anything and you get goose bumps. Yes David C is versatile but he cannot sing. They have separate styles but Archie has the edge. He can sing!!!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Marc — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:28:09 GMT

Archuleta will not have a successful career unless he hits the crooner circuit (Josh Brolin and others). Cook has not only the voice but stage presence that when you look at the whole package, makes more sense that he be the winner than David A. David A will join Rueben, Taylor Hicks, etc. at being a commercial flop. Artists are now making more money at concerts and video distribution than CD sales, and know one I know would go see David Archuleta.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

PF, New Jersey — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:29:25 GMT

David C is a true performer. He will sell more records than David A because he's stronger, takes risks and downright great. I'm so proud of him and I KNOW he will win.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Jim Laliberte, Sacramento, CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:31:16 GMT

Cook has a limited vocal range and this is about the best singer. David A. wins by a mile and the kid is a teenager. Imagine how good he'll be in years to come. Why everyone thinks Cook is so great eludes me. The guy hasn't half the vocal talent as David A. He screams, David A sings.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Carmen, Paterson, NJ — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:36:40 GMT

If this is and is supposed to be a singing competition, David A. should win tonight. David C. is a great vocalist, but little David won last night. He made me and I know a lot of people cry last night with his rendition of imagine. He has been consistant every week, and he deserves to win. I agree with Simon, David A. is in it to win it. Good luck David A. or should I say, David VS Goliath.?

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Kurlee, SC — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:37:28 GMT

Karrie in OK... I agree with you.
I think Archie has an amazing vocal talent for someone his age. But, I believe that Cook would have longevity in the music business. It wouldn't surprise me if Archie wins because there were millions of preteens having sleepover parties and pounding on their cell phones all night. But will they remember Archu-Who? in 10 years?
I prefer to base my decision this way:
If I'm stuck in traffic and I'm flipping through radio stations, do I want to listen to a boring ballad no matter how beautifully sung? I need to keep alert, not fall asleep at the wheel! I'd much rather rock out to a Cook tune!
But I wish them both well anyway. *8)

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

get alife, lawrence,ks — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:44:11 GMT

oooo another american idol flop as usual--people are so dumb to get hooked on shows like this--there is a real worl out there people--try going ouside for a change--or would that be too much reality--lol!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Cheryl NJ — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:45:23 GMT

To Cook Fan in Pennsylvania -- THANK YOU -- you said what I wanted to say, he didn't cry because of the praise David A was getting -- it has been a long road of practicing every day performing, going to this and that, being away from your family/friends. It was the culmination of a great competition. And yes you can't pick the winner just by last night's performances. You have to take the whole season and David C. always did great why David A can only sing the ballads and remember what Andrew L. Weber said -- stop closing your eyes -- he still is squinting and I don't want his father getting anything as he didn't do anything

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Cheryl NJ — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:47:45 GMT

Also re David C -- he was the most original talent in years. Took a risk every single week and why redo a song you already did like david A did with Imagine -- I'm not a Randy J. fan but he was right on the mark about david c. being ready weeks ago to produce an album. Also I voted over 100x for david c. I hope he wins, I'll never watch AI again if he doesn't.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Tracy, Va — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:52:54 GMT

I think both david's can sing quite well but they have different singing and personality styles. David Cook is perfect to represent American Idol and David A. is more the "Disney Channel" singer for shows like high school musical.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Stephanie, North Missouri — Wed, 21 May 2008 16:54:02 GMT

At this point I don't care who wins. I know that I will be hearing David Cook on the radio no matter what. I am happy that he has made it this far otherwise I probably would have stopped watching the show if Cook and Michael Johns were both gone. The season Chris Daughtry was voted off prematurely I quit watching. The song choices this year were MISERABLE!!!!! David A. is a good singer, but so damn boring to watch.
GOOD LUCK TO DAVID COOK!!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Lisa, Flint, Michigan — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:02:03 GMT

David Cook is the man the better performer and the one who should win. David A. is darling but leave him for the teenie boopers. We need a real man!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Liz, Williamsport, PA — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:09:56 GMT

If the judges opinions are not going to matter, than I wish they would just keep quiet. Randy and Paula sounded so moronic, esp. with that overused "you could sing the phone book" line. Give me a break, Randy!! And Simon, for someone who all season long expected the singers to "change things up", and "make songs their own", everyone of DA's songs was the same old, same old. Did he do a good job? Yes, but he took no risks, he stayed right in his comfort zone, he has not grown at all in this competition. When you put how he sang "Imagine" from the beginning of the cometition to the end, it actually sounded better the first time. DC did not play the IDOL game, and Simon knew it. He even winked at DC when DC called him out about it. He continued to try different and more difficult music. He is trying to show what a concert would look like, or a CD of DC. He is a mature musician. Not some cookie cutter, like DA. Many have said it before, DC will go on, just like Daughtry and do great. DA has ALOT of growing up to do and needs to get rid of that stage father. Do we remember "soul patrol", just because all these crazy fans gave some guy his 15 minutes of fame, doesn't mean he deserved it or he will ever maintain it. Be careful what you wish for DA fans, you might not like what you get a year from now.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

teri helms, evans, georgia — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:17:37 GMT

david c is the best all around. he can sing pop, r&b & rock. david a. however, can only sing ballads. i get very tired of the same o' same o'. david c to me should be the next american idol. just like the year chris daughtry was voted off. big mistake. i have his cd and its wonderful. i will definitely buy david c's when it comes out. not david a's.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Linda Orth, Independence MO — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:26:52 GMT

David Cook is the better of the two, if he doesn't win American Idol, he can hold his own and have a great future ahead of him as for David A, he has a great voice, but it is more for the teens, maybe he can get a job at Disney Land.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Angela Monts de Oca, Spring Hope, NC — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:30:06 GMT

I love both Davids, but Cook went off key in every song last night and some last week. It was painful listening to him. Rightfully Archuleta should win based on the last 2 weeks alone, but I'm not betting on the outcome. It could go either way.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Barbie, Virginia Beach, VA — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:30:21 GMT

Here is my thought. I think David Cook is much more talented and able to make a huge career for himself. In saying that, I think the stringent Idol contract would restrain him from doing what he wants to do. I think Archuleta is very talented, very pure voice, but I'm not sure if he would have a career without Idol. So, I think he would benefit more from winning than Cook would.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Dom G,Brooklyn,New York — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:32:49 GMT

I hope David Cooke wins. During the competition I have gotten that he is a more rounded singer where Archuleta just seems to sing pop ballads. David Cooke would sell more albums and appeal to a wider audience. Either way if David A. wins Cooke will defintely be more successful. Example: Taylor Hicks is doing Grease and Daughtry has gome multi platinum. same would happen here. Besides give David Archuleta a couple of years so he can stand up to his father and live his own life and call his own shots instead of being his jerk fathers puppet. Nice hat Mr. Archuleta let your kid have a life of his own you big jerk.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Kendalljaye — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:35:53 GMT

It all boils down to one song for me....
"Hello"
Yes, it's you I'm looking for, David Cook!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Susan Fields, Apple Valley, California — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:37:24 GMT

David Archuleta should win hands down, his talant has won the hearts of america, and last night David Cook wasnt up top of his game. I believe because of politics that David Archuleta wont win, and he is the winner...If politics get envolved then I have lost my interest in American Idol..As the best man should win and his age shouldnt be a factor in the decision.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

M. Johhson, LA, CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:37:24 GMT

There are two types of people in this world (maybe more), one feels very comfortable with themselves, just try to be themselves, the other is try to be someone else, to be cool. And I believe the first type, are more of Archi’s fan, and the later are Cook’s fan.

Be honestly, can you distinct Cook’s voice if it is played on a radio? Originality? You will have to explain that to me in details, I just don’t see any.
On the other hand, Archi has everything that this county needs, humble, loving, true talent and comfortable with himself. No mater he wins or not tonight, he is a true American Idol.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

J.D. — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:37:26 GMT

I don't think this was a good finale at all. In fact, I wasn't impressed by the lackluster performances and contestants this season. This season was a disaster, worst than what many others thought last season was....

But if I were to choose, David Cook would still be the better choice.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Nicole, Tampa, Florida — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:41:08 GMT

I think I agree with the majority on this one. Sure, Archuletta can sing, but Cook is definitely the better performer! Cook is ready to make an album, go on tour, etc. Archuletta is so not ready for all that comes with winning this title. I could also agree that whatever album Cook might make would not necessarily be the kind he wants since he won't have much say, but I guarantee his fans would still buy it, then he would move on to something more his style and fans would be lining up to buy the next album. Cook would be a more Contemporary Idol and deserves more credit for what he did last night than he got from the judges. I'm a Cook fan all the way!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Genisis Ray, Spring, TX — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:45:58 GMT

I have to admit Archie has a great voice, but in the end who will go on to sell more records? David Cook by a mile! David has orginality and has the superstar appeal, whereas little Archie does not. He looks like he going to have a nervous breakdown everytime he gets a compliment from the judges. He just dosen't have the stage presence, unlike Cook who is ready to start touring and selling out concert tickets! Whatever happens tonight, Cook is the real winner!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Carl Brock — Wed, 21 May 2008 17:59:15 GMT

I have two thoughts on David Cook & David Archuleta.
If you review the whole season of idol on these two winners. I would say that David Cook has more variety of range in performance than David Archuleta.

I believe that David Archuleta has a good heart and mellow.But there is so much ballards people can take. He really hasn't done very good on upbeat tempo songs the whole season.

On Tuesday night performances, It hard to swallow but David Archuleta did have better consistencies in vocal quality and music than David Cook. Even though I hope that David Cook gets the title.

If I was in David Cook shoes I would have done 3 upbeat hard hitting songs, cause David C should had known that David A was going to do mellow ballard style songs. And he (David C) needed to have contrast style vs. David A style.

GOOD LUCK DAVID COOK

Thank you for letting me share my opinion.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

NDJ Thousand Oaks, CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:05:57 GMT

This is my take... David A can only sing one way-- the type of music you hear in the elevator or a Christmas album. David C is a rocker, yes-- but can sing many different genres. Who will win? David A. Who will we remember in 5 years time? Daivd Cook.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Kathy Smith Burlington, Ky — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:06:26 GMT

I think David Cook should win, finally a rocker should win, he will sell more records. I would not buy a CD from David A. (boring) I can't believe the judges thought David A. was better last night, any song he sings sounds the same.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Lisa Cordle, Richmond Virginia — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:07:04 GMT

I can't wait till American Idol is finally over!! I want my Tuesday and Wednesday nights back. Go David Cook..

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Brett, San Francisco, CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:12:59 GMT

Archie.... what a bore. Can he even relate to the words he is singing. His mechanics are perfect but who cares if doesn't have the passion, charisma, emotion that Cook brings to the stage. I wouldn't even go see him in a free concert in the park.

Doesn't matter what happens to Cook. He is destined for greatness as Daughtry. And probably is a blessing.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

DCfan, Tennessee — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:14:19 GMT

I really hope david cook wins! He deserves it! THe judges got it completely wrong last night! David cook did better on every song!! All david a. can do is gooey boring love ballads! i voted 4 times for DC last night and i am hoping and praying that he wins! I have never wanted a contestant to win this badly since i started watching the show!!

GO DAVID COOK!!!!!!!!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Michelle, Santa Cruz, CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:17:30 GMT

David A is destined for Disney soundtracks, predictable, pitch perfect and boring, and he actually had two very off nights, one when he forgot the lyrics in the uptempo Beatles song, and last week again when he tried to leave his comfort zone with a faster pace. He is just not mainstream and would probably thrive on Broadway. DC, on the other hand has taken risks I have never seen on Idol and has consistently been entertaining. His is the first Idol CD I will actually go out and purchase!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

M.G. Dallas Texas — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:19:48 GMT

This is my 1st season watching Idol so I cannot relate with all the whining and moaning that the contest is fixed, rigged, the judges ram certain contestants down the audiance's throats. All I know is that I fell in love with David A's voice the day he sang Imagine. Yes, I know David C is more original, takes risks, and more creative, but David A has a God given talent. His voice is so pure, so fluid and beautiful. He is only young, and needs the right guidance in the real world or music production. In my opinion, David A's voice out shines David C's creativity. This is a singing contest and it is clear David A is the better singer, not to mention more adorable, sweet, humble etc...

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Jonah, Auburn, Maine — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:19:53 GMT

If David Cook ends up being the winner on this season's "American Idol", it will not be a win based upon talent or vocal ability, but a win based upon revenge due to the ousting of Chris Daughtry on Season 5. David Cook, albeit very sexy, does not have the musical talent that David Archuleta does, and this everyone knows, whether they voted for him or not. It only comes down to a popularity contest, and it also goes back to the credit, or lack thereof, in the voting system-can you say "Sanjaya"? David Archuleta needn't worry. He is the best, everyone knows it, and he doesn't need to win a competition show like "American Idol" to be a star.

What happened to Taylor Hicks, anyway? That win was such a joke!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Brian, Akron, Ohio — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:20:27 GMT

As I have heard everyone say on here David A. does have a geeat voice. But it escapes me why he doesnt get criticized for singing the same crap week after week. IT never changes and the one time he tried to do something else he got slammed. I dont know if David C. will win because I think every tweenie in the us will be voting for David A. but I can say 100% that David Cook will out sell anything David A. puts out 4 to 1

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Teri, Chicago, IL — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:21:04 GMT

I think the only thing that makes David C. original is the fact that he is a rocker and on this show they are far and few between. At least ones that make it this far. He sounds exactly the same w/ every song he sings, they start out slow and then he rocks. David A. recomposes every song he sings to make it his own and has a better voice. It really just comes down to the style of music you prefer. But, if it is based on who has the better voice, David C. shouldn't have even been allowed on the same stage as David A.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

AL KC MO — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:23:42 GMT

David A should not get credit for winning the AI if he does. DC is much better and does not relie on his dad to pick his songs for him. DC is his own man and DA is a puppet for his father. Ballads are for the people who can't take a chance with other types of music. DA wins I lose respect for AI and the judges.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

carol k, edmonton,AB — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:27:49 GMT

David Cook hands down is the winner in my books. He is about as original as it comes and by far the better performer. I'm tired of seeing Archie sing with eyes closed and licking his side lip. Actually Cook will do much better whwther he wins or not. I will definitely buy any of his CD's. "David Cook is the BOMB!!!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Carson Payne, Denton, TX — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:29:34 GMT

If I have to watch Archie give his "aw shucks" shy speil on every show for the next two weeks I will go crazy! Cook will be the more successful IDOL, as was Daughtery, and Archuleta will do well on Broadway or with some adult contemporary career. They both have completely different styles and completely different fan bases so it is impossible to compare the two. I'm afraid Archuleta is going to win (gag), but Cook will have a successful career anyway.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Kirk Garner, Reedley, CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:38:38 GMT

It's so lame when contestants repeat songs, thank God David Cook didn't! Hat's off to him for rising above the obvious.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Mark, Raleigh, North Carolina — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:39:07 GMT

David Cook - hands down was better in my opinion. A lot of talk about DA being ballad boy - no doubt - and no doubt an amazing, young talent. But Cook, he is immeidiately marketable and will sell millions. It was almost like the judges had preplanned all the Archie praise and I don't get it. And they certainly were not fair to Cook - he deserved way better than than what was said. Archie was just belting out tunes with a naturally, gifted and great voice - Cook was singing tunes with amazing talent, passion and flare that will go a long way. Can't wait for the first CD Mr. Cook. Hats off to you.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

musicfan4life — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:49:11 GMT

Simon: Where to start..I have been a fan of the show (despite the propaganda machine that gets these kids & teens to vote). I am not a little kid nor a teen, but I am sad to say this is the worst propaganda push I have ever seen, & it's coming directly from Simon. You were the person whose opinion I have agreed with & argued w/friends about (that you were the one w/the taste for talent). Simon, how can you possibly push a kid who can't even respond to the simplest questions? He's going to be a complete nightmare when it comes to the interviews after the show. Good luck Simon; all the talent you've found in the last few years will now be erased because you have a kid who hasn't even come clean w/who he is & will hardly be able to get through 1 junket w/o that insessent giggling he does. What exactly does "Idol" mean to you, Simon? Is it all about the money the little girls, boys & teens who are willing to spend on a farce instead of someone who has real talent? Just like Daughtry before him, Cook will rise above & prove to be the idol & the bigger talent. I will thank you for 1 (& only 1) thing from the "1st finale" show. Thank you for finally admitting your comment @ Cook being arrogant was completely off-base & absurd. You didn't come right out & say it, but calling Cook "one of the nicest contestents" ever to be on the show was wonderfully hypocritical of your "arrogant" statement a few weeks ago. Hope you're happy w/who you tried to sway to win. You'll have to live with that mistake, & I'll have to live with the mistake that I thought you understood the meaning of the word "Idol". David Achihuahua (by the way, I coined the phrase long before you said he sang like a chihuahua; which he does) is NO "Idol". He a confused teenager who is too afraid of his father to be who he really is, & that doesn't set a good example for anyone. The show is nothing but a hypocritical farce, & I won't watch tonight regardless of who wins because of the pitious farce the show continues to be. Please learn what "Idol" means & try to make a show that produces "Idols" & not more stars for "Peter Pan on Broadway". How many Clay Aikens does the world need? Very disappointing Simon; I used to be such a huge fan of yours. You caved in such a big way. I hope Ford & Coke are paying you a lot to sell your soul. Sellout...

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

musicfan4life — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:50:58 GMT

Definition of "idol": an ideal instance; a perfect embodiment of a concept. ...Now maybe neither of them are the embodiment of this, but I would like someone, anyone to name ONE thing David Archihuahua has said or done that could be "idol"-like... I can name several for David Cook.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

musicfan4life — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:54:22 GMT

Simon said several weeks ago that "if this was actually a talent competition and not a popularity contest, you (said to David Cook) would win hands down." But for Simon to be such a hypocrite last night with David Cook? At least he tried a new song instead of singing the same songs he's been singing since he was 14. Shame on you Simon.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

drew, concord, CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 18:59:31 GMT

anyone happen to notice the recap @ the end of tuesday night for david archuleta, when they were rolling out the numbers one last time? archuleta, completely ruins the word "join" on the last line of imagine. he is so obviously off and, suddenly my wife and i just froze. you see we are a musical family and we tend to notice bad notes. so we rewound the dvr to archuleta's performance of that song just minutes before, in tv time. what do you know, he sang it pitch-perfect, and the word "join" was spot on. apparently this whole deal is fixed and they don't really do this stuff in one take. he obviously got a 2nd take to do the song for the tv. kind of bothers me. bothers me so much i didn't even vote. should have voted, but i'm not sure that voting really matters because the producers want archuleta to win, not cook, the cook is clearly more marketable and artistic. sorry, every archuleta song sounds the same to me, i thought he was great @ the beginning, now i'm bored w/ him. btw, the world i know was a beautiful arrangement, though simon was right, as usual, cook should have done billie jean, or one of his other smashes. oh well, looks like this will be another american idol that will drop off the face of the earth in 1 year and the runner up will go on to sell way more. lastly, for archuleta to really succeed he needs to be able to compete w/ the voices of clay aiken and josh groban. those 2 guys really have a pretty good hold on that sector of the market.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

tamara, california — Wed, 21 May 2008 19:02:49 GMT

from the beginning the show has been promoting archuleta. he doesn't deserve it, he's 17 and has never had to work for anything. i believe COOK GETS MUSIC...archuleta sings what he thinks people will say sounds good. i hate his voice. i HATE it. sounds the same every time he sings, he has NO personality, do you know how BORING a david archuleta concert would be?! he's so blah and has no talent. american idol is a popularity contest, not a talent contest, therefore archuleta will win, unfortunately.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Linda Brooking — Wed, 21 May 2008 19:10:28 GMT

David Cook all the way, but like others posting here maybe a second place finish will give him more creative license. Archie is a one trick pony, and while he has an awesome voice, he is BORING to watch. David Cook is an entertainer and quite compelling to watch. He always put a unique spin on his material. I can't wait to buy his first album.
BTW, www.dialidol.com shows David C. way out in front of David A. I have never voted in an Idol final until last night when Simon's verbal crowning of Archie as the victor inspired me to leap to David C's defense. Go DC go!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

KATHLEEN AULL ALLENTOWN PA — Wed, 21 May 2008 19:14:51 GMT

We all know who the best talent is, hands down it is David Cook. The only thing saving David A. is his teeny bopper fans. He has a nice voice (boring) but nice and he does not have the ability like David Cook to take a song and really make it his own and sometimes more emotional than the original song. I would only buy David Cool's cd. I am sure it will be great. Good Luck David C. Long live ROCK N ROLL

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

The Tenor's Mom, Lancaster, CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 19:22:11 GMT

I will definitely see David Archuleta in great performances such as specials on PBS!!! I rank him with Josh Groban, Michael Buble' and Andrea Bocelli to mention a few of such caliber! David Archuleta has a unique style, one that will still be around 30 years from now! Besides, his personality, clean image, high values and his ever present humility make him the perfect "America Idol"!!!
Congratulations!
I already antecipate your victory young man!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Katelee Otto Savannah, GA — Wed, 21 May 2008 19:31:33 GMT

I am seriously sick of all the negative comments on David A. No one does it to Cook as far as I can see on numerous blogs. I think it's wrong that you can vote more than once. I don't see fairness in that At All since some have virtually No lives and sit by the phone and redial over and over and over. David A is a great singer and deserves to win. I'm sick of idols winning due to their poor pitiful me life! David A may be young but so were a few others if you remember...age has Nothing to do with alot of things! We got enough rockers and quite frankly winning might just hurt Cooks career. I am a chick from the 70's and appreciate rock as much as the next guy but I certainly have taste and can appreciate great vocal talent. David A is a winner. It's just some of you voters that are losers. Get a life.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Steve, Denver, CO — Wed, 21 May 2008 20:10:36 GMT

David A. and David C. are completely different in style - that's the key here. Both are very good, both have great voices and incredible potential. They will never compete for the same market share. David C. is older and therefore more seasoned in many ways, not only as a performer - even though David A. has been "performing" for years in various competitions. The main problem with David A. is his father's micro-management and obsession with his son's success. I really feel sorry for David A. because of that. Would he be where he is today without his father? Maybe not, but I just hate stories like this (remember Jean Benet Ramsey). I sort of feel that David A. has been forced to be so focused on singing that he has never been allowed to be a kid and hasn't developed many social skills. If you watch him closely, he becomes a completely different person when he is singing. He appears to be very outgoing and confident when he is singing, but reverts back to a shy introvert when he is not singing. He lacks that self confidence in his everyday life. Unlike Melinda D. his humility is not fake, it is very genuine. I really think he is overwhelmed by it all. At first I thought it was cute, and now I feel sorry for him. I think his father should spend a little more time helping overcome this if the boy has a chance at being as successful as he could be. I think David will win, but if not and David wins, I will be so OK with it - at least this year the two most deserving got to the finals.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Rebecca F. — Wed, 21 May 2008 20:13:00 GMT

Theres one thing I want to say to Taz...

If someone close to you was dying Im sure you'd have tears in your eyes as well. I listened to David Cook sing The World I Know and got tears in my eyes before he did. You have to lose someone to know the feeling.

As for who the better singer is- well Archuleta may have powerful pipes but he is NOT a good performer. The only song he changed up was the one his daddy made him. (Sean Kingston)
I will buy David Cooks CD before I buy Archuletas.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Cilla Ann, TN — Wed, 21 May 2008 20:13:03 GMT

Although I am a DC fan, I will be ok if he doesn't win ONLY because it will be better for him in the long run. I don't want to see him tied down by someone else's rules if he wins. But if this is about talent, DC has been the obvious choice for weeks!! He is the whole package!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Lizzy , Tampa — Wed, 21 May 2008 20:18:41 GMT

If you check the sites which predict the totals of calls & text messages it looks like David C. wins.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Katie, Longmont, CO — Wed, 21 May 2008 20:22:14 GMT

I am happy it was the "Davids" in the final because this time we can say the two best talents made it to the end. I really thought David C would be "Cookin'" last night and turn in the stellar performances he is more than capable of but he didn't. Why? Honestly, I wonder if he wants to win. He gets to have much more control over his career if he DOESN'T win. David A showed up ready to win. What an incredible talent. The inflections and tone of his voice is probably the best I've heard all 7 seasons. He beat Cook last night and as in many other competitions, it is only your last performance anyone remembers. I love both rock and ballads and will buy both CD's. I just wanted the more mature (David C) person to win because I don't think David A can handle it right now. He's young and his Dad is a control freak. However, he kicked Cook's butt last night and will win season 7.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Theresa, British Columbia — Wed, 21 May 2008 20:22:47 GMT

David Cook has a very sexy voice. I would pay $ to see him perform/ buy his his cd. He will win AI and go on to great things. Go DC! David A. - good luck in Disneyland.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Pat, Bensalem, PA — Wed, 21 May 2008 20:22:53 GMT

Archuleta better hope he wins. David C has a career no matter what. If Archeleta doesn't win, he'll be as memorable as "Blake Who?"

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Deborah A - Cheyenney, WY — Wed, 21 May 2008 20:38:35 GMT

David Cook is the more versatile of the 2 David's. He can take any genre and make it feel fresh and new. It didn't matter if it was a up tempo or slow tempo #, David C always delivered. David A, has a beautiful and pure voice, but he did not consisitently deliver in every genre thrown his way. David C is the winner in my mind & I don't care what the rest of America thinks. He has the potential to pull it out like Chris Daughtry did a couple seasons ago and I would buy anything he puts out in a heartbeat.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Jackie Rosenow, St.Louis, MO — Wed, 21 May 2008 21:11:04 GMT

David Cook should win simply because he is the better performer. I agree with the comment by Heather who asked "who would buy a CD by David A."? I know for a fact that I would not and believe that most other people would not buy it either. Case closed.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

B Torro Daly City, CA — Wed, 21 May 2008 21:16:17 GMT

Give David Archuleta his own Disney show already!
"American Idol" he is not.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Go David C, Virgina — Wed, 21 May 2008 21:19:18 GMT

David Cook has the edgy voice and I think he will go far. If you like only ballads or choir boy type songs, then Archie is your person. Nothing against him, I think he is young and has a wonderful voice. David C is better and I prefer to listen to him even if he is off key at times!

Personally, I liked the version that David C did on the Collective Soul song. If I wanted Karaoke or a song to sound exactly like the band that sang it, I would have put my CD in or gone to a bar!

Daughtry had it right...I am sure everyone knows what I am talking about.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Ms. Puddy , Seattle, WA — Wed, 21 May 2008 21:25:47 GMT

Everyone it does not matter who will win. Both of them have record deals in the works and both will have successful careers. Each have found their fan base.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Lauren, IL — Wed, 21 May 2008 21:28:15 GMT

David Cook should win hands down! He has been so amazing all season. He has such a talent for making songs his own. He made his own arrangement for Dolly Parton's 'Little Sparrow'! Neil Diamond also told him that he got chills when he listened to him sing HIS song! He can sing any type of music and sound great. 'Always Be My Baby' and 'I Don't Want to Miss a Thing' left me speechless. I'd like to see Archuleta try to hit those notes! hahaha David Cook has rockstar written all over him and will do great no matter what happens tonight. Daughtry is a great example of that. I just home Cook wins to show that this is a talent competition instead of a popularity contest...

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Deb S, Broomall, Pa. — Wed, 21 May 2008 21:40:17 GMT

I was somewhat shocked by the judges myself. They are both great singers, but Cook can do so much more with any song, which Archuleta can not do. In the end, he will be the one to sell out concerts and I will be the first one to by his CD.

About the tears, I really don't think it had anything to do with the way things were going with the judges. He has had a tough time, especially with his brother having cancer. He was suppose to be there last night and I did not see them focus in on his family. I was actually worried something happened.

Cook goes outside the box and that is exactly what the judges all loved about him. He was the whole package.

If he does not win tonight, I will find it hard to watch Idol next year.

I tried voting for 2 hours and could not get through at all.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Janice, MN — Wed, 21 May 2008 21:52:45 GMT

I'm going for David Cook all the way. He is by far the more diverse and talented of the two. David A. has a pure voice and sings very well, but has no presence otherwise. He is young, and hopefully that will come as he gets older. But the AMERICAN IDOL should have the whole package!
GO DAVID COOK!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

2 taggs in MT — Wed, 21 May 2008 21:55:49 GMT

David Cook all the way! David A is a very good singer but David C has the whole star 'thang' happening. Im sure both will be successful but I truly hope David Cook wins.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Lisa El Paso Tx. — Wed, 21 May 2008 22:03:28 GMT

You know what. I have watched AI every year. It is very intertaning to me. I have a fave always including this year. Sometimes they win sometimes they don't. Even if mine dose not I will always watch. It is great for these artist that might not get a chance other wise. I agree it does not matter who wins. They got thier chance to shine. Its up to them to keep on shining.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Connie, Ca — Wed, 21 May 2008 22:04:50 GMT

I have it, it should be a tie and American Idol would make the most money ever. Think about it. They have different audiences who love them and why not give them each their choice. This would be history making. Both of the David's are spectacular and should be the winner. Neither one is better because they are so different.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Nina Epperson, Blue Springs, MO — Wed, 21 May 2008 22:26:12 GMT

I am from David Cook's hometown of Blue Springs, MO. I have done a lot of soul searching since last nights performances and I honestly believe DAVID COOK is by far the better musician, entertainer and artist. Everyone in B.S. MO has their fingers crossed!!!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Tommy, Indianapolis, IN — Wed, 21 May 2008 22:37:18 GMT

I really liked both David's all season. Cook wins hands down on originality. Archuleta has the purest voice and was consistent. I hope David Archuleta wins because I know David Cook will have a career regardless of the win. I would buy music from both of them.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Kim, Louisiana — Wed, 21 May 2008 23:04:11 GMT

David Cook for me! While David A sings very well, he's too inexperienced and if I have to see the "I'm about to cry crap" from him again - come on, if he's about to pee his pants on this show, what's going to happen if he wins. Also, a vote for David A is a vote for his father and family - he's already been supporting them as no adult in that family actually has a job besides Dad being paid to be his manager - I have real problems with that whether you're David A's dad or someone else's Dad. Get your own job, support yourself and your own family. That's why David A is so emotional and wants to win so bad, his family needs the money to support them - how sad...

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Jennifer, Niagara Falls, NY — Wed, 21 May 2008 23:15:00 GMT

To Taz from Texas...the reason David Cook teared up is because his brother Adam was in the crowd. His brother is, as most know, dying from Brain Cancer.

I find your comment really rude.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Cook, WA State — Wed, 21 May 2008 23:31:35 GMT

Ok, David A is a minor, right? In the past years the judges always gave the young contestants the speeches about how they could in no way be ready for this experience. That they are not old enough to handle this, etc. Where was that this season? I noticed that early on. Out of the two David's, I think think it should go to Cook. Age aside, he is truly a better singer. I think someone mentioned it in a previous thread, he sticks to pop ballads, he really hasn't stuck his neck out. David Cook said it last night when I believe it was Simon who made a comment on a poor song choice because no one knew it. Davis said he wanted to do something new, sing something that he hadn't sung on the contest yet. Well said David Cook!! Good Luck tonight!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

erin, california — Wed, 21 May 2008 23:45:17 GMT

It has only been 24 hours since the show but I do believe its not called “America’s Best Singer”, it is American IDOL. What does the word idol mean? Its funny that Webster uses these words: pretender, imposter, and my personal favorite “a form or appearance visible but without substance”. So then certainly little Archie, whose cheeks may be cuddly, but whose dad arranges songs for him that I doubt he could say one word as to their meaning, could be an idol. After all Paula praised Cook for “standing in his truth” and singing with “integrity”. So if Mr. Merriam Webster knows it, then I guess the teenies and grannies will get their empty idol. But if I were to personally choose an idol, and I am an American I will say, I much prefer the old “someone the ladies wanna be with, and the men wish they could be”. I’m not sure many men wish they could close their eyes, give their lips a lick, and belt Elton with perfect pitch. And I’m pretty sure it’s against the law to date a child. But your right, age aside, I prefer Paula’s reference. Someone in another comment said we should choose an Idol to which America can be proud. I’d find much more pride in this being someone who is timeless, has integrity, is honest, interesting, never boring, always new, caring and kind, a man of his word and honor, and can at least think for himself. I’d worship Cook if he won.

But I’ll still worship him even if he doesn’t.
Guess that makes him the REAL idol :)

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Shelley, AZ — Wed, 21 May 2008 23:50:15 GMT

How can anyone seriously think that Archie should be the person named as AMERICAN IDOL??? This american wouldn't buy his mushy crap nor would I pay money to see him live. He can sing, but he has one style, a style that plays at night, on the love song station, where people dedicate songs to other people and cry alone in the dark. I voted non stop last night for Cook because he is the one that I watched every week to see what he was going to do, not Archie, he did the same old stuff every time. For those people that keep saying Archie will grow as a performer, maybe, but we need an AI NOW not 5 years from now, we need someone who can release something NOW!!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Greg Goff — Thu, 22 May 2008 00:26:14 GMT

Wow! it is amazing to me that people can't see a fake when David Archuleta starts boo-hooing. "Thank you, thank you..." It looked totally scripted by Daddy!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

RJones Dallas, TX — Thu, 22 May 2008 01:27:42 GMT

I honestly feel David should win. If it truly a singing competition. David C in all of his songs last night went flat numerous times. He has an Ok voice not any where near the quality has David A. Simon was on the money with his remarks and you people voting for David C must be tone deaf!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Jo, Yakima, WA — Thu, 22 May 2008 01:34:55 GMT

I love David Cook and I think he's the better performer, but I'm hoping Archuletta wins, for two reasons:

1) My friends and I make brackets at the start of the season and I have him picked to win

2) David Cook will make a much better album if he comes in second than he will if he's bound to the AI contract for the winner.

I did think Archuletta was better last night, but Dial Idol has Cook winning.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

katie s, newyork, newyork — Thu, 22 May 2008 01:51:27 GMT

honestly as much as one of you guys think David A is better or David C is better, they both are amazing. I really have no idea whos going to win. Sometimes i think hey David A did really amazing than bam David C does just as good. They both equally deserve it, its just going to be determinded on whos got the most dedicated fans to vote numerous times.

personally iv'e liked David A from the beginning since he did "Imagine" but when David C did "Always Be My Baby" during the Mariah Carey he really shinned.

its going to be interesting thats for sure.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

RMW — Thu, 22 May 2008 01:52:48 GMT

It's all ARCHIE-BOY!!!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

tommy — Thu, 22 May 2008 02:12:51 GMT

Wow!! Not who I expected to win, but both are excellent talent for different reasons. I will buy both their CD's as I don't have just one favorite type of music I listen to. Way to go Davids!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

John Paul, San Diego, CA — Thu, 22 May 2008 02:16:17 GMT

Obviously, yet again, another year where the American Idol winner isn't the most talented of the two finalists. Another popularity contest with the raspy talentless poser being favored. He'll have a career reminiscent of Taylor Hicks, and nobody will remember his name in a year or two. Obviously, too many young horny girls with cell phones in the world. Not a contest based on talent, this has become a painful undeniable fact.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Dan, Oakdale, Mn — Thu, 22 May 2008 02:16:52 GMT

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Dan, Oakdale, Mn — Thu, 22 May 2008 02:16:58 GMT

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Jeremiah, Chicago, IL — Thu, 22 May 2008 02:21:01 GMT

He won by 12 million votes?!?! Wow!! There cannot be that many deaf or tasteless people in the world. ROFLMAO That's the funniest thing since I heard Obama might be President.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Bqqkn — Thu, 22 May 2008 02:33:46 GMT

Way to go DC!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Julie, Appleton, WI — Thu, 22 May 2008 02:45:25 GMT

I prefer David Archeleta over David Cook and would never buy one of David Cook's cds. He changes things up too much and half the time they're so changed up, you can hardly understand the melody to the song cos he's just screaming

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

sherri, amsterdam ny — Thu, 22 May 2008 02:52:02 GMT

Congratulations to the best Idol! Cook rocks the stage EVERY TIME!! I am so happy he won. In all seven seasons of this show, this is the first one I've ever watched. And because America FINALLY got it right, I will watch again next season. One thing I like about this show is that it exposes talent that we may not otherwise see. D.A. is also a very good singer, but Cook deserved this win hands down.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Mary - Mesa, AZ — Thu, 22 May 2008 02:58:29 GMT

Oh please - Gloria Derby Ks! I also enjoy David Cook's performances much more than David A's and am hoping that Cook will win. But PLEASE don't compare the young Archuleta with his moderate talent to Josh Groban. Groban is indeed an amazing talent that is much more of a complete performer than any American Idol who has won in the past or will win in the future. Take a little time to listen to Josh Groban to see for yourself the reason why he has tens of thousands of fans around the globe and sells out his concerts worldwide. Know what you're talking about before speaking. I do agree with you, however, that with Archuleta's nice voice and looks he would make a great addition to a Disney movie or Disney channel show. GO DAVID COOK!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Maria, TX — Thu, 22 May 2008 03:51:56 GMT

I'm thrilled that Simon's reverse psychology worked on AI voters. Everyone remembers how much he praised Carly Smithson then she got booted the next night. I'm sure he knew praising David Cook would mean he didn't get the Idol he wanted, so he laid the praise on thick with David Archuleta. Thanks Simon for giving us an American Idol I won't be embarrassed to admit that I like.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Rosie, Jamestown, New York — Thu, 22 May 2008 04:42:12 GMT

I told my son last night that I thought Simon used reverse psychology and it might help David Cook. I am thinking that is exactly what he did! Simon looked EXTREMELY happy when he was announced as the winner! In my book, Simon is always right on!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

beth — Thu, 22 May 2008 05:00:30 GMT

Congrats to David Cook! Lil David is OK, he's got a great voice and will do well on Broadway as he matures. however, he is not an "Idol". Cook is.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Rosie Wuerl, Peachtree City, Ga. — Thu, 22 May 2008 05:10:34 GMT

No doubt both Davids will have a sucessful career. I said all along David C was a performer and would win Idol. I loved all of the songs on Tuesday night. David A did give me chills when he sang his ballads. That's what slow weepy songs do, they make you want to cry. David C was a showman and has range. I can't wait for David C to come out with an album. I'm buying. Rosie W. Peachtree City, Ga.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

no more idol, Douglas, WY — Thu, 22 May 2008 05:48:11 GMT

After the finale tonight I'm finished watching Idol. All of this puts money in Simon's pocket--and, yes, all of the judges already knew who would win and manipulated the show. The judges shouldn't make comments during the final week--David A has an unbelievable voice and deserved to win. David C is a bad actor and typical rocker with really nothing special. Again, Idol continues to decrease in popularity and this was a ploy to attract mindless viewers. David A, you were a pawn but no one can take away that heavenly voice! Grow and learn and cash in; that way Simon won't profit!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Roshini Roy, Pune, India — Thu, 22 May 2008 06:55:34 GMT

Yippie :) I'm so glad for David Cook, and yup, I wouldn't buy an Archuleta CD anyway!!! Thanks a million to everyone who voted for Mr. Cook :)

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Robin Bishop,Honokaa, HI — Thu, 22 May 2008 07:08:24 GMT

Cook used his guitar as a prop. He is not a player.

Too many voters prefer the bad boy image.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Dan,WI — Thu, 22 May 2008 07:59:25 GMT

"Maybe the reason the youngsters aren't watching the show as much these days is because there's not much they can relate to musically, since the guest stars and themes are from their parents' and grandparents' day."

This is so true,my mother who's in her 70's watches the show.My daughter 14 years old won't watch.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

miron — Thu, 22 May 2008 08:53:53 GMT

I don't give much about the trophy in the last round. David Cook showed the best he's got, Artuleta did so too. It was a huge step up for Cook, Artuleta on the other hand is far more mature as a singer and professional. He just a bit younger as a person and he did not seek some way to show off his mastery. It might haunt him for an hour or two. The important thing is what is going to happen a year, two, three, or five down the road. If anything I understood of Artuleta he is got character and he loves music. I want to see a golden disk by Artuleta, and if he puts one out, I certainly will not wait for a long to buy one.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Mike Yakima Washington — Thu, 22 May 2008 09:31:29 GMT

Well Well Well, Looks like the true talent won out! Cook has chrisma Archuleta doesn't. Cook can sing almost any type of song Archulets can't. 12 million can't be wrong.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Linda, Missouri — Thu, 22 May 2008 11:00:13 GMT

After watching the show all season and listening to the judges heap praise on David Archuleta after each performance, I felt like they were "cramming" him down our throats as the crowned winner already. He is very talented and will go far, if his dad quits sheltering him and sets him free. Very handsome, but he lacks maturity and needs coaching on his mannerisms to be a "star".

I think the judges, especially Simon, were too partial Tuesday night, thus everyone decided they had had enough already and went to David Cook's aide. He was the true artist of the two and deserved the win. He was just as surprised as everyone that he had won.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Howard Hainley Schuylkill Haven, PA — Thu, 22 May 2008 12:12:02 GMT

All persons who voted for David Cook have very poor taste when it comes to their choice of music. What he produces is "noise". David Archuleta is and always will be far superior to Cook! I am so disgusted with the outcome! I'll never again let myself become involved in this stupid show again!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Also, Cook displayed an arrogant,smug demeanor throughout the entire competition. How could voters turn their backs on a truly genuine and sincere performer like David Archuleta??? It proves beyond doubt many people lack the ability to choose a true peformer over an egotistical,self indulgent one. Cook rocks??? Not!!!!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Sherrie Christensen (Sandy, Utah) — Thu, 22 May 2008 13:03:33 GMT

I don't understand all the negative comments about singing ballads. One reference to Josh Grobin as if it were an insult. J.G.'s album last year was the highest selling on Billboard's chart, what's insulting about that? David A could do a lot worse. And as far as all songs sounding alike, David C.'s songs all sounded alike to me. I certainly didn't find that more interesting than someone who could belt out a love song and make people cry. OK, so D.A. needs more training on stage presence, etc. but I sometimes felt the same way about D.C. Never mind, they will both get LOTS of grooming and training from their new record labels, whichever of Simon Fuller's companies they sign with. Both are under contract as finalists on the show to sign with Simon Fuller, so the "loser" doesn't have as much freedom as we are led to believe, he just doesn't have the title of American Idol.
P.S. I agree that the show did NOT need to be two hours long, and I certainly could have done without the Mike Myers nonsense, among others.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Sue, Clifton, NJ — Thu, 22 May 2008 13:08:51 GMT

Archuleta has a smooth silky voice suited for ballads & maybe pop but Cook has that voice that would sound great in all kinds of music. & i loved how he did The World I Know--great song choice,great haunting poignant lyrics,perfect for his voice--it's been on my ipod long before he sang it. maybe the judges don't really know it well--there are lots of good not-so-popular music out there. great job David Cook!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Donna, Tupelo, MS — Thu, 22 May 2008 13:09:22 GMT

It's no mystery why David Cook won. David Archuleta is a cute youg kid who can sing. David Cook is a HOT, SEXY, ROCK STAR!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

angel — Thu, 22 May 2008 13:17:57 GMT

I don't quite understand why everyone is so resentful of the guy they didn't vote for. This was the first year that I felt that either of the final two was a great choice and they were both so genuine and adorable. They seems close to each other as well and they finale clearly showed that these two repected and cared for each other. Cook was very generous at the end of the show and everyone united around him. I really don't think anything can stop either one of these boys from having a successfful career. I bet we see a couple of the other top 10 again too. I enjoy American Idol and I thought that this season was the best. I also think that many of you fail to understand the way the baton gets passed in the music business. While some of the mentoring isn't the best, it's a great nod from the legends on the viabilty of this new young talent. Many of them have found their niche by working with the legends. All that is old becomes new again. All of these young ones have been influenced by someone from the past. I have a 21 year old son who is a musician and relies on the old guys for his inspiration. He calls a lot of new music fraudulent. My 18 year old daughter regularly listens to Frank Sinatra. While the kids are the future and I am wildly supportive of that concept, I still know that the future is meaningless without the past. It combines to create the present. All the great music from the 40s through the 90s have melded to become the music of today. Get used to it!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Lisa, Ontario, Canada — Thu, 22 May 2008 14:21:40 GMT

Congratulations David Cook! A well deserved win! While I think that young Archie has a lot of talent and we will be hearing more from him in the future, I did not think that it was his time . David Cook is primed and ready to go out and make records. His presence on the stage makes you want to go and see him live. I can't say the same for Archie. I think David Cook is a much more versatile performer and has a lot of musical talent above and beyond his singing. His own arrangements of well known favorites were amazing and breathed new life back into these older tunes. He is a very well rounded performer and I am glad that America recognized it and named him the new American Idol!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Bud Terryberry — Thu, 22 May 2008 15:33:34 GMT

Well, wasn't that interesting! I really think that they messed up last year with Chris Doughtry and this year the same kind of singer won. Doughtry is amazing and very determined, we will see What david A will do now, i think Disney might be his best option, it has worked for the Jonas Brothers!!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Edith Meyers — Thu, 22 May 2008 15:41:47 GMT

I felt that David A was robbed. He pulled out all the stops Tuesday night and engaged his audience. Cook was flat. David A is a cross between Judy Garland and Eddie Fisher. David A has mega star potential - and will transend time. Cook is just another rocker with dirty jeans and chains and will fade out. As a tv producer, I would take David A any day, he can sing, he can do movies, he can do Los Vegas, Broadway - his capacity is unlimited.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Elaine Listenes — Thu, 22 May 2008 15:56:22 GMT

Congratulations David Cook!!!!!
David Archuletta has a beautiful voice, but will not come into his own until he matures. David Cook is ready now!!! I wish all good things for David Cook and his family!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Monica Edwards Peru, Illinois — Thu, 22 May 2008 15:56:38 GMT

David Cook rocks!!!!! I have loved him from day one. I grew up with all sorts of music in my household and that rocker style of his wins hands down. Congratulations to you!!! I will be first in line to by Cook's CD.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Linda G. Reynolds — Thu, 22 May 2008 16:37:42 GMT

I think both David's were awesome. I think the right one won but David A. will go far also. I think he felt safe with all the ballards and David Cook is a rocker. I love the dueo's from last night and the
David Cook & ZZ Top performance was great. No need to make cruel comments about the performers. They were the two left standing during AI!!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

BJ Oklahoma City — Thu, 22 May 2008 16:50:49 GMT

I like both but I adore David Archuleta. He has an amazing gift which I believe God has a plan for. SO don't count him out. I love the ballads..thats just me and I will definately buy his cd's whether its pop, or even christian music. He is amazing. But I believe Simon was playing with him...Why else was the numbers so different. But then again..Do they really count the votes. I figure they know what they want and thats who they will get...in the end. I wish both David's the best but I am real concerned with what songs they will give him David Cook to sing on his first CDl, hopefully it won't be another Taylor Hicks. But if they market Archie correctly he will take the teen scene by storm..come on Miley and the Jonas brothers are taking the scene by storm and I think they are great but Archie is amazing he just has something so special about him.. Hey Clive Davis, he could be the male Whitney Houston if you market him right. David Cook though could never replace Chris Daughtry...awesome...But then look at Michael Johns and Carly Smithson were they stars last night together or what they were awesome...

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Molly, Kansas City, KS — Thu, 22 May 2008 16:57:10 GMT

David Cook is no Daughtry Lite!! Chris and David are 2 different artists. Can't wait to buy his first album! He was fantastic and the audience knew it. Too bad the judges had their own agenda.

David C. makes Kansas City proud!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

jeremy A SIOUX ,FALLS S.D — Thu, 22 May 2008 17:45:42 GMT

i think the only reason david cook won was because of sex appeal because the show is called american idol not american's best singer because we all know that david archuleta is a way better singer but it all works out for a reason chris daughtry didnt win and look at him now

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Stacey, Santaquin Utah — Thu, 22 May 2008 18:38:41 GMT

I am a huge David Cook fan!! I was really afraid that David A would take the win. He had all the little girls as fans and they sure do know how to text message!! I am so glad that America could see the true amazing talent of David Cook. It was a really great season this year and I am happy to see that David C got what he really deserved!!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Debra, Tucson, AZ — Thu, 22 May 2008 18:58:30 GMT

Finally an Idol show where I'm happy if either one of the finalists won. I was happy for Chris Daughtry losing. I thought he was clearly meant for stardom and didn't want him stuck. I think the same thing will happen for David Archuletta. He has an amazing voice, timing and vision for what a song can be. The final performances showed he can really change it up and do popular music instead of just balads. Congratulations to both David's!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

A 70 year young grandma, Miami, Florida — Thu, 22 May 2008 20:01:31 GMT

No question. David Cook is an all-around singer, whereas David A. is just another cute balladier. Not to mention the enormous sex appeal that DCook exudes, which is a great part of his stage personna. David Cook IS the obvious choice for American Idol. And yes, I'd go see him any time.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

A 70 year young grandma, Miami, Florida — Thu, 22 May 2008 20:02:11 GMT

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Suzanne, Columbia, SC — Thu, 22 May 2008 20:17:49 GMT

Exactly... Every season, the judges tell every contestant the same thing: To take the songs and make them their own by putting their own creative spin on them. Since day 1, David Cook has done exactly this, proving that he make songs by Roberta Flack and Mariah Carey into modern hits that the judges say could be on the radio now. David Archuletta, while he does have an extraordinary voice, has performed one ballad after another. The one time he tried to venture out of his comfort zone by singing Chris Brown's "With You," he failed miserably. Instead, he stuck with songs that he has been performing in public for years. Of course they sound great; it's the same stuff he sings all the time. David Cook is the real musician, having not only a great voice and great stage presence, but also the creative genius and ability to sing anything well. I'm glad America voted for the real musician, as opposed to feeding into the judges' hype over Archuletta. Congrats David Cook!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Angela — Thu, 22 May 2008 20:21:27 GMT

I thought both David's were phenomenal! They are very talented and I'm sure they will both be successful. I was surprised however that DC won by such a large margin.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

M.E. Martinez, Austin,TX — Thu, 22 May 2008 20:54:57 GMT

I like both singers. I wish David A had won. No matter. He's a winner in my book. Many say he is a teeny-bopper singer or sappy ballads singer, but I'm 54 and love his voice. Like Randy J. would often tell them, David A. can sing the phone book and it would sound great. I can't wait for David A.'s album to come out. I will buy it in a heartbeat. He is only going to get better in time and with a great manager. Look out America!

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Chuck, Pacific Grove, CA. — Thu, 22 May 2008 22:42:43 GMT

If this was a singing contest, as the panel has often said, then David A. was far and away the best of the two Davids. David A. is young and has not developed a relaxed stage presence and poise and ease in interacting with the panel, interviewer and audience. David C. is older which allows him the opportunity to be more versatile. That said, David A. has the best singing voice and on that basis should have won.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Lynn, Canton, GA — Fri, 23 May 2008 00:28:19 GMT

Ok, David Archuleta did not sing ballads on purpose. The final 3 performance was rigged. According to David A.'s voice coach in a Fox interview, David a. picked "I don't want to miss a thing" Aerosmith's rock song and the producers came and told him he was not going to sing that and gave it Cook instead. Also, on "Longer" David A. rehearsed an upbeat tempo for that and the producers came in on that rehearsal and told him he was to sing it slower. So, there you go. The producers set it up for David Archuleta to become boring. Don't ever criticize David A. for that. He was set up. So, he was not allowed to take his chances and American idol did that to him.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Roshini Roy, Pune, India — Tue, 27 May 2008 09:30:20 GMT

I liked Kelly, our first American Idol... after that it sort of went into a decline, Ruben, Fantasia, Carrie, Taylor (what were they thinking!!!), Jordin, etc. Now it is back on track. Mr. Cook got lucky when Michael Johns went home. Anyway, from the rest, Cook was the best :) And to all who say that Cook is not talented as Archuleta, at least not enough to be the AI7, the same argument applies to Archuleta. And anyway, we will find out who has the star power to last, so all the best to them :)

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Sam Lim, Seattle, Washington — Sun, 01 Jun 2008 00:58:11 GMT

Simon Cowell when he predict its always a kiss of death remember with Carly Smithson. Everytime Simon Cowell open his mouth people go against him there is a reason why people go against him - I will leave it up to you why. Plus at the early stage they already crowned David Archuleta the one to beat. The Kid himself predicted that this already a curse - that he won't win but he still try to do his best. On the Finale, majority of America expected David Archuleta to WIN for he really gave his all and its obvious he nailed it and David Cook admitted that. That's why until now even though American Idol is already over its still being talked about on what happened for a lot of people don't believe on the 12 million votes nobody does. Now, my prediction next season American Idol rating will dramatically drop - a lot of people lost interest in this show they lack integrity and there is so much controversy - this season they used David Archuleta - Dad to drum up the rating. AI can deny that but its the way how I see it. I am done with American Idol and lot of people does, I think. I did watch it because of David Archuleta. Good Luck for the next season and I hope I'm wrong.

David vs. David: Is Simon using reverse psychology?

Sam Lim, Seattle, Washington — Sun, 01 Jun 2008 01:00:08 GMT

I forgot to say: David Archuleta is THE BEST THING EVER HAPPENED TO AMERICAN IDOL.